Talk

Advanced search

To think 8 stone at 5'4 isn't that slim

(330 Posts)
Hadbetterdays Sat 18-Jun-16 11:54:36

I am that weight and height and I often get people telling me how skinny I look and that I need to gain weight.

EatShitDerek Sat 18-Jun-16 11:56:06

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

NeedACleverNN Sat 18-Jun-16 11:56:34

No.

I'm 5ft 3" and I weigh 6stone 3 pounds

Inyournightdress Sat 18-Jun-16 11:57:53

Well it would mean you bmi was in the healthy weight range. Bottom of the healthy range but healthy none the less.

Drbint Sat 18-Jun-16 11:57:56

Duh, it depends on your build, muscle etc

Your problem is people being rude,

TheUnsullied Sat 18-Jun-16 11:58:36

It is slim though.

Is this going to be one of those threads where people out-skinny each other?

Mellowautumn Sat 18-Jun-16 11:58:43

Errrrh do you have a history of eating disorders or similar body dismorphic issues? If not can I really really suggest to vist your GP and ask them about heathy body weights and I'm sure you will be reassured and perhaps get any help you might need.

hootatoot Sat 18-Jun-16 11:59:00

It depends on your build I suppose. I'm 5'2" and the lightest I've been as an adult is 8st 10 which made me a small size 8 (always a 12 previously) and had ppl tell me I was too skinny and they were worried about me. The top and bottom is that you can't win. Someone always has an opinion on us! If you're happy and healthy, ignore them.

formerbabe Sat 18-Jun-16 11:59:04

I'm 5'2 and wore size 10 jeans at 9 stone so yes I'd say 8 stone at 5'4" would be quite slim.

MaidOfStars Sat 18-Jun-16 11:59:47

I'm the same height and weight, OP. I'm pear-shared though, so rarely get called 'skinny'. I get a lot of 'don't lose anymore', which gives me the rage.

Aeroflotgirl Sat 18-Jun-16 11:59:55

It is quite slim, am trying that height and 10,5 stone

AGruffaloCrumble Sat 18-Jun-16 12:01:37

YABU.
I'm 5"4 and when I am 8st I am a size at best. I would consider it slim but it all depends on personal build. At 8st I look gaunt.

fuctifino Sat 18-Jun-16 12:01:51

I'd look pretty poorly at that weight, I am 5'5" and 10st 6lbs, a size 10.

ifyoulikepinacolada Sat 18-Jun-16 12:02:00

Have you always been this size? How much energy do you have day to day? Do you exercise? Do you watch what you eat or feel stressed going to social events where the food will be out of your control?

8 stone is very slim for 5"4 - but I can't tell from your post whether you've always been healthy and wish people would butt out, or whether this is a recent loss and you can't see how far it's gone, or any of a million other possibilities iyswim!

stopgap Sat 18-Jun-16 12:02:12

I think it's slim, but not worryingly so.

I'm 5'7.5 and 8 stone 10lbs, and still have a bum and 34C boobs. I am really narrow in the hips and have skinny legs that, in spite of weight lifting, are still thin. People say I'm slim but no-one has ever described me as way too thin or urged me to gain weight.

cosytoaster Sat 18-Jun-16 12:02:13

It definitely is slim, but not to the extent that you should need to gain weight.

cardibach Sat 18-Jun-16 12:02:48

Need I think BMI is a bit rubbish for individuals, but your weight and height out you as seriously underweight on that system. I know there are outliers where the BMI doesn't reflect health, but I think you suggesting someone isn't slim because they aren't as light as you is dangerous nonsense. You may be healthy at that weight (I don't know) but the vast majority wouldn't. The OPs weight and height put her in the bottom bit of healthy BMI, so I think she probably is slim. Best health outcomes are in the overweight range, incidentally m possibly because BMI recommendations were randomly altered downwards after they were introduced...

AGruffaloCrumble Sat 18-Jun-16 12:02:56

Need
So your BMI is only 15? I would consider that dangerously underweight.

HahahahaFuckYou Sat 18-Jun-16 12:03:23

It's slim but not 'skinny'
I'm 5'6 and 7stone 5 but look pretty healthy.

NapoleonsNose Sat 18-Jun-16 12:03:24

I'm 5'3" and the lightest I've been as an adult is 10.2 - I was a 10/12 - I do have enormous norks though! People were telling me then I'd lost too much weight. I guess it depends on how you're built to a certain extent.

Hadbetterdays Sat 18-Jun-16 12:03:37

I've always been this size. I have a healthy diet where I allow myself treats and walk quite a lot.

It's slim but not skinny. If you stayed that weight as you got older then you might start to look a bit gaunt, and there is an argument that women's ideal healthy weight range gets a bit higher as they get older - but it's really hard to prove for certain where the cause and effect lie.

Janeymoo50 Sat 18-Jun-16 12:04:56

I was that once (long ago). People often commented on my slimness, looking at photos now I looked gaunt actually and my size 10 work skirt swivelled around my waist. I looked better when I had actually put on a few pounds.

PortiaCastis Sat 18-Jun-16 12:05:50

Why does it matter ?

ReginaBlitz Sat 18-Jun-16 12:06:36

Agree with poster up thread about a thread out skinnying. It depends on body shape etc there is no right and wrong. I'm 5.2 and when I was 8.5 I looked like a smack head tbf and haggered.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now