My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

AIBU?

to think this MP's comments are outrageous?

38 replies

SashimiStevens · 28/02/2016 18:32

London MP Dawn Butler has said she was a victim of racism when a fellow MP assumed she was a cleaner.

www.independent.co.uk/news/people/black-mp-dawn-butler-reveals-she-was-victim-of-racism-in-parliament-after-fellow-mp-assumed-she-was-a6901261.html

In a separate incident in 2008 former senior Tory minister David Heathcote-Amory confronted her in the Members’ section of the terrace.

“He actually said to me, ‘What are you doing here? This is for Members only’,” she wrote. “He then proceeded to ask me, 'Are you a member?' And I said, ‘Yes I am, are you?‘ And he turned around and said to his colleague, ‘They’re letting anybody in nowadays.’ “This man could not equate the image he saw in front of him with that of an MP. It was quite upsetting for my team and so we had to take it further.”

Mr Heathcote-Amory rebuffed the accusation that his remarks were racist.

“It’s quite absurd,” he said. “What she is actually objecting to is that I didn’t recognise her as a new MP. I simply asked her what she was doing at that end of the terrace, and they are quite sensitive about this kind of thing, they think that any kind of reprimand from anyone is racially motivated.”

OP posts:
Report
acasualobserver · 28/02/2016 18:36

Tory.

Report
ItsAllGoingToBeFine · 28/02/2016 18:40

Yup. Tory.

Report
MrsTerryPratchett · 28/02/2016 18:42

‘They’re letting anybody in nowadays.’ Hmm And the use of 'they'. Can't think why anyone would think this racist was a racist.

Report
SashimiStevens · 28/02/2016 18:44

I know. It's such a disgusting way to refer to anyone! What a piece of work Angry

OP posts:
Report
nceccoli · 28/02/2016 18:47

It's absolutely hilarious that in rebuff ingredients any accusation that he is racist, Heathcote -Amory has gone on to display how actually racist he indeed is.

Report
nceccoli · 28/02/2016 18:48

Rebuffing

Report
sugar21 · 28/02/2016 18:48

Yep Tory

Report
BunnyTyler · 28/02/2016 18:53

There are actually black Tories by the way, and non bigoted Tories. Confused

I think the sage nodding and "Yup, Tory" is a bit pathetic to be honest.

Regardless of his political leanings he is a bigoted, racist twat and that is rife across all sections of the population and quite probably not that uncommon across all parties.

Report
caroldecker · 28/02/2016 19:12

Note she refuses to name the Labour MP who assumed she was a cleaner

Report
Tanith · 28/02/2016 19:53

Perhaps the MP who mistook her for a cleaner apologised for their mistake when it was pointed out to them.

Presumably all party MPs are capable of apologising for mistakes, not just Labour ones.

Report
sweetcherrycakes · 28/02/2016 20:06

Agree Bunny

Tory is hardly a synonym for racist Hmm

Report
AdrenalineFudge · 28/02/2016 20:11

Par for the course really.

Report
UnmentionedElephantDildo · 28/02/2016 20:18

Why has this become a story now, 8 years after the events in question?

Report
JoffreyBaratheon · 28/02/2016 20:21

I've been on that terrace - am not an MP nor was the person I was with. Never got stopped or challenged. I'm white, though.

Tory is not a synonym for 'racist' - but TBH those tories who fake being PC never quite convince. Cameron always reminds me of Flashman. He knows the 'right' thing to say and to pretend to believe, but you'd be naive to think he was anything other than a shit when behind closed doors with his old Etonian mates. And anyone who can stay in a political party fronted by that - well they're never going to be nice people, are they? I suspect they're as racist and homophobic as ever - the vast majority of tories. They have just realised the world have moved on and now it's expedient to hide it. Is anyone really taken in by them?

Report
WhiskyTangoFoxtrot · 28/02/2016 20:22

As she didn't name the other MP, nor give details on whether she or he apologised, there's not much we can do other this. Speculate.

But I do think it's worth reminding people that as the Tories have always had about the same number of black MPs as Labour, plus the only Jewish and only female PM, and the highest number of state school educated PMs.

It's easy to castigate the stereotype. But also worth pausing to remember that it's not terribly accurate. Confirmation bias is a snare.

Report
sweetcherrycakes · 28/02/2016 20:23

Do you believe everyone who votes conservative is racist or homophobic Joffrey? Honestly?

Report
caroldecker · 28/02/2016 20:38

It was a Labour council and Unison who conspired to pay men more than women in birmingham and refused to support the court cases initially.
Trade unions also have a long history of racism.

Report
jeremyisahunt · 28/02/2016 21:14

Disgusting behavior. His response sums him up.

I'm glad she has spoken out though. I doubt she's the only one that this kind of thing has happened to.

Report
Gartenzwerg · 28/02/2016 21:25

The irony of some of the previous posts is astounding - professing outrage at one person's bigoted view of black people by demonstrating their own bigoted view of Tories.

Report
MrsTerryPratchett · 28/02/2016 21:31

There is a difference between judging someone on the colour of their skin than on their stated political preference. Not saying that all Tories are racist BTW but that someone's own stated political stance says something about their tolerance to that party's stance on immigration etc.

Report
Chipstick10 · 28/02/2016 21:35

Labour, the kinder politics . Yeah alright

Report
SchnooSchnoo · 28/02/2016 22:55

Well, if there was any doubt about him being a racist before his handy explanation, then there certainly isn't now! What a twat.

Report
PaulAnkaTheDog · 28/02/2016 22:57

And things like this are the reason that the only page I follow on Facebook is 'Nobody likes a Tory'.

Report
Chipstick10 · 29/02/2016 16:22

My son is the kindest, least non judgemental person you could ever wish to meet. I have been told so many times he's a son in a million. No mother could be prouder. He gained a first at uni from sheer hard work and continues everyday to make me proud with his gentle nature . He votes Tory. paulAnka that makes me so sad and angry.

Report
ForalltheSaints · 29/02/2016 16:29

A Tory MP looking down on other people? Whatever next? It may not have been based on race (though I think it could have been, or because Dawn is a woman) but still unacceptable.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.