To think it unfair to blatantly spoil one grandchild over another?(61 Posts)
I have two dcs, one girl, one boy. My mother has always spoiled my first, the girl. When she was born she set up a bank account for her, and regularly deposits significant sums into it. Fast forward five years, and I have a 3 year old son. He has never had an account set up. He does get equal gifts for birthdays and Christmas though. DM mentioned this morning that she must put some more money into dd's account. I casually mentioned, what about dgs? The response was "oh someone else will give him money". I am not sure who...his other grandparents are not flush, but always give them equal amounts anyhow. I told her I would rather she split it between them, and she laughed.
It is her money, obviously. She can do what she wants with it. However I am not sure how I will explain this to my son in years to come. Maybe I should just let him think what he likes of her. But I don't want him to feel hurt.
She clearly doesn't care as I have already pointed it out to her. Any ideas how I should react? She so blatantly shows favouritism, and I don't want my children being a part of that kind of behaviour.
Accept the money. Split it between them when the time comes.
I think you need to tell her straight that if she will not treat them the same then you will not accept anymore gifts/money for your dd.
Thanks. It is not like a trust fund or anything, she plans to spend the money on dd at some point, I won't get to decide what it is spent on so cannot split. A part of me feels like just closing the account or putting ds's name on it too ;) but that might be a bit spiteful.
If you have control of the account I'd certainly close it - you can't be complicit in this! Of course you can't stop her opening her own account for your dd and giving her the money at 16+ but you can insist that her interactions with them up til then are fair and equal.
Thats not OK. I have no idea how to put it right without causing a family meltdown.
You can try reasoning with DD and explain Gran is being unfair so you are asking her to share. Ask her how she would feel if it were the other way around. Leave it for her to manage, she can transfer the money when she is 16 or 18, but it would have to be by her own choice with no pressure.
If she can find it in herself to be the bigger person, your family will be stronger.
But surely if it's a savings account then why would she be 'spending the money on dg later' surely it will be up to dd?
I would say you'll split it between the two or make it a joint account maybe.
I have access and control of my kids accounts. I would set one up for ds, split the money in it 50:50, then transfer 50% of any new deposits into ds account.
If the money is in an account with DD name on it, it is legally her money, it belongs to her.
Your DM is being unreasonable tho!
It is a joint account between my dd and dm. I don't know what her intentions are, she just mentions she is topping it up every so often. There is probably quite a bit of money in there now, I mean over a thousand. I always got the impression from earlier comments that she will use it to do nice things with dd, but she has never actually proposed doing anything in particular. Maybe when she is a teenager, I just don't know.
If I insist on something she will melt down and say I am ungrateful, as she is such a generous gm, and likes to remind us all of this regularly. I could close the account I think, given I am dd's guardian. But that would be a major statement.
I don't think it will be a case of dd just actually getting the cash, so I couldn't even ask her to share it.
I kind of just expected that she would open an account for ds when he arrived, but she never did, and obviously I never suggested she should.
Maybe I should show her this post?! Thanks for the advice! I think she is being really daft actually as ds will just dislike her for the favouritism, but I don't want dd to feel smug being the spoiled one.
Actually to rub salt in the wound, about a year ago I set up an account for my ds in the same bank, and I did mention this to dm, so if she wanted to put money in it she could, easily.
my gran done the same to me and my brother many years ago - she would give me stuff that she wouldn't give to him, things like biscuits and juice but once we got a bit older she started to give me money. it wasn't a lot, maybe £10 every 2 or 3 months but she never gave it to him. I told my parents when it happened and I always gave my brother half of it.
I don't know what I would do if my parents done the same to my kids - part of me thinks its their money they can do with it as they please however part of me thinks they should treat them equally.
sorry ive been no help, just rambled on.
sorry just seen your latest post - once my brother learned what was going on he didn't stop speaking to her but he didn't go out of his way to be with her or speak to her either - he just didn't bother her. She lost out at the end of the day.
Thanks Peggy. It just feels wrong and not a good example to be setting my dd and ds. I sometimes feel like my dm spends her time undoing the good work I am trying to do with my kids...encouraging them in selfish behaviours etc, when she wouldn't have let us away with anything as kids!
A grandparent did this with me and my cousins. We don't speak now because it caused so much bitterness.
Can you ask the bank if they can change it into an account just for your Mum? I would tell her you don't feel comfortable with money for your DD but not your DS. Open an account for your DD that you control, and tell your mum she can put money in that one, but to let her know, you'll split any money put in between both DCs unless the same is put in DSs. If she would rather just pay into one and you sort that, you'll do it.
She might cry, but you can't allow this to continue. If she says she is being generous - say "no, you are only being generous to [DD] - you are being mean to [DS] and when they are older, both will probably think less of you for it. I am giving you the chance to put this right before they will know as I don't think you mean to show favouritism, but if you do mean to show favouritism, I don't want that money for either."
Oh that's vile behaviour op.
Honestly to me my kids getting on together and teaching then to support and share with each other would be more important to me than contact with a grandparent.
So I would tell my mother straight that it stops now. She either treats my children equally or not at all.
Seriously this would be a deal breaker for me.
Your kids need each other much more than they need a selfish devisive gran.
My parents have done the same with presents. They gave be a present to give to DD "just because" i.e. not birthday, Christmas etc. It is in a box in storage because I've refused to give it to her when there is nothing for DS. That did not go down well!
It's the same with their behaviour when they visit, all DD, DD, DD. Totally ignore DS. At least I can give him 1-1 attention then, but it is hard for him.
I think now you have mentioned it and she has blown you off, that you need to be totally clear to her how unacceptable you find it that she would treat your DC differently.
I can't imagine anyone doing this as it is such an abhorrent idea to me to treat childrne differently.
My gran used to bring gifts for me & nothing for my brother - she was a seamstress & used to run up dolls' clothes with scraps - I think because they cost nothing she didn't appreciate the impact. My DB used to ask what she had for him & she'd reply, "Nothing darling"
My DM put her foot down & told her she was to bring something for each of us or nothing at all - even a packet of sweets for my DB would be fine. It changed.
Do your children have different fathers or something that would explain it eg your daughter having no contact with her father's family so your mum feels she and her husband are the only grandparents? Maybe there isn't a husband as you only mention your mother so feeling a child only has 1 grandparent and you are it might explain being overly generous to 1 child. Still seems unfair though.
Dinosaurs and Hiho - what they said.
To me, if you do nothing - you are supporting it. Not easy to tackle I am sure OP - but still needs doing.
oh and long term OP - someone's feelings are going to get hurt - your Mums now, or your DSs (and possibly DDs) in the future. Get it done now.
The money is for your dd. Perhaps your mum is trying to balance the unfairness inherent in society which is blatantly unfair tomgirls/women. Your dd will work as hard as your son and wny other man, yet she will earn less, she will be as qualified and competent as men yet they will be preferred over her for promorion, it goes on and on.
Let your mum do her bit.
My bro was favoured by one grandmother. She gave him fab oresents, money and left him dosh in her Will. I got a pair of tights, beige, for my 8 th birthday. That's the only thing I got from her. Only telling you so you know I know what I'm talking about.
You need to nip this shit in the bud now op, she will be fully aware of what she is doing.
Generous GM or not, she either treats your children equally or doesnt see them at all. Your son won't care now, but in a few years he will be all too aware he's being treated differently. As their mum it's your job to stand up for him now before it's too late.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.