to be quite upset after helping out at DD's school?(75 Posts)
I volunteered to help with the costumes today and I was sitting with the other parents in the infant corridor (it's huge, more like a reception space).
DD's teacher was so shouty You could hear her giving the most unclear instructions and then shouting at the children when they didn't complete the task properly (I think it was a sort of colour by number). She was really so unpleasant to hear, I wouldn't have talked to my dog like that.
The other reception class were painting. They split the classes by age and playground gossip says they are a very young class who need a firm hand but their teacher was so firm in the nicest possible way. Listening to her teach was lovely. She was so clear and actually very strict, but in a really positive and gentle way IYKWIM.
I'm so down about DD being with Mrs Shouty
Then say so to head teacher or write a letter saying what you said here, if you don't how will the teacher know she needs to communicate better and less shouty?
Would I BU to let someone above her know though? I am loath to make a fuss on one day's events.
But then she was terribly unpleasant.
No not unreasonable and I think I'd say something. When I was 7/8 we had a horrible teacher, we would queue up beside her desk and she would call each of us up to look in our books. If she didn't like your work, she would write on it and then throw it on the floor in a temper for us to pick up.(can't remember whether she did it to me ever) I told my mum and I think she said something at parents evening because it didn't happen again. She might not be so quick to shout like that again if she thinks parents are listening.
I helped out a lot at both my children's schools and I have to say 70-80% of what I heard and experienced corresponds with your description. I think keeping 30 Kid's on track is hard and most of the time it's crowd control more than anything else.
No, there's nothing wrong with voicing your concerns. I had a very shouty teacher at school at one point and being a somewhat anxious child, I started suffering a lot of stomach aches and missed a lot of school pretending to be ill to avoid her.
Just be polite, calm and professional about it, give concrete examples of what concerned you, and definitely don't do it anonymously. Parents should feel able to raise concerns such as this in an appropriate manner.
I think keeping 30 Kid's on track is hard and most of the time it's crowd control more than anything else.
I completely understand that! It was her manner, it was so unpleasant.
e.g. Someone did something wrong in their work and she said 'Why did you do that? Did you not listen? What do you think your ears are for?'
Whereas next door, the teacher was saying 'Let's fix that then. How did it go wrong? Oh dear me!'
Write today's problems and is there any chance you can volunteer again in DD's class? Observe over a few days?
I have signed up already to help on a couple of trips next term. They prefer parent helpers in a different class though. I think the HT chooses where you go.
OP you have just seen a snapshot of a day. had you been sitting next to me today you would have met Mrs exhausted - couldn't be arsed. tomorrow I will be fine but not today. surely this could just have been her off day - perhaps her dog had died or she was not feeling well or a million other things. hands up, if you have never had an off day at work?
does your DD say she is shouty or has she never mentioned it.
I think it must be really tough to be a teacher at the end of this particularly term with kids who are completely knackered and you are trying to get stuff done. are you being a bit pfb here?
Oh I totally get you OP. I find it very upsetting. I home educate one of my children now.
When I helped out in school I heard the HT scream at a kid in a really aggressive manner to the kid with the bad reputation - a few of heard it and and none of us said anything. I really regret not having the balls to go to the Governors.
That is what I am worried about, mummymeister. I mean, I know I have had days with DD which I am glad no-one has seen!
DD says she is very loud and has been getting tummy aches a lot recently.
I find teachers in general so shouty and abrasive... DD is at big brother's former primary (one he moved to because it was such a wonderful, warm learning nook, not the shouty, brash, institution it has become).
I find myself very sad about this. Definitely, if the head is a reasonable person, voice your valid concerns.
Surely the HT will know.
I think she probably always shouts, the HT knows, and there is nothing you can do (besides move school)
NickyFury interesting that you home school. I would in a heartbeat, but DH is totally against. I was home schooled in year 4 after a teacher who blew the roof up if you sniffled. She would perch us on the corner with a 'dunce' cone on our heads and slam rulers on our desks- across the knuckles if you pushed her. It was the 80s. But to this day, I am scarred emotionally. The fear, the stress was intense.
I'm a teacher and I still think its ok for you to say something to the head. As long as you dont go in all guns blazing, which it doesnt sound like you will, then its fine and a gentle word might make all the difference.
The other teachers approach sounds lovely and the one I hope I manage most of the time! We all have our off days but too much shouting is not productive. I had a colleague who yelled aggressively a lot and after a while we all (kids and adults) just tuned her out.
I save my big scary raised voice for when something awful has happened (like a child purposely hurting another child) and then it usually has the desired effect.
Hmm. I think it really depends on how bad it was. Tbh, the remark you say she made to that kid about not listening really depends - if the kid was trying his best then that would have hurt, however if she had seen him messing around when she was giving instructions and knew that he was capable then I think it's a fair comment. I think that it's important for parents to respect that teachers are professionals, and not try to tell them how to do their jobs just because we have kids. But at the same time, if she was really beyond anything acceptable, then yes you should mention it.
Well, go in and show your child's class teacher how to teach without raising your voice.
I am sure she will be delighted.
And you might just discover why she finds it necessary.
OP, I understand how you feel. I know someone who had to come into school during class time once. She heard the teacher shouting and she moved her child. She just did not like that a teacher would talk to small kids like that.
My eldest is 11yo. He has been complaining about the music teacher for ages. She shouts all the time apparently. And takes any inclination for music they have a nd shreds it with her vicious screaming at them...
The other day she was shouting at them all the get in straight lines for rehearsal for Christmas Concert. She grabbed DS by his tie and yanked him really hard apparently. She has grabbed him roughly before, and other boys too.
I just don't know how to approach it with the head,or even if I should?
I'm sure sorting hundreds of boys from 3yo-18yo is draining and frustrating at times, but she really needs to reign it in!
Should have mentioned that I name changed for that post.
I had teachers at school who never raised their voice, they were the teachers that had complete calm in class. It can be done but perhaps they went to a different training school to the teachers that shout in class.
If you had observed me yesterday (athough I am secondary) you would have probably thought the same.
It's the end of a long term, I am biting my tongue as much as possible but after 3 hours of being spoken to by yr9 and yr10's like I am something they wouldn't tread in and the school consequences having no impact on them at all it's tough.
In one lesson yesterday I was talking to the whole class about controlled assessment which is worth 25% of their total mark and was repeatedly asked the same question by different students 6 times, as they can't be bothered to listen - they even said as much - even the most patient person in the world would begin to lose patience with that.
Join the discussion
Please login first.