Talk

Advanced search

to not understand the fuss about gluten?

(147 Posts)
Bleakhouse1879 Mon 10-Aug-15 13:08:07

This has probably been asked on here before, if so, shoot me down.

When I was a wee nipper I had never heard of gluten or its dangerous life changing properties. Now everyday I'm hearing about gluten-free this and gluten-free that, "I'm a celiac" or "my wife is intolerant to wheat and everything else in life"

Please could someone explain to this confused and rather befuddled gentleman of advancing years what all the fuss is about? Is it genuine or is it just another attention-seeking illness?

laffymeal Mon 10-Aug-15 13:09:59

Oh dear

AllThatGlistens Mon 10-Aug-15 13:10:05

Don your hard hat, this will not be pretty..

maybebabybee Mon 10-Aug-15 13:10:07

Coeliac's disease is a genuine illness.

People who just refuse to eat gluten for no apparent reason are annoying.

Bread is not the enemy.

CherryBonBon Mon 10-Aug-15 13:10:38

hmm

Coeliac disease is just that, a disease.

It's not some silly food fad.

Coeliac disease

pretend Mon 10-Aug-15 13:11:22

Hahaha got your hard hat with you??

Have you heard of a thing called allergies? Where certain foods give you tummy upset/rash/death?

Well some people are allergic to something called gluten, so they have food which we call "gluten free".

If you aren't allergic to gluten then you don't need gluten free food. Although I suppose some weirdos people might like it.

Does that help?

jenenberry Mon 10-Aug-15 13:11:33

I think for Celiacs, then gluten IS a big deal and can seriously affect their health. So I think you are being a bit AIBU.

But you are right about the 'rest' who think it's fashionable to give up this, that and the other.
They have way too much time on their hands.
Gluten is now the new sugar, which used to be the new fat.

CherryBonBon Mon 10-Aug-15 13:11:36

Were you really born in 1879?

It kinda sounds like you were.

MuddhaOfSuburbia Mon 10-Aug-15 13:13:33

I'm coeliac. Before my dx I was MOST sniffy about weirdos in the free from aisle

And now I are one. Serves me right

AnUtterIdiot Mon 10-Aug-15 13:14:00

It upsets my stomach so I don't eat it. HTH.

worldsgonemade Mon 10-Aug-15 13:14:29

LOL all I can say is your a brave man for post that.

Coeliac disease is exactly that a disease, it is an auto immune disease where your body attacks itself when you digest gluten. 1 of my dc has it, it can make you quite ill but is not life threatening also you have a higher risk of developing bowel cancer in later life.

EponasWildDaughter Mon 10-Aug-15 13:14:41

Oh blimey.

I've just read a post accusing posters of ''pretending'' not to be able to control their eating habits (on the thread about being annoyed with women who complain about their lives but don't 'just' leave).

And now we have 'attention seeking illnesses'

hmm

Are you to befuddled to use google OP?

maybebabybee Mon 10-Aug-15 13:15:29

My Gran claims she is allergic to dairy and wheat. Yet I have seen her eat half a tub of haagen-dazs because 'ice cream doesn't count'.

I have also served her fish cakes containing gluten but I only realised afterwards they had gluten in them. She was fine. I don't want to be cruel but in her case it genuinely is all in her head.

CMOTDibbler Mon 10-Aug-15 13:15:47

Coeliac disease was first described by the ancient greeks, but the link to gluten wasn't discovered until the blockade of Amsterdam where doctors realised that the coeliac children were actually putting on weight when there was no bread around.
Once the link was made, children no longer died from coeliac disease.

I have coeliac disease, and its in no way attention seeking. Before diagnosis I couldn't move without pain, had continual mouth ulcers and a weeping rash all over my hands. One dietary change, and I haven't suffered any of those in 17 years - apart from the odd occasion I get accidentally glutened

pretend Mon 10-Aug-15 13:15:51

I cannot imagine why the eating habits of others would be on anyone's radar.

Do you lot have nothing better to worry about?

stevienickstophat Mon 10-Aug-15 13:16:42

There is a theory that genetically modifying wheat over the last few decades has created a problem. Something about a strain of wheat that has more allergens.

Also, the over-prevalence of wheat in the Western diet (because it is cheap to produce) has triggered allergic reactions. Nature hates excess. If you look at a typical day's eating, that might include cereal/toast for breakfast, sandwich for lunch, pasta for dinner, biscuits and cakes for snacks. That's a LOT of gluten.

Also, you say it's a modern phenomenon, but that could be down to awareness. How many of us remember Grandad swigging from a bottle of Gaviscon or constantly sucking Rennies? Might have been gluten-intolerant...

As far as attention-seeking goes (and I notice you appear to aim your snotty comment at women) I have to say I don't tend to advertise my inability to digest wheat. How odd that you think that I would.

If I want attention, I tend to rely on my excellent sense of humour and amazing tits.

HTH

allwornout0 Mon 10-Aug-15 13:17:38

I know some people that have Coeliac disease which is like Maybebabybee says is a serious genuine illness. They get very annoyed when they go out to eat or mention it to people and get an automatic reaction from people that it is just some sort of diet fad
They absolutely hate suffering from it and wish they didn't have it but say because of the number of people who are going gluten free as a lifestyle choice people think they are making their illness up.

FluffyCubs Mon 10-Aug-15 13:17:50

Op, we are not eating the same wheat as our forefathers. The stuff we are eating now is bred to max out GI etc and is more geared to a commercial business. for most people, this isn't a problem but for some of is, it causes endless issues. I have gluten sensitivity which is not the same a coeliac disease but in me, causes horrendous psoriasis, migraines and ibs symptoms. Read a book called wheatbelly for further info. I can assure you that while some people just dint want to eat gluten, most people who avoid it have solid reasons for doing so, backed up with medical advice.

TheOnlyPink Mon 10-Aug-15 13:18:12

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JaneAustinAllegro Mon 10-Aug-15 13:18:27

Coeliac is a very real disease, but going gluten free is also a currently popular eating hobby for others who think it might give them a flatter stomach. You can't win on this one as for every fashionable eating type, there will be someone for whom eliminating gluten has massively helped.

DiamondsInTheFlesh Mon 10-Aug-15 13:18:28

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

maybebabybee Mon 10-Aug-15 13:19:20

They absolutely hate suffering from it and wish they didn't have it but say because of the number of people who are going gluten free as a lifestyle choice people think they are making their illness up.

This is what I have a problem with as I think it sort of minimises the suffering of those who genuinely can't eat it. My sister has coeliac's and would love to be able to eat bread and pasta - she gets pissed off when people claim to have intolerances to it when they actually don't. Feeling a bit bloated after a plate of pasta does not equal a food allergy. It just doesn't.

Superexcited Mon 10-Aug-15 13:19:36

Well if my son eats gluten he has a severe allergic reaction which could require the use of his epipen and an ambulance being called.
Food allergies and intolerances can be very serious and they have always existed. A child like my son would have been diagnosed many decades ago but people with intolerances might have gone undiagnosed and been left to suffer with symptoms that they couldn't pinpoint to anything specific and couldn't do anything about.
A lack of diagnosis is previous decades doesn't mean that people were not suffering.

SaucyJack Mon 10-Aug-15 13:20:50

Well firstly coeliac disease is a "proper" medical condition by anyone's standard, but I don't think anyone refuses to eat gluten for no apparent reason. People who do avoid wheat and/or gluten do so because they feel better for it.

Whether it's because they are mildly sensitive to gluten or because they replace the endless slices of carbtastic bread with other healthier foods is anyone's guess. It's of no concern to anyone else tho (provided they don't bang on about it at the dinner-table obv)

MrsGentlyBenevolent Mon 10-Aug-15 13:21:01

I can see where the op is coming from (Coeliac is a real illness though!). I don't think anyone would deny a true allergy - they can be awful, and even limit usual activities most of us don't have to think twice about.

It's the annoying bunch, who self declare some 'intolerance', just to be part if some fad that are in the majority it seems. I've seen these numpties - 'oh no, can't have pizza, makes me so bloated and ill! I'm lactose/wheat/gluten intolerant. Now pass me more chocolate cheesecake please.....'. They just come under 'fussy eaters' to me, really don't care if some bit of food gives you the farts hmm. (Again - unless that ties in with another genuine medical condition, like IBS).

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now