Advanced search

To ponder on whether Matthew Macfadyen

(15 Posts)
LunchpackOfNotreDame Sat 08-Aug-15 21:08:23

Could do comedy

He's sorry serious all the time. He's a brilliant dramatic actor but I can't imagine him doing comedy. His face doesn't seem to lend itself to humour.

Rhine Sat 08-Aug-15 21:12:10

Completely off topic but he was a shit Mr Darcy, Colin Firth all the way.

I'll leave your thread now..

Toffeelatteplease Sat 08-Aug-15 21:13:05

Yes he can be very funny. He played fop the Alan Davis adaption of the way we live now.

LunchpackOfNotreDame Sat 08-Aug-15 21:13:13

Oh I agree on the Darcy thing

Toffeelatteplease Sat 08-Aug-15 21:15:56

It was the writing and pace of the pride and prejudice film that let the actors down. I still remember the hand thing he did when he hand Elizabeth Bennett into the carriage. That was nicely done

Toffeelatteplease Sat 08-Aug-15 21:17:18

Andrew Davies

NormanLamont Sat 08-Aug-15 21:19:54

It would have to be very deadpan humour, naturally.

He worse some very funny disco gear in an Ashes to Ashes episode. Does that count?

JimmyChoosChimichanga Sat 08-Aug-15 21:24:02

I think he was a better Mr Darcy than Colin Firth. I thought he was excellent in Little Dorrit too. I so would!

I absolutely love him as Darcy (detest Colin Firth) but have never seen him in anything else.

Rjae Sat 08-Aug-15 21:26:07

Gorgeous in ripper street. Sorry what was the question..... blush

NormanLamont Sat 08-Aug-15 21:26:24

Memory fail - not actually disco smile

CoogerAndDark Sat 08-Aug-15 21:27:23

He does comedy extremely well in Ripper Street.

MalmseyWhine Sat 08-Aug-15 21:45:31

He was in Jeeves and Wooster in the West End last year, that was a comedy although I didn't get to see it as too bloody skint and a bit slapstick. He's also done Noel Coward.

He can do me anytime, nevermind comedy.

MummaGiles Sat 08-Aug-15 21:49:22

I saw him play Jeeves in the West End last year and he was very funny in that, in a straight man kind of way. Many different ways to be funny.

MalmseyWhine Sat 08-Aug-15 21:51:47

envy Was he gorgeous MummaGiles? Could you see his big hands and broad chest?

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now