Talk

Advanced search

To wonder what the hell *does* break Facebook community standards

(63 Posts)
Hobbes8 Thu 30-Jul-15 20:53:37

I saw some proper porn on Facebook today. Someone had tagged a friend in it and so it appeared on my news feed. I presume they had been hacked.

There was a series of pictures that were clearly pornographic, and some text about someone drugging someone. Full frontal genital penetration shots and the implication that it was rape as well. Really jarring when you're scrolling down minion quotes and kitten pictures.

So I reported it and clicked on the "sexually explicit material" option. I got a message back saying the post had been reviewed and judged not to contain nudity.

What the hell?! It's still there. I've heard about FB removing breastfeeding pictures and children in the bath, etc - how have they left this up?

FarFromAnyRoad Thu 30-Jul-15 20:57:27

I had a load of this on my feed yesterday because the hacker had tagged a friend of mine - it was really quite shock porn but they did remove it quickly. Encouraged by that I reported something similar today involving two underage kids having sex in a toilet - but that, apparently, didn't contravene their rules.
Makes you wonder doesn't it.

BlackHillsofDakota Thu 30-Jul-15 20:59:22

I know what you mean, I reported a picture of a gymnast mid air legs akimbo who's leotard had pinged open and she had nothing underneath - hence a full frontal legs spread picture of her bits. Apparently that didn't violate their standards either.

crustsaway Thu 30-Jul-15 21:00:56

The thing has become too big to police. You probably need to do that yourself and just delete.

cleanmyhouse Thu 30-Jul-15 21:02:56

I've reported some really graphic violence/animal cruelty videos and been told they didn't break standards. I was genuinely horrified to hear these videos were considered acceptable.

AbbeyRoadCrossing Thu 30-Jul-15 21:03:57

The only thing I've successfully reported is swearing. I reported it because the person was being abusive in other ways but it appeared to be just a swearword that did it.
Ones I've reported about killing all disabled people for example are fine according to fb though

Thefacttheyact1234 Thu 30-Jul-15 21:04:18

Yes I reported some nasty sn bashing. Nope not a problem hmm

crustsaway Thu 30-Jul-15 21:07:39

Why not just delete. The world is full of strange people. You can actually change your settings so you dont receive anything other than messages and feeds to do with who are on our site.

crustsaway Thu 30-Jul-15 21:09:09

Whats with all this reporting? just change your settings. Its a tool for communication and there would need to be 1000 people there night and day policing the thing. Its called the internet.

Ishtar2410 Thu 30-Jul-15 21:11:20

I reported one of those videos where a woman was flicking a towel at a baby; the towel was hitting the legs and torso. Baby was understandably crying.

Apparently it didn't contravene their rules hmm.

Hobbes8 Thu 30-Jul-15 21:11:34

I can just delete, but I thought it would be socially responsible to report as well. I understand it's reviewed by some sort of algorithm rather than an actual person, but there's nothing in this post but tits and genitals so I'd expect even a computer to be able to see that it's inappropriate.

crustsaway Thu 30-Jul-15 21:12:58

computers cant see grin

crustsaway Thu 30-Jul-15 21:13:17

people find ways round machines.

Hobbes8 Thu 30-Jul-15 21:20:02

Ok picky pickerson - I would expect a computer to be able to determine that it's inappropriate. And if it can't, then yes, they need to employ people to ensure that porn isn't visible on a massively popular website that is used by 13 year olds.

If I posted porn on here it would rightly be removed.

crustsaway Thu 30-Jul-15 21:23:48

You cant "expect" anything on a computer, as I said, people have ways of bypassing this. You use a site like facebook and know the dangers in my opinion or you are really living in lala land.

TartanTrousers Thu 30-Jul-15 21:25:37

I saw a very disturbing video of people in Africa being accused of witchcraft and thrown into a pit where they were beaten and burned alive. I reported it also and received a similar response.

I blocked and hid the post but some things you can't un-see:

crustsaway Thu 30-Jul-15 21:28:30

The easy answer is dont use facebook then. Stop blaming a huge communication tool that can be infiltrated by "people". You will never ever do this and make a site clear of twats etc. Even bloody nassa got done grin and think how much they spend in safeguarding.

Hobbes8 Thu 30-Jul-15 21:30:07

Then why have community standards at all? Why have a report button? Why not let it be a free for all?

I use the Internet all the time and manage not to view porn.

Of course you can expect things on a computer.

crustsaway Thu 30-Jul-15 21:35:05

Can you imagine on such a scale what this would incurr? any social media site would have to close. Manage yourselves really. Know that this is what happens. Know that there is not some individual behind a screen blocking every report. It probably gets done eventually but takes a lot of time. It's the same as being outside in the big bad world. Stop blaming media sites that are for communication.

Hobbes8 Thu 30-Jul-15 21:42:18

I manage to walk around outside in the big bad world without seeing porn as well.

your argument would make sense if there was no report or review function available. But there is, and apparently Facebook has reviewed the explicit pornography and thinks it's just fine. It's not.

Hobbes8 Thu 30-Jul-15 21:43:28

I'm sorry others have had to see distressing content as well.

crustsaway Thu 30-Jul-15 21:43:31

Dont use the thing then... It happens because human beings can get round these things.

WoonerismSpit Thu 30-Jul-15 21:47:45

ODFOD Crusts.

You just pop up on thread after thread falling over yourself to be a GF, sending multiple messages (lest you forget to put enough goadiness in your original missive)...doesn't it get boring?

Hobbes8 Thu 30-Jul-15 21:47:56

Ah ok. Good plan. I'll make sure I don't see or speak to any humans any more, lest they thrust their genitals at me.

Tootsiepops Thu 30-Jul-15 21:52:01

I had bestiality in my newsfeed the other day. Woman and a horse. I'm still shuddering. I reported it, but no word yet if it was removed or not.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now