Talk

Advanced search

DS's thread - WHY DOES EVERYONE DIE IN HARRY POTTER? [SPOILER WARNING added by MNHQ]

(221 Posts)
dougieroseagain Wed 22-Jul-15 20:58:55

Dobby,
Cedric
Sirius
Does anyone evil die, he says?

An d my point is/

??

2 gottles of wine. your honour, i feeallly don'e care.

GGabcd Wed 22-Jul-15 21:00:46

Voldemort dies.

OstentatiousBreastfeeder Wed 22-Jul-15 21:01:47

Plenty of evil folk die.

BlueAcres Wed 22-Jul-15 21:02:04

Voldy
Bellatrix
Crabbe or Goyle, never remember which it is
Er... random death eaters die?

LillyBugg Wed 22-Jul-15 21:02:07

Maybe don't start a third 'gottle'? grin

cashewnutty Wed 22-Jul-15 21:02:50

Harry, Ron and Hermione live. What more does he want?

00100001 Wed 22-Jul-15 21:02:56

<runs in>

SNAPE KILLS DUMBLEDORE

SuffolkNWhat Wed 22-Jul-15 21:03:07

In life people die. People who do the right thing and those who don't.

dougieroseagain Wed 22-Jul-15 21:05:04

He's only 8 and we're trying to show him the full set of films before we go to the WB studio tour on Saturday. That was his response after watching Deathly Hallows part 1. Oh hear. Tonks and Lupin are still to come :[

dougieroseagain Wed 22-Jul-15 21:06:15

blueacres I thought crabbe or goyle was in prison for burning down Croydon in teh London riots?

steff13 Wed 22-Jul-15 21:07:51

And Fred Weasley.

Lots of death eaters die, we just don't know them as well.

SuffolkNWhat Wed 22-Jul-15 21:07:53

In the books Crabbe dies in the RoR after setting off Fiend Fire, they had to have Zabini with Malfoy and Crabbe because the actor playing Goyle was in trouble for riot and drug offences.

BertrandRussell Wed 22-Jul-15 21:09:23

Don't show him the later films- he's too young, he doesn't need to have seem them all for HP World!

Noeuf Wed 22-Jul-15 21:15:41

Yeah don't show him the films past about the first two!

dougieroseagain Wed 22-Jul-15 21:16:33

Oh bless, Bertrand Russell - older daugher (age 17) has been the custodian of the Harry POtter films for several years. She's deemed it appropriate as the Harry Potter police.

He seems ok. He is towel flicking everyone in sight. With the towel. Whilst avoiding the shower.

Diggum Wed 22-Jul-15 21:17:29

00100001 grin

Evil laugh. Now sit down and catch your breath.

PourquoiTuGachesTaVie Wed 22-Jul-15 21:18:00

To prepare you for Game of Thrones.

pickingstrawberries Wed 22-Jul-15 21:19:36

has he read the books?

5Foot5 Wed 22-Jul-15 21:20:46

To prepare you for Game of Thrones.
gringrin
But, no. Really - not with an 8yo.

howabout Wed 22-Jul-15 21:22:33

Agree with don't show him the later films yet. I am still traumatised and I am 47.

dougieroseagain Wed 22-Jul-15 21:23:47

He's going round the house shouting "Accio Club Penguin."

This is an insight into my life.

I was going to stop after film 4 (Goblet of Fire) but 17year old and the HP POLICE says it's OK to show him the rest of the series. Hmnnnn.

Sighing Wed 22-Jul-15 21:24:35

I was thinking about Game of Thrones.
If you think people die in HP .... 10 ish years. You know nothing dougierosie son

BertieBotts Wed 22-Jul-15 21:26:14

grin "To prepare you for Game of Thrones"

BEST. COMMENT. EVER.

MrsHathaway Wed 22-Jul-15 21:26:25

Real answer? Because JKR isn't that great a writer and struggles with loose ends.

dougieroseagain Wed 22-Jul-15 21:27:34

Don't even start me on Game of Thrones sighing as that is DP's favourite pastime. He's yet to see that Joffe comes to a sticky and well deserved end

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now