to think it's unfair we have to pay a £500 surcharge for the NHS

[alaskanbaby]

My DH (let's call him Mr. Alaska) and I both work full time, and pay income tax like everyone else, which goes towards our use of the NHS like everyone else. We've just found out that we need to fork out a £500 surcharge for his use of the NHS as part of his extension of his immigration visa (for being my husband of 5 years, and father of our 18 month old DD - both she and I are British, though I guess she's sponging off the NHS quite a bit). Am I being unreasonable to think it's unfair that my DH has to pay twice?

[VegasIsBest]

It's not unfair for people who are new to the country and haven't been paying tax for as long to be asked to pay a bit more.

If you had moved to your husband's country would you have received excellent and free health care immediately?

[MadameJulienBaptiste]

If he is from alaska then i'm sure £500 is ridiculously cheap compared to US health insurance plus all the copays and deductibles. Not to mention the cost of all the things the health insurance won't cover.
you could always move to his home country to save the £500?

[Purplepoodle]

Hes not british. If he wants it totally free then apply for dual citizenship

[HermioneWeasley]

Doesn't seem unreasonable to me. How long does the £500 cover him for?

[Movingonmymind]

Nope, sorry! Paid a shed load of tax and out for ptivaye insurance while overseas got severalyears amd got diddly squat. Thats life. If you choose to live overseas you will st times be treated as a foreigner. Uk damn sight better than most places!

[alaskanbaby]

We are applying for residency - obviously it takes 5 years and £5000, so we're saving up. He's paid tax in the UK for all of the 10 years he's lived here over the last 15, apart from when he was an international student and paying £10,000 per year fees.
And he's been to the doctor about twice in the last year.
But I guess I'm just being unreasonable.

[ostrichchurchyard]

Following that logic, shouldn't all (ie regardless of where they were born and raised) 18 year olds pay a surcharge too as they have not contributed through taxation?

[WhattodowithMum]

Why £5000 pounds? That's much higher than I thought it was. Also, if he's been here for 19 years already, why does he have to wait another 5?

[Nolim]

Op as an expat i agree that paying a surcharge on top on tax is unfair, it would be understandable for those who dont pay national insurance. But good luck convincing ppl that there are immigrants whi pay they fair share if taxes and di not abuse the system.

[Viviennemary]

Well maybe he should go back to Alaska and then he would have to pay a lot more. Honestly some folk!

[ProvisionallyAnxious]

YANBU. Isn't it £500 per year of the visa, as well?

For PPs saying that if you lived in Alaska you'd have to pay healthcare insurance - well, yes, but you wouldn't simultaneously be paying taxes towards a national health service.

[Velocitractor]

I thought it was a bit unfair (I live in an EU country where all residents (including non-EU ) in the country for more than 3 months have access to free healthcare) but on the basis of the previous posts it seems mine is a lone voice!

[MelanieCheeks]

Is this a new thing? I'm surprised, I admit. Have we all the relevant information?

[Balanced12]

£500 seems reasonable he could go private. It was people's parents and grand parents that built the system so a lot more has been put in by them.

[alaskanbaby]

He had to work abroad for 2 years, so had to start again - hence the length of time. It takes 3 applications once you're married, and it's about £700 a pop, plus the £500 NHS charge for the first two times, and about £400 each time to go in person (we've not used the in-person service previously and the first time they lost his passport and the second time took 3 months when he got stuck in Belgium).
But like I said, I'm obviously being unreasonable. We could easily sell our house, quit our jobs, take our daughter away from her relatives and friends and just move to Alaska to no home and no jobs.

[MadameJulienBaptiste]

Provisionally - US health insurance charges are massively more than UK national insurance. And don't cover as much.

[ProvisionallyAnxious]

MelanieCheeks

It is definitely true. From the horse's mouth: www.gov.uk/healthcare-immigration-application/overview

[Kampeki]

FWIW, OP, I think it is unfair, but obviously, I'm in a minority on this thread.

[alaskanbaby]

Yes, it's a relatively new thing (the Tories brought it in)
One thing to remember, all you lovely mums, is that first they make the foreigners pay, and then they start on everyone else...

[WidowWadman]

I agree that it's unfair and disproportionate. But the government does anything to work towards its shortsighted goal of reducing net migration.

[HighOverTheFenceLeapsSunnyJim]

I think it's unfair.

[Nolim]

Balanced the surcharge is independent of having private insurance or not.

[lljkk]

Being non-EU immigrant can be expensive, yes.
With all the hype about health tourism, you understand why the charges, right?

[Nolim]

With all the hype about health tourism, you understand why the charges, right?
But there is (or should be) a distinction between someone who genuinly has been paying national insurance contributions for years and a health turist, right?