Talk

Advanced search

MIL, DH and school reports.

(137 Posts)
butterfliesandbee Sun 28-Jun-15 19:43:15

Mil and Fil came to our house today. DCs had both received their school reports on friday so i offer Mil and Fil if they want to see them. DS had am excellent report and DDs behaviour etc is excellent but actual work is below average. This is nothing new to any of us and we are worki g hard to help her.
Mil insisted that Dd was fine, ahe is doing well etc. Basically she doesnt like to think admit that she is struggling with work. I said that actually she isnd doing well and there is no point in pretending that she is. DH said nothing during this discussion.
Now they have left he has said I threw the fact DD isnt doing well in his mums face and that there is no point in argueing with her as she wont believe that Dd isnt perfect.
Apparently i shouldnt have let them read the reports although he never said anything at the time.
Did i do wrong?

CherylBerylMeryl Sun 28-Jun-15 19:44:11

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BitchPeas Sun 28-Jun-15 19:45:44

Yabu. Your poor DD. How old is she? Was this in front of her?

AuntyMag10 Sun 28-Jun-15 19:46:22

Yabu, all they needed to do was read the report. Not sure why you felt the need to go on about it. Are they going to actively participate in helping your dd get better?

GinUpGirl Sun 28-Jun-15 19:47:33

I'd avoid showing the reports in the future if they cause so much aggravation.

Work out what you have to do for DD and get on with it. But don't heap pressure on the poor girl if she isn't capable. Celebrate effort, not grades.

whois Sun 28-Jun-15 19:47:45

Who on earth did you give their reports to the GPs to read?

And why be so insistent your DD is struggling?

Strange.

Gemauve Sun 28-Jun-15 19:48:33

so i offer Mil and Fil if they want to see them

Why?

0x530x610x750x630x79 Sun 28-Jun-15 19:48:39

Listen to your OH he has spent a lot longer learning how to handle his parent than you.

And grandparents job is to think the sun shines out of their ....

Crikeyblimey Sun 28-Jun-15 19:49:10

Poor kid! Maybe she's doing the best she can.

manicinsomniac Sun 28-Jun-15 19:49:20

Aaawww, the whole point of grandparents is to think you're perfect, spoil you and leave the actual parenting to the parents.

I've always felt bad about my DDs only having 1 grandparent. They have some incredibly amazing great grandparents though who will not hear a word against them (or me, their granddaughter). This is as it should be, imo.

cuntycowfacemonkey Sun 28-Jun-15 19:50:10

I'm baffled why you needed to make such a fanfare of the fact your dd is struggling?

MakeItRain Sun 28-Jun-15 19:51:37

If your dd's behaviour is good and she is doing her best then I would agree with your MIL that she is doing "well". It's a strange thing to argue about.

viva100 Sun 28-Jun-15 19:55:34

YABU. And mean. Poor DD

pigsDOfly Sun 28-Jun-15 19:56:43

I'm not really sure I understand what point you were trying to make with your MIL OP.

MIL thinks DD is perfect and that's lovely but you seem to want her to join you in picking the report apart and putting DD down.

If you all know DD isn't doing well with her work you didn't really need to point it out to MIL and make such a point of it.

I hope you poor DD wasn't in the room when you were banging on to everyone about how useless you think she is.

Yes you did do something wrong.

3littlefrogs Sun 28-Jun-15 19:58:11

I agree. Poor DD. I hope she wasn't in earshot.

butterfliesandbee Sun 28-Jun-15 19:58:26

I did not make a fanfare out of the fact dd is struggling but equally i dont see the point in lying about it. Perphas hoping that we could all work together to help her.
I dont feel that just telling someone how well they have done, even if they havent is very productive. Obviously i do put this across to dd in a age appropriate way. But maybe MIL method of only seeing g the good and refusing to acknowledge the bad is right and i am wrong.
Dd know she has done very well in some areas i.e dance, behaviour etc but also she knows some areas need help and thats what i am trtig to do.

pigsDOfly Sun 28-Jun-15 19:58:49

Over use of the word point there.

AuntyMag10 Sun 28-Jun-15 20:00:51

Why would the gps be 'working together' sorting this out confused

NinkyNonkers Sun 28-Jun-15 20:02:34

Your mil disagrees with your approach, sounds like your DH does too. I have to say I think I do too, trying to rope Granny into coming down on your daughter seems very harsh. She doesn't have to agree with you on this and you can't make her. So in future either don't show her the reports or accept her valid opinion.

Were both your children there? What a hideous experience for them both.

butterfliesandbee Sun 28-Jun-15 20:03:01

Where did i say that i was banging on about how useless my dd is?

Is admitting that your child isnt above average now calling them useless??

AuntyMag10 Sun 28-Jun-15 20:03:57

Yes but what do you expect your il to do about it. How do you think they are going to help practically?

butterfliesandbee Sun 28-Jun-15 20:04:33

My dd was not there, i didnt sat she was although she is quite capeable of reading her own report. Should i not be letting her see that she is brilliant at some things and not at others.

redshoeblueshoe Sun 28-Jun-15 20:04:55

Maybe dd could help you with your spelling

Chillyegg Sun 28-Jun-15 20:04:56

I feel sorry for your DD hmm
Yabu

Mistigri Sun 28-Jun-15 20:06:24

I really, really hope your DD wasn't listening!

I wouldn't show reports to GPS and especially not if it is likely to cause aggravation.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now