Talk

Advanced search

To wonder what constitutes an 'Mumsnet storm'? (Royal related)

(53 Posts)
Arsenic Mon 16-Feb-15 16:18:44

Apparently.

I've just started reading Catherine Mayer's new book about Prince Charles. There is a passage in the prologue about criticism of the the Cambridges' March 2014 trip to the Maldives (leaving baby George at home) which the author calls 'a manufactured tempest in a child's teacup'.

Discussion of Netmums, Mumsnet, Twitter.

Then the following;

"Had there been outrage on Mumsnet? Not according to Katie O'Donovan, Mumsnet's head of communications, who emails that there were 'just over 300 responses, which isn't really a "storm" by Mumsnet's standards. Not at all unanimous criticism of the couple.....'."

So how many comments makes a storm? I'm curious now.

Arsenic Mon 16-Feb-15 16:20:38

And does frothiness matter? <watches SAHM thread and muses>

EatShitDerek Mon 16-Feb-15 16:21:59

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

LurkingHusband Mon 16-Feb-15 16:23:23

PAC parking

RedCrayons Mon 16-Feb-15 16:23:39

It's not a storm unless the thread gets pulled, there's more than one Thread about a thread, a few people get banned, someone flounces.

MuttersDarkly Mon 16-Feb-15 16:24:48

We've had several (full) threads over any given controversy on here. New threads being opened as the old ones fill up fast.

So I am going with 4000ish posts minimum, a piece in the guardian about the hoohar that LEGITIMATLY references MN and preferably the banning of at least one protagonist before the storm label can be applied.

Arsenic Mon 16-Feb-15 16:24:53

That's what I thought Del- froth - not post count grin

The other interesting nugget is;

*"Netmums posted an item inviting comment on the royal jolly only at the request of the Daily Mail."

The great big tabloid handmaidens. That's deliberate froth solicitation <tuts>

ghostyslovesheep Mon 16-Feb-15 16:25:10

Redcrayons wins - <draws line>

Arsenic Mon 16-Feb-15 16:26:17

Red and Mutters have very high thresholds smile

AwfulBeryl Mon 16-Feb-15 16:30:30

Yep, what red said. Extra points if it gets a mention in the DM.

EatShitDerek Mon 16-Feb-15 16:33:01

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Arsenic Mon 16-Feb-15 16:34:23

Start that thread Derek wink

We need a practical demo.

kim147 Mon 16-Feb-15 16:38:42

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Smallcogbigwheel Mon 16-Feb-15 16:41:12

If its just a general storm what about this one here?

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/child_internet_safety/2307274-I-am-everything-you-hate-about-people-on-the-internet-I-am-here-to-help?msgid=52584776

AwfulBeryl Mon 16-Feb-15 16:42:50

Aibu to pierce my bubbaz earz ? She is 1 and luvs mine so I no she wud like em dun. I have seen a lovely pair of earrings that wud go wit Her headband.
I will take her to Macky Dz after innit.

Arsenic Mon 16-Feb-15 16:43:04

I think they mean this one kim;

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/a2018064-WillKats-second-honeymoon

....but I remember it being discussed across threads and I think I remember you getting grief for it. Or was that some other royal matter ? grin

AwfulBeryl Mon 16-Feb-15 16:43:57

She is 5 weeks btw

Behindthepaintedgarden Mon 16-Feb-15 16:44:41

I have seen storms on here on threads that started out perfectly innocently and on some totally innocuous topic. It is amazing they way some threads evolve.

Arsenic Mon 16-Feb-15 16:44:42

That one went viral Small smile

Arsenic Mon 16-Feb-15 16:46:00

<slightly scared of Beryl, so keeping quiet about headbands on babies>

EatShitDerek Mon 16-Feb-15 16:46:13

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

WereJamming Mon 16-Feb-15 16:46:25

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Arsenic Mon 16-Feb-15 16:47:35

I reckon Kate IS MN royalty by now.

Behindthepaintedgarden Mon 16-Feb-15 16:48:25

SUV threads can turn quite scary sometimes.

And I agree, threads about Mumsnet Royalty beat the Windsors anyday.

kim147 Mon 16-Feb-15 16:48:38

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: