Talk

Advanced search

to be a bit fed up.. negitive home birth comments

(144 Posts)
ghostspirit Tue 06-Jan-15 21:38:56

im going to have a home birth. and i have not had one positive comment. its all been things like. something might go wrong. oh thats dangerous. what do you want to do that for. aww what about the mess.

reallyneedmoresleep Tue 06-Jan-15 21:41:12

I had a home birth with DS3 and it was wonderful. I wish I'd done it with the first two. It was brilliant cuddling up in my own bed afterwards rather than a horrible busy hospital ward.
There was a mess though!

idiuntno57 Tue 06-Jan-15 21:43:33

I've had two and they are up there as the two best days of my life.

IMO Home birth has loads to recommend it particularly if you have other dc as it is much less disruptive.

MollyMaDurga Tue 06-Jan-15 21:43:39

Get a dutch friend! Everybody has a home birth in the Netherlands. Well, not really, but it is completely normal to do so anyway. I think it's great. Giving birth if all is well is not such a medical procedure that it requires a hospital. You are not ill, you are giving birth. If you have a good midwife you are as safe or safer.

PiperIsTerrysChoclateOrange Tue 06-Jan-15 21:44:38

There is about to be a mess, but I think the MW clean it up.

How far away is the local hospital.

ghostspirit Tue 06-Jan-15 21:44:49

i had home birth with my daughter. by accident it was awesome. i guess no one knew before so probably why i did not get the negative comments.

Velvetbee Tue 06-Jan-15 21:45:48

I've had 2 too, DC1 and 3. It was fab, like having a private midwife and you get to snuggle in your own bed afterwards.

MrsMinton Tue 06-Jan-15 21:47:01

My home birth was the best experience. My midwives and DH cleaned it all up and took away clinical waste. It was peaceful and easy and I'd recommend.

LetMeDriveTheBus Tue 06-Jan-15 21:48:45

I had the same sort of comments. If I had my time again, I'd probably just not tell anyone that's what we'd planned!

42bunnytails Tue 06-Jan-15 21:50:19

DD2 was born at home, absolutely agree with it being right up there with the best days of my life.

Own bath, own bed. No stuffy postnatal ward, no hospital food and DD1 met her sister aged 3 minutes old!

Mess, what mess? The MW bought enough inco pads to sink a battle ship.

There was, quite literally, one slight blood stain on one old towel used to wrap DS2 in.

HappyAgainOneDay Tue 06-Jan-15 21:50:53

I had both mine at home because I had running water so didn't qualify for hospital...... Having seen friends packed into after-delivery wards, I'm glad that I had them in private at home. Yes, the midwife each time cleaned up the mess with my husband emptying buckets, rolling up bloody paper etc.

I'll never forget his face when he was asked for newspaper and had the placenta laid in it for him to wrap up and put on the fire downstairs! He paper cut his thumb a couple of years before and fainted.

42bunnytails Tue 06-Jan-15 21:51:27

DD2 (oops)

ghostspirit Tue 06-Jan-15 21:54:03

i never had time for the pads as it was all unplanned. but even then it was not that bad. i did not have to clean it up and even then it was not as bad as cleaning up sick haha.

paramedics cut cord long haha looked mad. when midwife came i asked her to cut it shorter so she did.

bunchoffives Tue 06-Jan-15 21:55:01

Take no notice OP, homebirths are lovely and at least as safe - less infection risk, mw for the whole labour, less stressful, no move afterwards... and no mess that the mother has to deal with grin

It's a shame you're getting negative comments. It's a personal decision that I'm sure you've thought about, including accessing the prod and cons. Just practise a quick easy retort and then ignore them, carry on as you were, it's not them giving birth. Something like "I've weighed up the props and cons and have made an informed choice to plan for a home birth. I'll interpret your comment as concern, thank you for wanting to look out for us, planning for a home birth is one of the ways I can influence how the birth goes and I'm excited to be having my baby in an environment that is safe and comfortable for us both." Then change topic, or go on to talk about how lovely and knowledge your midwife is, no rush of picking up a hospital infection, having a bath in your own bathroom, no undignified flashing of your bun cheeks from a scratchy hospital gown, the intimacy and privacy during and after your birth, comfort for your birthing partner(s), etc. So, although its annoying, if you can accept their comments as concern for you, you can turn the negative into a positive in that they care for you and want a good outcome for you but perhaps aren't as informed as you are and are expressing their care in a clumsy way.

PourquoiTuGachesTaVie Tue 06-Jan-15 21:58:08

My 7 week old was born at home in a pool. No mess at all, no stress, no childcare worries for ds who slept through it and my own food, bath and bed at the end of it all. Wouldn't have had it any other way.

ghostspirit Tue 06-Jan-15 21:58:14

thats why i want home birth again. in my own surroundings no replying on in anyway. no dying of boardem for 6 hours after the birth. no grumpy midwife... all mine have been grumpy when i was in hospital.

Birdsgottafly Tue 06-Jan-15 21:59:24

My DD has just had her first baby at home, in a pool hired from her local Maternity hospital.

There was no mess, I helped her DP empty the pool etc but the MWs would of been happy to do it.

They take away all of the bodily/Birth by products, they have to, by law.

It was a lovely birth experience.

You've been unlucky, my DD had positive feedback from all the HCPs and had people ask questions but no outright negative comments.

More just "you're brave", type comments.

mushypeasontoast Tue 06-Jan-15 21:59:54

Ds1- midwife led unit, I barely got there in time and it was stressful.

Ds2- accidental homebirth. He was prem and I delivered him myself as very quick birth. Dh was calling the ambulance when he was born.

Dd- planned homebirth, midwife arrived in time(she knew me and drove fast), it was calm and peaceful. Own bath, own bed, takeout for dinner and dh didnt have to leave me(ds2 was taken to hospital so on my own). I think my recovery was quicker as well.

If I ever have anymore I will definitely opt for planned home birth.

SantasFavouriteHo Tue 06-Jan-15 22:00:13

I too had a hb for ds2, great experience and as other posters have said, so nice to be in your own bed/have access to your own food/privacy of your own bedroom etc
There was no mess either the midwives know what they're doing and brought sheets/pads with them and took them away
The worst bit (and it was funny rather than painful or anything) was waddling down the hall to have a shower trying not to get blood on the cream carpet!

Accessing the prod? I meant assessing the pros...

WillBeatJanuaryBlues Tue 06-Jan-15 22:04:41

Well...you have already had one....I am not sure why anyone commenting.

Its just naive first timers who want one I would be worried about.

You have had a baby, you understand the pain involved, you know yourself....and how you were under stress....and you had all this - at home!

You sound like a great HB candidate to me, if all well with baby!

ChocLover2015 Tue 06-Jan-15 22:07:16

maybe they think it is an unnecessary waste of scarce resource?

Gawjushun Tue 06-Jan-15 22:07:39

"It's so kind of you to take an interest!" Then silence.

ghostspirit Tue 06-Jan-15 22:08:13

i would like to have a water birth. dont think i will have time though as dd was born so fast.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now