To put someone else's child in time out?(59 Posts)
Dd1 (6) is having a sleepover tomorrow night. Only 3 kids plus her and only 2 of those actually staying the night.
One of the children is...lets just say spirited. When I had her to stay in the summer she literally destroyed my house. I caught her throwing toys out of drawers all over the playroom, emptying dd wardrobe and dresser, and rolling all the toilet roll on the floor. She also opened the front door and left the house around 8am with dd in tow (DH luckily saw this and brought them back in).
Call me crazy but we've invite her to said sleepover as that was 6 months ago (and kids mature, right?!). Anyway, my plan tomorrow eve is to sit all kids down and tell them the "rules", I.e. "Don't destroy my house". Strike 1 will be time out and strike 2 is you're going home.
AIBU or is that fair enough?
You are substitute parent so yes, you use time out.
I've never given either of my DC a time out, so on that basis I'd be irritated.
Did you speak to her parents about her behaviour?
I've never had to use time out so dd wouldn't have a clue. Presuming the challenging dc is used to that.... maybe lay down the rules.
Think I'd just cancel
I forgot to add...
If you don't tell the childs parents then YABU, if you do and they agree, then YANBU.
Your house your rules - but when they have friends over and tend to be over excited I am a little more generous before I wade in with appropriate telling off. But would not put up with any of the behaviour you describe above.
I wouldn't , I'd just tell them upfront that any bad behaviour and you call the parents to collect them. I would also tell the parents that that is what you intend to do .
I don't do 'time out' as I don't agree with it really, but if I had a child that feral and you were prepared to have them sleep over you'd get
a medal, wine, chocolate pretty much free run at doing whatever you would do with your is, bar beating them/locking in the under stair cupboard type stuff.
I will be informing all parents at drop off. Having them at 5 and putting them to bed at 9:30 or so. I know I'm crazy. I wish I could cancel!
We don't do time out with our kids so they would see sitting somewhere for 6 (?) minute as a big deal.
On the other hand they wouldn't misbehave at someone else's house.
If the child has firm for misbehaviour I'd am warn that they'd get one chance and then their parents would be called - and I'd stick to it.
I'd warn the parent that that's what would happen too.
Other people's children don't behave badly in my house, I quash all cheekiness/bad behaviour at the very first sign and they all tend to fall in line.
Hasn't DD been throwing up?
I fail to see how/why parents would be offended by you disciplining their children while they're in your care. Any of those patents could feel free nit to leave their children in my care... Also explains the behaviour of some children these days.
Of course that's fair enough.
But you should also be supervising so the room wrecking and escaping cant happen.
Obviously you've read your own DD the riot act regarding leaving the house again too?
If so, hopefully it will go better this time.
I still think it's a very young age for a sleepover though, but maybe that's because I didn't start sleeping over at my friend's house until I was about 10yrs old.
I would't do time out with someone else's child.
But I would tell them the house rules, and tell them breaking the rules means getting dropped home go their parents.
i think and have always thought that 'time out' in its usual form is
if necessary give her the time she needs to regain her composure..do that whilst you are in the same room for containment
make it clear that you would like to understand what is going on with her
perhaps consider a diary where you look at all the things that piss you off and get her to do the same in some form <nice to chat about also>
you can learn a lot for this and so might she
use 'i feel' o 'was wondering' language...when discussing
I think there's a difference between calming down time and 'time-out' as punishment. I'd be fine with some calm down time out, perhaps for all the children, but time-out as punishment might be a bit weird.
If another parent told me this at the point of drop-off, I'd be a bit . But I'd also hope that is done a decent enough job on my own child so that they wouldn't get themselves into trouble (please note: my child is too young for sleepovers. I may be naive). I remember being told to pipe fine at sleepovers as a child - I assume I was a bit giggly and loud at 2am... but a quick reminder to shush was sufficient for us.
I think you sound a bit formal sitting them down and telling them this.
One of mine at that age (who would have been absolutely fine behaviour) would probably have burst into tears at the thought of being in trouble and insisted on going home if this had been done to her. That would have been a good start!
One warning then you're home sounds fine, but I wouldn't sit them down and tell them that as such. Firstly some children will then see if you mean it. So you're actually inviting them to see what they can do, and secondly you can't list all the possible things a 6yo might think up, so they may say "but you didn't say we couldn't do...." And also because 6yos are terrible tell tales, and you could be in the position of constant "A isn't playing nicely... are you going to send them home" type comments.
And the last thing is that my reaction to the pulling stuff out wouldn't have been "literally destroying my home" because it isn't. It would have been, "right you have 10 minutes to tidy it up before I phone your mum and ask her to pick you up" the first time.
Plus She also opened the front door and left the house around 8am with dd in tow I would assume your dd was at least complicit in this, and if it was my dc I would have regarded my dd as more guilty because they would know that I didn't allow this, whereas their dc may well be allowed round to the neighbours etc.
I think you need to watch them more carefully
I wouldn't be leaving my DC at that age for a sleepover, and certainly not with someone who would put them in time-out! I think all you can do is be with them and play with them - if the rowdy kid is getting out of hand then steer the play into a different direction so they aren't singled out and made to feel bad. They are bound to be excited and a little nutty. If, however, her behaviour is upsetting the others and you just can't make it work, then I would call her parents and tell them it really isn't working out and X is struggling. They are way too young though imo.
seems unnecessarily young for sleepovers. timeouts r weird anyway. supervise properly and you'll have no problens
I think it sounds fine - she will be used to some form of time out at school even if it's not done at home. I'm a bit worried about how two of them could just wander outside without being noticed and also how she could have done all that without being noticed - maybe your children don't need much watching but most 6 year olds do.
For the people that don't agree with time outs or NAIGHTY steps, what do you do instead? we have a friend who NEVER disciplines her child and she is fucking horrible and keeps hitting mine. Have just decided not to see as mine eventually lashes back and I then put her on the naighty step and she is then MASSIVELY confused "but heidi never got told off" etc
My six year old would be scared by your "talking to" idea. A sleepover would be a big step. Five year olds can be nutty, so perhaps six months ago the problem was YOU not supervising? Six months later, 6 year olds are not that much bigger.
You should be hovering quite nearby, so no chance for naughty-ing.
If you want to do the whole rant and then time-out nonsense, you would need to tell the parents BEFORE drop off. Otherwise you make it quite hard for them to think about it and cancel if they don't want their children part of it. I would be totally freaked out to be met with this kind of thing at the start of a sleepover.
You are not at all "crazy" to be having a sleepover. It's not a drama. It's 3 little girls in sleeping bags. I'm sorry the child got some toys out and unrolled a loo roll six months ago. why on earth didn't you just tell her to stop being silly and put it all back?
Front doors should be locked.if my child was allowed to wander into the street when playing at your house I wouldn't be allowing her to come to yours to play alone. It was entirely YOUR responsibility.
Join the discussion
Please login first.