Talk

Advanced search

To not understand why someone from the UK with a British education would want to join an extremist organisation

(121 Posts)
Wowthishurtsalot Sun 09-Nov-14 18:14:59

I don't understand it. Moreso if they are 2nd and older generation British who could have conversations with their elders as to why they emigrated to the UK and the hope they had when they came here.

What is the attraction?

ItsAllGoingToBeFine Sun 09-Nov-14 18:20:04

I would guess they are somehow being marginalised in the UK, and want to feel a sense of belonging, the same reason nice middle class children join gangs.

hiddenhome Sun 09-Nov-14 18:20:52

They get to make friends and run around with guns?

Young people always believe they want to change the world and they have the time and energy to do it hmm

msrisotto Sun 09-Nov-14 18:21:50

I see it as rebellion against the discrimination they face living in the very country they were born.

bodhranbae Sun 09-Nov-14 18:25:55

It has nothing to do with ethnicity and religion.
Not really.
It is about confused, disenfranchised young men looking for adventure and somewhere to attach their rage and anger.
Extremist organisations only survive because of young angry men.
Plus some people really get off on violence. That is why war as a concept has never gone out of fashion.

Marylou2 Sun 09-Nov-14 18:27:54

They are brainwashed and radicalised by religious fanatics who despise the western way of life and our values of tolerance and equality. The failure of some religious and ethnic groups to integrate into British society can make their offspring easy targets.

hiddenhome Sun 09-Nov-14 18:28:20

Gah, all young men are angry. It's nothing to do with being marginalised.

I have a mini Marxist upstairs. He's always ranting and raving about stuff. It's the way their brains are wired up.

AesSedai Sun 09-Nov-14 18:36:25

It has nothing to do with ethnicity and religion.

I haven't heard of any local Baptists/Methodists joining up yet !

paxtecum Sun 09-Nov-14 18:37:49

I don't think the illegal Iraq war helped. In fact it probably started it.

Guantanamo Bay doesn't help. The torture of terrorist suspects carried out by the USA, but it doesn't seem to be illegal because it is in a US Naval Base in Cuba.

Of course it's ok, because the USA have God on their side.

Sunna Sun 09-Nov-14 18:38:41

It happened in Ulster as well, I believe their terrorists were supposedly Christians.

JanineStHubbins Sun 09-Nov-14 18:44:42

In the 1930s plenty of British Christians went off to fight in Spain; in the 1940s plenty of British and European Jews went off to fight in Palestine. The 'foreign fighter' phenomenon is not specific to one ethnicity or religion AesSedai

ghostyslovesheep Sun 09-Nov-14 18:46:10

they are young, idealistic, full of their own indestructibility and a sense of self righteousness

the young have always been a great source of canon fodder for extremists and not so extremists

plus if they are constantly being told they don't belong here ...

Wowthishurtsalot Sun 09-Nov-14 18:46:34

Well this is it its not just Muslim men is it. It's many other faiths or causes too.

I guess it might just be a case of angry young men needing a focus

Hassled Sun 09-Nov-14 18:46:47

I don't understand it either, but then I'm not a disenfranchised, dissatisfied youth from an ethnic minority - I don't think I can hope to understand, and that's where the problem lies.

ghostyslovesheep Sun 09-Nov-14 18:48:14

it's not just men

Wowthishurtsalot Sun 09-Nov-14 18:49:30

Very true ghosty

AesSedai Sun 09-Nov-14 18:50:29

The 'foreign fighter' phenomenon is not specific to one ethnicity or religion AesSedai

We're not talking about in the past Janine - we're talking about NOW. And 'now' it is not Ulster, or Spanish Freedom Fighters is it? They are long gone. Now it is young Muslims (let's be honest here what we are talking about).

The one difference between Ulster/Spanish/Isis is that you cannot return from Isis if you find it is not your idealised life after all. As those young women have no doubt found out - and brutally, at that.

TalkinPeace Sun 09-Nov-14 18:53:07

Faith Schools
often single sex
nothing to balance the junk they see on the interweb

the sooner ALL faith selection in state schools in the UK is ended the better

alemci Sun 09-Nov-14 18:57:17

perhaps an adventure like those young men in WW1 who signed up and in some cases to get away from their communities and parents who want to run their lives.

MistressMia Sun 09-Nov-14 18:58:42

Disenfranchised ... disaffected .... marginalised ... what bollocks.

Medics and other professionals and graduates have all gone over too. In fact the vast majority we hear about are all those with seemingly affluent or middle class backgrounds, in some cases privately educated, and with good prospects.

Well this is it its not just Muslim men is it. It's many other faiths or causes too. ... really which other faiths members are currently beheading, raping and crucifying people ?

WooWooOwl Sun 09-Nov-14 19:04:54

They go because they can see a different type of injustice. I think a lot of it goes back to Palestine. It is not unreasonable to feel that the British/American way isn't the right way, even if you were born here. Clearly, an appropriate reaction to feeling those things is not to go and join a terrorist organisation abroad, but people feel passionate about all sorts of things.

ItsAllGoingToBeFine Sun 09-Nov-14 19:07:52

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

specialsubject Sun 09-Nov-14 19:08:31

I saw a TV interview with the mother of one of these people. She had the guts to use the word 'brainwashed'. So should we.

I'm also slightly puzzled how young teens get the money and the passport to head off to Syria.

JanineStHubbins Sun 09-Nov-14 19:09:15

The Lords Resistance Army has a pretty nasty rap-sheet. So do Buddhist terrorist groups in Myanmar. Their activities don't get reported so much though.

bodhranbae Sun 09-Nov-14 19:09:21

Why does nobody mention the young men and women from all over the world who volunteer for combat roles with the Israeli Defence Forces?

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now