to be completely hing up on wanting a series of books.(37 Posts)
Join the discussion
Already registered? Log in with:
I know I should just move on but I can't get them out of my head.
I had a set of books as a child which I absolutely loce and really want the same set for when my ds is old enough but I know my chances of finding them are slim
it was a set of kids versions of classics like tom sawyer and huck finn in hardback.
it will be at least 15 years ago now - more like 20 id guess but I just can't shift the idea that i want the same set. Silly i know....
Have you tried second hand book shops? There's a lovely one near me that has a wonderful children's section, with books just like that.
I'm going to have a look on that website, thanks for that.
I don't fancy my chances out of all the books out there on the market and with it being so old but it's defo worth a shot.
May I just say [as a retired teacher and an avid reader/buyer of books for children aged 4-16] that there is little more likely to kill off a child's love of books than outdated abridged versions of so called 'classics' many of which weren't all that good to start with.Just try Coral Island or Children of the New Forest now.Even Treasure Island is hard going for most children and as for Robinson Crusoe and Gulliver....
Yes when you are an adult but there is such a wealth of wonderful stuff available for children that you don't need those tired old tales.I understand wanting to share things you loved as a child but maybe buy them for yourself and introduce them as read-aloud bedtime stories first.
My DD loved Children of the New Forest!!! And Treasure Island! I think that the old books still have a lot to give to modern readers. , If you enjoyed it as a child, then why not try tour DC on it. YANBU. [Tired old tales indeed]
thegraylady, I disagree.
My DC love all the ones you discard as 'old stories' as did I when their age.
Problem with vast majority of the 'current' books, a la Horrid Henry et al, is that they are badly written, with no literary merit whatsoever and more often than not use grossly simplistic vocabulary.
I work in a school and adore some of the kids books we have - story time is my baby!
but this set of books has stayed wuth me for the last 20 years so clearly hasn't kilked my love of books.
if only it stayed with me in tge literal sense too
I remember giving it away to my next door neighbour in one of my 'im too grown up for these now' phases. I nust have been about 12ish. im 29 now but I just cant seem to leave it behind.
my gm bought it for me and i would guess it came from either one of those book clubs (were they going then) or a bargain book store of some description.
my nan passed away so can't ask her and tge neighbour moved long ago so cant ask her. its so frustrating.
I hate Horrid Henry and the like. I love E Nesbit and Wind intheWillows, Winnie the Pooh and The Secret Garden, Bevis and Heidi and Tom's Midnight Garden Children of Green Knowe and The Wolves of Willoughby Chase. I read avidly as a child and have a huge collection of books which have been enjoyed by my dc and dgc and I am amazed that CotNF and Coral Island are enjoyed by children who have access to a wide range of books.
agree with The Greylady. i had hopes of my boys reading all the old classics I enjoyed and have tried to encourage them. They just don't want to. as soon as they realise it was written ... ago they turn off. They read a lot but love all the more modern authors and series.
Have resigned myself that Anne Of Green Gables, Little Women, Little house on The Prairie etc are especially no shows.
But Horrid Henry is for really young children so will be simplistic.
Kafri, was it by any chance the fake leather bound ones in blue, red and green?
begonia - anne of green gables is one of my favourites along with carries war and goodnight mr tom
oh the memories
I have them upstairs. And the magazines that went with them.
If its any help, I can look tomorrow and see who the publisher was, it might help you look for them? They were a series type thing from the newsagent, you got one every two weeks.
Children are different: some can't bear the old tales, others adore them.
Dd loved the classics.
Ds wasn't very keen on books at all- didn't take to the modern ones either, but Treasure Island (read aloud) made a deep impression.
I don't think the old/new thing mattered so much to them, more the fact that some books are simply a whole load better than others.
Another vote for lots of older books. Many of them are wonderful, some are not. Lots of modern books are crap, and some are great.
Don't assume all kids reject anything old- completely untrue.
Oh I know which ones you mean, I had them too. I probably do still have them somewhere.
They were lovely, but yes, very hard going for young children.
I love the old kids books. Ds is currently reading stig of the dump and loving it, and at bedtime we're working our way though the swallows and amazons series which he adores, although i have had to edit as i've read as i unexpectedly encountered the n-word the other night, which was a shock.
The N-word in swallows and Amazons? I read that to my DD, we did not encounter it! Maybe we had an edited version! S & A is brilliant. Ditto Stig of the Dump. I know the N-word is in Tom Sawyer, that is also a fantastic book. Glad to see that lots of children are still reading the old books.
Those tired old tales have been much loved by my dcs. Just William, Tom Sawyer, Half Magic, Five children and it. One's off to do Lit at uni this year, another will be off to do Lit at uni next year!
5 children and it and Stig ofbtue dump - id forgotten about those.
ne interesting to see if ds os into reading. I love it (and do read to him) while dh would never pick up a book. (unless its his football stats one)
When I was about that age they used to do cheap fake leather bound classics in wh smiths. They were red with gold embossed letters. I remember having Jane eyre. Does that sound like them? I'm 35 now, so about the right era.
What thegreylady said. From bitter experience.
Join the discussion
Already registered? Log in with:
Please login first.