To NOT want my children to get US passports?(146 Posts)
DH is American (by birth) but also has British citizenship. We met, live and had our children in UK. No current plans to move to US.
Children are entitled to get US passports as well as UK ones. But my understanding is that at same time they are issued with a social security number too and being US citizens has implications for future tax situation. US citizens are taxed on worldwide income, regardless of where they live.
I feel this could be a huge burden to place on our children when they may never choose to live or work in US. DH places significant value on US citizenship for them.
My father is US born, but resides in NZ, since he was 2. Recently, on booking travel to US, he was informed that due to being able to hold dual citizenship, he would pay astronomical fees every time he entered US soil. Once he took up dual citizenship, this charge was removed. As he is over 60, he's never registered for social security, and only pays income tax in NZ.
Why would you deprive your children of the benefits of an American passport?
The threshold for US taxation of expats is quite high ($95K if you live out of the US most of the time iirc).
If you were in a position where the IRS claimed you owed $5m in taxes, you would be able to afford shit hot lawyers to tell them what they could do with that. The IRS does not randomly decide that individuals owe them that sort of money.
In return for filling out your paperwork your DCs get the option of being able to move to and work in the US, and study there. Whatever you may think of the US wrt politics or culture or whatever, there are enormous upsides to all of that. They are not "benefits". They are real benefits.
My DCs, Americans all, have Irish passports too, giving them the option of moving to the EU to live and work, no questions asked.
Cutting off your nose to spite your face is always the silly option.
I'd kill for US passports. The benefit outweighs the cons.
@kursk it's a zombie thread... advertising it looks like
I would get them US passports without a second thought.
The tax issues are not as bad as they appear,
Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.
"Taxpayers with an AGI (Adjusted Gross Income) of $57,000 or less can electronically file their tax return for free using freefile. Taxpayers with an AGI greater than $57,000 can either use the Free File Fillable Forms or efile by purchasing commercial software. A limited number of companies provide software that can accommodate foreign addresses. To determine which will work best for you, get help choosing a software provider."
24/31 Grosvenor Square
London W1A 1 AE
Tu-Th: 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. & 2 p.m. to 4 p.m.
M-F: 9 a.m. to 12 p.m.
from same page
Also you may be able to exclude $95K of your foreign earned income if you meet certain conditions -- e.g. you live the vast bulk of your time in a foreign country.
You can't e-file with TurboTax. I think the sting is taking FEIE.
That's unless things have changed this year.
I don't think not being able to e-file is a show-stopper though.
You MUST use your US passport to enter the US. Both dh dd do this. Dh once tried to use hi UK passport because he forgot his US one. At immigration, they saw he was born in the US. To make it worse, it was clear dh was trying to hide the fact that he was in fact a US citizen not dh's finest hour. He was taken for questioning and strictly speaking, could have been deported on the next plane back. he got a stiff warning, and I had to hang around with dd for hours not knowing what on earth was going on.
So definitely you must enter on your US passport. We won't try that again anytime soon.
i would not go there on a different passport if you have a us passport.
sorry, i meant, do not go there on a different passport if they've decided you are a US citizen.
note: you may not have any say in this.
dabdab, good question.
extra revenue from having to have a us passport, and then you get embroiled in the tax situation. win-win for them.
they threatened to arrest my dh. he basically got out of it by saying that he's travelled there hundreds of times before, and does he (the immigration guy) really want to be the first to cause a stink? but he won't go there again.
also, born in the us, no us passport, no social security number.
i would not go there on a different passport if you have a us passport.
But why is it illegal for US citizens to enter on an alternative passport if they are dual? My dc are dual, and we are travelling to US this summer - I was wondering about not renewing and just having them travel on UK passports
because I would like to avoid the expense and the pain in the bum hours of waiting at Embassy for all 3 dc to get renewed
What will happen if we did travel on UK passports?
Thanks all. What a wealth of knowledge on MN! I'm going to speak to one of DH's partners who is also from the USA and ask him what he does, it seems that he's been diligently filing ever since he moved here many many years ago-- but that's because he intends to return one day, whereas I don't. However I don't want to burn any bridges. In the meantime I'm off to investigate how to get my hands on the tax forms, and talk to our company accountant about what I need to declare.
And Knowsabit I've just downloaded the application for DD, seems straightforward. We'll have a (hopefully) nice mother-and-daughter session going down to the Embassy for an appointment. And just in time as she's 18 in a few months, she can decide what she does after that!
You can't efile from overseas, ll.
You have to print out your return, sign it, and take it to the post office.
CAB can't help you.
There are some helpful ex-pat forums.
This is what i think is true (am not expert):
Don't panic. ExPats fail-to-file tax returns a lot, It's very common.
I wouldn't bother with that form.
Get hold of the right forms for the right tax year (I guess you owe for 2012?) and file them soon. Your return isn't due until June 2013 and you can even request a deadline extension until September, I think. If your income in 2011 was over threshold you'll just have to file late taxes for that year too and any previous when you made lots of money; there will be some late penalties paying tax owed but not outrageous.
If you never owed taxes in previous years you don't have to worry about failing to pay tax installments last year; but you will have to worry about paying tax instalments for 2013 if you'll continue to have income over the threshold (because you were liable for tax last year, iyswim). That part I find tricky!
I would probably try the stupid Turbotax thing just because of the convenience of e-filing. I've had experiences of bad advice from accountants so I would shy away from hiring one of them unless you think your situation is enormously complicated; I reckon I will pay less in penalties than I would to an accountant, and the accountant is never liable for any mistakes on your return, anyway. Technically you could sue accountant, but probably not worth it.
Your DS19 almost certainly does not have to file because he wouldn't owe anything, either (read upthread for details).
By the time you work thru allowances & deductions you may not owe for 2012, either. BUT if you can establish that now, then you will be in a good position whenever a year crops up that you do owe taxes, because you'll have paperwork to show you've been open & honest about previous income.
Don't forget that any tax-free savings you have in the UK (ISA's / Premium Bonds etc.) or tax-free benefits (child benefit etc.) are not tax-free from a US perspective, and need to be declared.
Many thanks Knowsabit, I guess they have an obligation to be reasonable! I suppose it cannot hurt to contact them as it's not like we've deliberately misled them and it seems like there are plenty of others in this situation. It's just the way the forms are written that makes me so nervous! I never minded doing returns when I was living there but that's because I usually got a refund.
Unless you want to move to the US within 3 years, don't worry about back taxes. Just start to get your affairs in order.
You basically need to keep calendar year records of your income, and then do a 1040 before June 15th next year. It's pretty easy if your finances are simple.
As for your 17 year old, you have a short time to get her Consular Report of Birth Abroad, which will establish her US citizenship.
If she decides at a later date that she wants to study or settle in the US, she will have her paperwork cut out (and expenses), whereas it is very easy to do it now while she is still under 18.
Oh no, I can feel my life imploding having (skim) read this thread... I am from the USA and haven't filed a return since we moved here 18 years ago. Last year due to being a director of OH's company I earned over the threshold, first time ever. Can anyone help me and tell me who I need to 'fess up to? The Embassy scares the life out of me. BTW I gained British citizenship a few years ago but haven't got a UK passport yet. I am cursing my laziness but hoping I can use 'I was just a housewife' and 'no one told me I had to' to excuse all those years of non communication.
BTW I had no idea re: the citizenship, I have one child born in the US and one in UK, I'd assumed that the UK born one's entitlement to US had expired as she's 17 and we are not really bothered about it, no desire to live/work there... and DS aged 19 needs to know that he should be filing! he won't thank me for that I suppose. I need to sort this out but don't want to spend £££ doing it... is the UK Citizen's Advice a good place to start or will they just send me to the embassy? [[http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-utl/non-resident_questionnaire.pdf] this] was the form I found via the embassy website and I cannot make heads or tails of it... professional advice will be needed I suppose. Just furious that it will cost me money for no point whatsoever.
Can we all claim political asylum if they demand unreasonable amounts of money?
Sorry OP haven't carefully read the whole thread (as I've been to busy having a minor heart attack imagining what sort of prison they'll put me in) what have you decided to do?
having a US parent is enough to confer US citizenship
not always, the rules are complicated.
I haven't heard of anyone actually being turned back for travelling on their non-US passport, but I have heard of a great many wink-wink-nudge-nudge heavy hints dropped liked bombs about "That child should have a US passport" from the Border Agency people. They are still human beings and appreciate children can't fix the situation there and then, so they can't say something overt. At least one friend had no idea what they were on about, though until I explained.
Some of this talk about filing taxes is scare-mongering. Uk is moving hard towards universal self-assessment too, anyway.
My dad always files his own taxes, he got audited by the IRS and WON. .
AFAIK it is illegal for a US citizen (and having a US parent is enough to confer US citizenship), to enter the US on a foreign passport. I'm assuming that your US DH has family there and will therefore wish to visit them with the DC at some point? If so, you should check very rigorously before you book your travel that you will not be breaking the law/risk being turned back at the border for having the wrong travel documents.
I know this because my DH is American and we faced a similar, though not identical, situation.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.