Advanced search

To think that bartering/trading goods and services is quite simply tax avoidance?

(47 Posts)
ShellyBoobs Sun 18-Nov-12 10:57:43

Someone on another thread was extolling the virtues of a friend who exchanges bookkeeping skills for goods. I've also seen advertising for companies who put people in touch with eachother for exactly this sort of trading to take place.

Is this not just tax avoidance in the same way as cash-in-hand tradespeople operate?

Am I missing something?

ImperialStateKnickers Sun 18-Nov-12 10:59:08

I've been told it's perfectly legal. But can't remember by whom.

ShellyBoobs Sun 18-Nov-12 11:03:49

Oh I don't doubt that it's legal - tax avoidance is also legal.

Bilbobagginstummy Sun 18-Nov-12 11:05:06

Barter transactions should still go through the books. This page explains about how to do it for VAT.

Not reporting income is evasion (not avoidance).

squeakytoy Sun 18-Nov-12 11:05:06

Would you have a problem with it though? I wouldnt.

Tax avoidance and tax evasion are two different things. The latter is a crime but as far as I am aware the former isnt.

Not declaring cash income is evasion, not avoidance.

ShellyBoobs Sun 18-Nov-12 11:07:13

Sorry, Imperial, my OP wasn't well worded.

When I mentioned cash-in-hand tradespeople, I was thinking of the situation where someone knows a joiner and he offers to hang a door for £20 one Sunday morning. Not the blatant 'pay cash and don't get a receipt' for £hundreds worth of business.

ShellyBoobs Sun 18-Nov-12 11:09:42

That's interesting, Bilbobaggins, I didn't think there would be a system for taxing barter transactions.

I should probably have looked into this a bit more. grin

OpheliaPayneAgain Sun 18-Nov-12 11:12:14

In our world, it's called 'doing someone a favour' - let me think, if friend A comes and plumbs my house, and DH goes and wires his house and no money exchanges hands, how is that a form of tax avoidance? It's called friendship.

mamij Sun 18-Nov-12 11:16:25

As Ophelia said. One person (A) has the skills to do something another person (B) needs doing, so A does person B a favour. Then B returns the favour later.

ShellyBoobs Sun 18-Nov-12 11:18:24

Yes, that's a barter system, mimij.

That's what we're discussing. confused

OpheliaPayneAgain Sun 18-Nov-12 11:18:48

Next door have a super house because of it - all in trades - one weekend you'll find 6 bare chested fit 20yos fenciung and laying turf, then it all goes quiet as the bloke next door is off returning 5 favours - roll on 6 weeks and they are all back doing a patio or decking.

I like it when it's his turn for renovations grin

OpheliaPayneAgain Sun 18-Nov-12 11:23:16

Quite common practice in some areas.

Next you'll be saying if Mrs X is neighbourly and gives a dozen eggs, when her neighbour is cooking and sends in a pot of jam, it should all go down on an income tax form

dreamingbohemian Sun 18-Nov-12 11:23:32

What a strange way of looking at it.

I think there should be more bartering of goods and services, especially at a time when everyone is skint and prices of everything keep going up and up.

You can't barter with HMRC or the landlord, at least you can with friends and neighbours.

mamij Sun 18-Nov-12 11:24:28

But I wouldn't really call it tax avoidance/evasion though...?

ImperialStateKnickers Sun 18-Nov-12 11:27:20

I do exchange services for services with some of my customers; I provide petcare, and they provide hairdressing, website design and support, bookkeeping, and private tuition for dds. I'm way under the VAT threshold, and when I added it all up it still didn't bring me over the tax threshold either, so HMRC aren't losing anything from me. My customer's accounts of course are none of my business, but since we're all skint, I doubt anyone's making millions out of this...

ShellyBoobs Sun 18-Nov-12 11:27:29

Next you'll be saying if Mrs X is neighbourly and gives a dozen eggs, when her neighbour is cooking and sends in a pot of jam, it should all go down on an income tax form

Yes, perhaps extreme but where should the line be drawn?

When I go to work, I exchange my skills for a wage from my employer. I'm taxed on that exchange.

When I worked in Finland for a year, part of my package was a 'free' house. I paid tax on that benefit. Wasn't I just exchanging part of my work for the use of a house that the company happened to own?

RuleBritannia Sun 18-Nov-12 11:28:28

If I keep a front foor key for a neighbour and have large packages put into her secure porch and she gives me a Sunday roast once a month, I have to report it to HMRC. What rubbish!

ShellyBoobs Sun 18-Nov-12 11:28:44

I'm thinking more of the income tax side of things, Imperial.

RuleBritannia Sun 18-Nov-12 11:28:47

Front door - not front foor. Sorry.

dreamingbohemian Sun 18-Nov-12 11:29:27

Actually I really hope this notion of bartering as tax avoidance doesn't take off.

All countries have informal economies, of varying sizes, and government generally tries to crack down on them because they're not taxable.

I would not put it past the Tories to start calling bartering 'tax avoidance' so they can continue to make life harder for people trying to cope and at the same time muddying the waters of all the big corporations engaged in the kind of tax avoidance that actually does hurt the economy.

ImperialStateKnickers Sun 18-Nov-12 11:29:52

So am I.

ShellyBoobs Sun 18-Nov-12 11:33:42

Look at it another way:

A normally earns a wage for plumbing and pays £100 per week in tax.

B normally earns a wage for joinery and pays £100 per week in tax.

A spends a week plumbing in a heating system for B in exchange for B spending a week fitting a new kitchen for A.

HMRC loses £200 in income tax.

What's the difference with them both just doing a week's work and not declaring the income?

strumpetpumpkin Sun 18-Nov-12 11:39:31

I cannot believe I am even reading this thread!!!

Why on earth would someone care fo someone was not declaring monetary tax on doing favours for favours??

christ on a bike

ImperialStateKnickers Sun 18-Nov-12 11:41:26

Isn't there a system operating in some areas called 'lets'? And I know in Bristol there's a local 'pound', which is a formalised bartering system. Am wandering off now to investigate...

Rudolphstolemycarrots Sun 18-Nov-12 11:44:02

It's an ancient thing and how communities used to operate. Used to happen way before tax man was invented!

Trading goods shows great community spirit and care. Why should everything hinge on money?

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: