Advanced search

to find my family planning teacher unprofessional??

(34 Posts)
firefly11 Mon 15-Oct-12 19:38:01

I have been going to one-to-one NFP (Natural Family Planning) sessions at the local sexual health clinic. I just wanted to learn how to tell my fertility signs from charting, observation of bodily signs like mucus, cervical position, body temperature, etc. as hormonal contraception doesn't agree with me too well and DH doesn't like wearing condoms (Though he will if we have sex because I insist).. Although we have no current or forseeable plans to conceive as we already have 3 DCs and they are keeping us busy. But I wouldn't rule out having another child in future since we are still in our early 30s. Before I took up the course, I thought about just learning this from a book but since I was advised that its best I learn from a trained NFP teacher, I decided to do just that.

Me and DH don't have a very active sex life. It's been like this always, we have been together 10 + years and we are close and talk to each other a lot, but just don't get around to having sex that much. The thing is if we tell our friends this, some of them just think this is odd, but at least they don't make rude comments at this. But this NFP teacher I'm seeing (who happens to be a midwife by profession) always asks me if we had unprotected sex every time I see her - I see her once a month btw - have seen her 3 times now so I think it is towards the end of the course.. Fair enough, it may be her job as a NFP teacher at a sexual health clinic to make sure no babies are accidentally conceived during the course of learning NFP, but when I say "no", she asks if I have had sex at all, and for the past 3 times, each time I told her "no" to that, she makes some sort of remark about it. The first time she was just incredulous, to which I politely explained that's natural for us, and it doesn't bother us at all. Then she said okay, yea, different strokes for different folks, blah blah.

The second time I saw her, she started laughing when I told her "no" again to her "did you have sex" question. I started feeling like that was a bit... odd. Rude, in fact.

The third time I saw her, same question again, and I answered the same. Then she shook her head and made a HUGE sigh and smiled wryly.

Now am I right or wrong in thinking she is being unprofessional with her reactions?

NatashaBee Mon 15-Oct-12 19:42:28

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

firefly11 Mon 15-Oct-12 19:51:34

I thought it was rude too but wasn't sure if I was just being oversensitive!

I don't know what the class is targetted for but I got on it after I called the local sexual health clinic asking if they could refer me to any NFP teachers in the area and they promptly signed me up to this,for free I might add. So I took it up, thought it was great that it was free as I was prepared to pay. But well, it's not perfect .. but I have learnt a lot in the 3 sessions I've been there and it has been a real eye opener for me in regards to knowing my body better.. I have really benefitted from this. Just don't know what to say to her the next time as it is almost inevitable she will ask the same thing again I think! Unfortunately she seems to be the only NFP teacher in the clinic so not like I can switch.

Pourquoimoi Mon 15-Oct-12 20:11:32

I guess she's wondering if you trust or have tried her methods yet? I don't know but either way I do think it's rude. Couples have sex at different frequencies and really it's none of anyone else's business.

Floggingmolly Mon 15-Oct-12 20:36:26

Maybe she's so wondering why you're so interested in contraception if you rarely have ex?

Floggingmolly Mon 15-Oct-12 20:36:49


eurowitch Mon 15-Oct-12 20:41:49

She's rude. I'd go for the MN phrase.

maybenow Mon 15-Oct-12 20:46:10

Yes, it is a bit rude, but she might be wondering if you need any family planning as it might be sounding like you don't actually have any sex life. Have you told her how often you normally have sex? I guess she might be thinking you're either not in a sexual rleationship or that you're lying to her.

maybenow Mon 15-Oct-12 20:47:07

blush just realised my reply sounds more rude than the teachers. Sorry. I didn't mean it to.. DH and I don't have sex that often but I think that 3 months without would seem a long time to most people.

RubyCreakingGates Mon 15-Oct-12 20:52:46

Very rude. I can't remember the last time we had sex... about 4 times in the last 4 and a half years, and it's nobody's business but ours!

Have you read this?

It has absolutely all you need to know, you can learn in the comfort of your own home, and it doesn't ask personal questions later.

lovebunny Mon 15-Oct-12 20:57:58

its the trouble you always have with nurse types. they're abominable for teaching sex ed too, as they assume everyone has to have sex all the time - no matter how young - and that they should all experience a wide range of positions and practices. i think they're just over-trained. well meaning, but they spend too much time focused on this stuff.

you and your dh seem to have worked out a pattern that suits you and brings babies into the world. well done.

firefly11 Tue 16-Oct-12 13:01:07

Thanks for the replies. We do have a sex life, just very infrequent to most people. That's not to say we don't need contraception, because look what we produced - 3 kids, sex life or not! The fact is I cannot take well to hormonal contraception and he is not happy with condoms or vasectomy, so the best solution to this is NFP imo, especially since we don't have sex that much anyway so the risks of pregnancy on this method is less. Why pump myself full of artificial hormones all year round and endure the nasty side effects it has on me, or have ourselves sterilised when we may want another child in future? Whatever her opinion of how we conduct our sex life, her response has been inappropriate I think. She should keep it to herself. The next time I see her I'm definitely using the MN line.

struggling100 Tue 16-Oct-12 13:07:45

Yes, that's inappropriate. I don't see why she needs to ask those questions anyway - it has nothing to do with the class. Also, everyone is very different, and she should respect that.

An alternative old-fashioned suggestion: you could get a diaphragm fitted. No hormones, but really quite reliable all the same when used correctly. smile

firefly11 Tue 16-Oct-12 13:25:01

I've never really considered the diaphragm before as I thought it might hurt or make my menstrual cramping worse - as tampons tend to do for me, but thanks struggling100, will do more research into that and see if it might suit me :-)

didldidi Tue 16-Oct-12 13:34:04

perhaps she a) doesn't believe you or b) thinks you're wasting her time. Either way it's not appropriate to comment. Would second the TCOYF book though it's really good.

eurowitch Tue 16-Oct-12 13:38:06

You only use a diaphragm when you dtd (and for a while after) so I don't see why it should affect menstrual cramping (unless you tend to dtd when you have period cramps?).

firefly11 Tue 16-Oct-12 13:55:23

What is "dtd"?

firefly11 Tue 16-Oct-12 14:00:53

Hmm if she doesn't believe me then perhaps I should just lie and say I did have sex the next time I see her then, if I haven't! Wouldn't that make life easier.

ClippedPhoenix Tue 16-Oct-12 14:21:33

She's a nosey one isn't she OP! YANBU.

HoldMeCloserTonyDanza Tue 16-Oct-12 15:11:51

"I would prefer not to answer such personal questions".

With a hmm look to suggest you think she's a bit of a weirdo.

That is the possibly unhelpful way I'd handle it.

NeedlesCuties Tue 16-Oct-12 16:10:21

DTD = do the deed (sex).

firefly11 Tue 16-Oct-12 17:30:36

Oh right, I see lol... I was thinking of that other contraceptive device where it stays in your body until the doctor removes it. Okay. Will have to try this one but it looks uncomfortable.

bachsingingmum Tue 16-Oct-12 18:11:14

I've used a diaphragm since I was 18 (over 30 years ago - not the same one obviously!) Absolutely fine once you've had a bit of practice and not at all uncomfortable. Ideal for occasional use. Two children when we wanted them and no accidents.

CharlotteWasBoth Wed 17-Oct-12 00:38:58

Very rude 'tude from the nurse.

You could also ask 'Why are you asking?'

Btw a very happy NFP user here -- worth persevering.

RubyCreakingGates Wed 17-Oct-12 08:15:31

I forgot to say that I find NFP very effective for both purposes! (we did used to have sex more often, honest)

It really helped when they wanted to induce DS2, and I was able with pinpoint accuracy to tell them when he was conceived! (Despite their outraged "but we have growth charts!").

Even if you don't intend to use the method TCOYF is an excellent de-mystifying "Haynes manual" of the femal reproductive system. I'd go so far as ro say every person in possession of a set of ovaries should read it.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: