Advanced search

to avoid having MIL for Xmas day?

(36 Posts)
kerpob Sun 14-Oct-12 19:27:04

I know it's early for this - sorry! PIL got divorced this year. FIL just rang DH warning us "not to allow MIL to be on her own for Xmas day". We have two children with SNs. MIL when she comes to see us (about once/twice per year at most) is an absolute hindrance and gives no help whatsoever. She is very stressful to be around. On the other hand she is quite down after events of this year. She lives in another part of UK so if she came would be here for several days and not just a few hours. AIBU to think it's rich for FIL to lecture us about what we should be doing when he is absolving self from all responsibility for her? (divorce due to his infidelity btw).

Nanny0gg Sun 14-Oct-12 19:28:57

Does your DH have siblings?

kerpob Sun 14-Oct-12 19:32:03

Yeah one in the USA sad

dickiedavisthunderthighs Sun 14-Oct-12 19:32:47

It depends if the alternative is that she's on her own. YANBU to not want FIL to lecture you but at the same time your DH's mum has got divorced because her H was unfaithful and Christmas will be pretty wretched if she's not with family I'd imagine.

Flisspaps Sun 14-Oct-12 19:33:55

What does MIL want to do? She might want to spend the day on her own, or have made plans to see friends (and FIL wouldn't know about her plans, I assume)

Katisha Sun 14-Oct-12 19:34:18

Think you're going to have to have her really. Unless she might fancy a complete break in a hotel with a friend?

hermioneweasley Sun 14-Oct-12 19:34:35

Yes, I think it is cheeky of FIL to lecture where his wife is concerned, but she is your husband's mother- can you really bear to let her be alone at xmas after a divorce? Surely you can grin and bear it for a few days? You say she doesn't give any help, but she doesn't sounds wicked or awful, just useless.

londone17 Sun 14-Oct-12 19:35:18

Ask her what her plans are?

Trills Sun 14-Oct-12 19:35:50

FIL can fuck off, he can't tell you what to do.

But if she really is going to be on her own then it'd be nice to try to include her.

LadyFlumpalot Sun 14-Oct-12 19:37:40

OP, I completely see why you are hacked off about it, and yes, very cheeky of FIL!

However, maybe this is one year that your MIL's needs should come before your desires for Xmas.

You may find that she will have changed, or, that she will be more willing to talk and join in.

I think, if she wants her family around her this year, she should. By all means stamp about it on here, Facebook etc, but be welcoming to her.

kerpob Sun 14-Oct-12 19:38:06

She has siblings closer than we are - think tbh she would jump at the chance to spend it with us. She is pretty difficult and DH and I spend the time when she's here, counting to ten and biting our tongues -dread spending all of our Xmas break doing this sad

Mollydoggerson Sun 14-Oct-12 19:38:19

I think you need to offer it up.

You could go to her, in that way only stay one night.

Blu Sun 14-Oct-12 19:38:55

Would she cancy a trip to the USA if you all chipped in for her fare? For a treat...

I think you might have to make generosity your thing this year, without establishing it as a habit.

What does your DH think?

And yes, it is cheeky of FIL. But that doesn't make it unreasonable to think about her.

kerpob Sun 14-Oct-12 19:41:44

He's not looking forward to the prospect either - don't want it to become a habit either. One year she came to us and stayed for nine bloody days. I was ready to top myself at the end of it...

myBOYSareBONKERS Sun 14-Oct-12 19:43:21

Arrives Christmas Eve afternoon and home day after boxing day. That's all it needs to be

CarnivorousPanda Sun 14-Oct-12 19:44:41

Lets just say I have similar issues...

How about inviting her just for a day or two, but also inviting over other people to dilute things a bit? If she has just gone through a divorce it would be the kind thing to do.

Also try to get out, even for a morning walk as I think it helps .

MollyMurphy Sun 14-Oct-12 19:46:03

She's having a hard time and she's family....I'd lump it up and invite her.

usualsuspect3 Sun 14-Oct-12 19:46:56

I think you should have her. Poor woman. Shes not just the MIL shes your DPs mother and your childrens grandma.

kerpob Sun 14-Oct-12 19:47:07

ok....hear the consensus smile will come on here to do loads of ranting..........

ThompsonTwins Sun 14-Oct-12 19:47:14

Kerpod, indeed it's rich for FIL to lecture you - presumably to make him feel better. However, if MIL would be alone at Christmas (if she has no plans) I would invite her. You could, however, have a conversation with her first, asking her to undertake certain tasks while she is with you. You could explain that the needs of your children are greater these days so it would be really helpful if she would for e.g. do all dishwasher/washing up duties while with you and/or tidying away toys at bedtime, helping with food preparation in whatever capacity suits her abilities as a cook etc. This will be a difficult Christmas for her but there is no reason for her to make it more difficult for you. Hope it works out OK.

ImperialBlether Sun 14-Oct-12 19:50:29

He's got a bloody nerve! He dumped her and now he expects you to put up with her!

If you have to have her, make it a short visit. Better for you to go to hers for Christmas Day (drive up on Christmas Eve afternoon and return Boxing Day morning) than to have her to yours for several days.

LadyFlumpalot Sun 14-Oct-12 19:53:04

OP, have her - but start lots of cathartic threads on here. Just be sure to head then with "I know I AM being unreasonable, but I need to rant in a safe place" so that people don't flay you alive!

kerpob Sun 14-Oct-12 19:54:27

We live in Ireland so it would involve ferry travel and due to the kids' SNs staying anywhere else is hellish so it looks like her coming to us - but maybe as other posters have suggested if we book it for her and keep it short then it will be best of both worlds for all

hermioneweasley Sun 14-Oct-12 19:56:13

Well done kerpob. I promise to listen to you rant!

alphabite Sun 14-Oct-12 19:57:30

She's family. She is your husbands Mum. Would you like your Mum to be alone at Christmas?

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: