Talk

Advanced search

To think Revolting Rhymes is not suitable for 5 years olds?

(52 Posts)
fosterdream Sat 13-Oct-12 12:27:00

I quote;

'Poor Cindy's heart was torn to shreds.
My Prince! She thought. He chops off heads!
How could I marry anyone
Who does that sort of thing for fun?
The Prince cried, "Who's this dirty slut?
Off with her nut! Off with her nut!'
― Roald Dahl, Revolting Rhymes

and

'Oh where, oh where had Snow White gone?
She'd found it easy, being pretty
To hitch a ride into the city.'
― Roald Dahl, Revolting Rhymes

I bought it for my nephew for Christmas and had a quick read and was shocked when poor Cinderella was called a slut and told her head would be chopped off!

I called up the book people and have a refund but I'm still very shocked it was for ages 5+ is this unreasonable?

ReallyTired Sat 13-Oct-12 12:28:43

lol... five year olds hear worse stuff in the play ground.

I think you are being a bit over precious.

WitchesWreakinHavoc Sat 13-Oct-12 12:30:43

I am not precious at all but would be mortified if my 6yo ds was reading the word slut in a childrens book.

ItsAllGoingToBeFine Sat 13-Oct-12 12:30:56

Littlies love that sort of stuff!

ItsAllGoingToBeFine Sat 13-Oct-12 12:32:34

Plus slut = one with slovenly or dirty habits, so no sex reference if that's your concern.

snooter Sat 13-Oct-12 12:33:08

Reading the word 'slut' is fine - it's when you're asked to explain it that the problems start...

nickeldaisical Sat 13-Oct-12 12:33:12

nah, it's funny.

i read it to a group of Rainbows last week and they thought it was hilarious grin

snooter Sat 13-Oct-12 12:33:35

Although agree yes it doesn't have to be sexual

vigglewiggle Sat 13-Oct-12 12:34:31

I would interpret the word "slut" as per the "slattern" type of definition rather that the sexual reference.

I therefore think you are over-reacting.

vigglewiggle Sat 13-Oct-12 12:35:09

X posts

IneedAgoldenNickname Sat 13-Oct-12 12:35:11

We have then on DVD, neither of my sons (8 and 5) have ever picked up on the word slur, but agree its not a sexual reference

poachedeggs Sat 13-Oct-12 12:35:36

YABU.

ErrorError Sat 13-Oct-12 12:38:45

The reference to slut I believe is the original definition of the word "a dirty, untidy or slovenly woman", which in the case of Cinderella is entirely appropriate in this context. If you're bothered by the sexually promiscuous connotation of the word, then wait a couple of years if it really bothers you. I was 8 when I got this book, understood it fully, and loved it!

ErrorError Sat 13-Oct-12 12:39:42

x-posts from me too!

HappyAsEyeAm Sat 13-Oct-12 12:40:53

It doesn't sit well with me either, OP. I would definitely avoid it with my nearly 5yo. But not just because of the choice of words, I also think it would terrify him! That said, I had a copy of Revolting Rhymes as a child (but I think I was probably about 8 yo) and I can't remember 'slut' appearing in it, so it couldn't have made a bad impression.

fosterdream Sat 13-Oct-12 12:41:22

But Roald Dahl didn't make the rhymes to be published so I believe he made them for himself and adults friends.

So how about the quote about snow white is it really appropriate for five year old's to read that been pretty will get you somewhere in life without having to try?

fortifiedwithtea Sat 13-Oct-12 12:47:36

YANBU. And if 6yr olds hear worse in the playground that is sad.

fosterdream Sat 13-Oct-12 12:48:00

Also the word slut is no longer means "a dirty, untidy or slovenly woman" you all know what it means in general.

derekthehamster Sat 13-Oct-12 12:50:12

I quite like the old fashioned meaning, I often refer to myself as a slut (as in slattern)

My dcs have had this book since ds was 4. They don't notice what adults notice.

Personally I think it's suitable. If you don't then don't read it with/to your kids.

fosterdream Sat 13-Oct-12 12:53:17

Hamster I agree the olden words are much better I called myself gay the other day to DH and my DD said it at school shock

I've never heard swear words at DD school

Himalaya Sat 13-Oct-12 12:54:31

I used to love that book. I think 5 is probably a bit young to get the humour. Just leave it on the shelf for a couple of years.

fosterdream Sat 13-Oct-12 12:57:50

Hima I found the book funny and have been told that they won't be sorting a return so I get to keep it, giving it to my 30 year old BIL for Christmas we all ways get him some sort of shite and I don't want it on my shelf DD can read

Himalaya Sat 13-Oct-12 13:00:41

I remember putting these on as skits with my friends when we were about 9 grin

werewolvesdidit Sat 13-Oct-12 13:05:21

My kids (6 and 3) loved this book. What they don't understand goes over their heads smile I'm not into censorship of books.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now