Talk

Advanced search

to think that there is NEVER an acceptable reason to call a 32 year old woman a "young girl?"

(794 Posts)
Hullygully Thu 20-Sep-12 18:13:36

No I'm not.

I couldn't care less what emotive flannel is flung about.

IT. IS.NOT.ACCEPTABLE.

The end.

TheGoldenKnid Thu 20-Sep-12 18:14:33

YANBU.

Hullygully Thu 20-Sep-12 18:15:12

I know.

TheGoldenKnid Thu 20-Sep-12 18:15:31

So do I. smile

Hullygully Thu 20-Sep-12 18:16:12

That's us two then, Kniddy.

So far.

OutragedAtThePriceOfFreddos Thu 20-Sep-12 18:16:17

YANBU.

If I want to kid myself that I am still a young girl at 34, then you are just being mean to try and stop me.

So ner.

TheGoldenKnid Thu 20-Sep-12 18:16:26

But I have a feeling our happy little consensus will be disturbed any moment now. sad

OutragedAtThePriceOfFreddos Thu 20-Sep-12 18:17:08

That was meant to be YABU. blush

See! I still only have the sense of someone younger!

JamieandTheMagicTorch Thu 20-Sep-12 18:17:12

Hi Hully.

I don't feel as annoyed or whatever as you seem to, but I do wonder about it. I do think, whilst very kindly meant, it is patronising and therefore indicative of the fact that women are not taken a seriously as men.

But, in this instance, context is everything. Intent is everything, and the intent was to convey warmth. I can't really get that excited about it in this instance

Hullygully Thu 20-Sep-12 18:17:13

We will have them with unassailable logic and reason and fight the forces of hogwash and flummery

scarletforya Thu 20-Sep-12 18:17:26

I wish someone would call me a young girl, I get called "the lady" and even worse "madam" sad

Hullygully Thu 20-Sep-12 18:18:00

That is up to you James.

Of course.

MrsTerrysChocolateOrange Thu 20-Sep-12 18:18:14

I hate girl, it's so infantilising. Young, however, I will take in a heartbeat although at 39 it's been a while.

spookytoo Thu 20-Sep-12 18:18:20

I get called 'lass' sometimes by people and I'm 59. Don't know what it is - maybe I seem a bit unsure about what I'm doing at the time or is it the way I speak?

Ragwort Thu 20-Sep-12 18:18:34

I got called a 'young girl' the other day - I am 54 grin.

My mother and her friends (all in their 80s) talk about their 'get-togethers for the girls' - have just bought them one of those rude cartoon cards 'girls just want to have fun' or similar !!

expatinscotland Thu 20-Sep-12 18:18:42

My mate's a physician and professor in her early 60's. She was in the corridor with her colleague, also a physician and mother of 6 in her mid-40's. A patient's parent walked by and said, 'Hi, girls!' They were not amused. grin

TheGoldenKnid Thu 20-Sep-12 18:18:48

I fear I'm too tired for unassailable logic and reason. sad Couldn't we just ignore anybody who disagrees with us?

Hullygully Thu 20-Sep-12 18:19:03

I wouldn't call a 32 yr old man a "young boy" to convey warmth.

Everyone would think I'd gone bonkers.

Let us be honest.

crashdollGOLD Thu 20-Sep-12 18:19:05

I'm 24 and got called young lady today (in a non patronising way) and I thought it was alright.

PeggyCarter Thu 20-Sep-12 18:19:37

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Hullygully Thu 20-Sep-12 18:20:43

It's not that I'm really annoyed, although I am a bit, it's everyone saying it's all right that annoys me.

It's not all right. The context is irrelevant. It just isn't all right.

That does not take away in ANY WAY fromt eh terrible sadness of what happened to those two police officers.

BadgersRetreat Thu 20-Sep-12 18:20:47

i get ma'am

god

SammyTheSwedishSquirrel Thu 20-Sep-12 18:21:25

Wish someone would call me a young girl. sad

MrsTerrysChocolateOrange Thu 20-Sep-12 18:21:40

You'd love Mark Kermode, then Hully. When someone referred to his wife as Mrs Kermode" he asked, "do you mean Dr Williams?". Mmmmm men like that make me happy.

MardyBra Thu 20-Sep-12 18:22:14

YANBU. I do wonder whether there is a regional thing going on though. It might be more acceptable in some parts of the country in a colloquial situation. It should never be used in professional context IMO.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now