Talk

Advanced search

Im not BU but this was BU (wasn't it???)

(60 Posts)
troisgarcons Sat 22-Oct-11 21:11:24

I was in a department store today with my 11yo and I was tapped on the shoulder. Turned round and a lady ratted her tin under my nose with a "NSPCC, donate please". I just said take this one and I'll find you two more at home "No thanks".

But the more I think about it, she really shouldnt have (a) touched me (b) directly asked me (c) caused my mind to wander when pondering the merits of new bathroom towels.

I'm far too bone idle to write/email to the charity and the store - but it was a bit off wasn't it?

carabos Sat 22-Oct-11 21:12:41

YANBU

ScarahStratton Sat 22-Oct-11 21:13:12

You were chugged inside a department store? shock

They're bold where you are, I'll give them that.

Shutupanddrive Sat 22-Oct-11 21:14:06

YANBU

Cantilever Sat 22-Oct-11 21:14:14

I would have been a bit miffed too. Anyway, when I was recently collecting for a charity we were told that it's not permitted (by law or local council regulations presumably, I'm not sure which) to rattle the collection tin.

badoomtish Sat 22-Oct-11 21:14:45

YANBU

AgentZigzag Sat 22-Oct-11 21:15:16

You are being a little prickly about it, but I can kind of see in the right circumstances it might have annoyed me a little at the time.

But I wouldn't have thought about it afterwards, she was just trying to help out.

IDontDoIroning Sat 22-Oct-11 21:16:35

I have done bag packing in supermarkets to fundraiser for various dc activities and we have always been told no bucket rattling / tin shaking at customers, dont pester our customers and be respectful if they don't wish to donate.
This sounds totally off and you should consider contacting the store to complain.

scarevola Sat 22-Oct-11 21:16:53

She can only collect in store with permission of the store's management, so f that ever happens again, ask to see the manager and say exactly why this intrusiveness ruined your shopping experience and has led you to leave th store empty handed.

Also, I think (but stand ready to be corrected) that tin rattling is banned, so it might be worth getting in touch with th charity giving location, date and time, and say how concerned you are that collectors who break the law risk giving them a bad name.

Then go and make a donation to a charity whose aims and conduct you support.

troisgarcons Sat 22-Oct-11 21:17:05

It didnt unduly upset me - its only just popped back into my head some 8 hours later - I just thought it was a bit off!

tottiesfortea Sat 22-Oct-11 21:17:47

I hate when they shake the tin under my nose. I do give cash to charitys, but only to the ones that DON'T shove it in my face.

worraliberty Sat 22-Oct-11 21:20:31

YANBU

The stand outside my local supermarket but they never approach or hassle people. They don't even speak actually...jut give the tin a gentle rattle now and then so people know they're there.

MumblingAndBloodyRagDoll Sat 22-Oct-11 21:20:35

Oooh I would have told her! I HATE being tapped on the shoulder!

topsyturner Sat 22-Oct-11 21:21:02

I am currently bald from chemo (breast cancer) and I have a whale of a time embarressing cancer charity collectors !
They wave their tins under my nose , then look up at me and almost run away !

But I am a cruel bugger grin

AgentZigzag Sat 22-Oct-11 21:21:09

In my mind, the fact that it was a charity volunteer would make me give her a bit of leeway in how she was.

It's maybe difficult for some organisations to enforce the rules about tin rattling etc, when they're relying on their goodwill.

I'm not saying that's right, or all volunteers are like this, but you can tell and tell someone something, but if you don't have the authority over them that a paid employer would have, what can you do?

thefirstMrsDeVeerie Sat 22-Oct-11 21:27:53

I wasnt allowed to rattle my tin or ask for donations either. Made it quite hard to get noticed outside tescos!

I have heard some shockers. One bloke stood inside the shopping centre shouting on 'money for the handicapped' and a lady in a wheelchair sat next to him with a sign round her neck (I am not making this up)

Another one I heard in a sing song voice, over and over 'Kids with CANNNNCEEER, Kids with CANNNNCEEEER'

Neither of them got my money and I am usually pretty generous hmm

I dont think she should have approached you in that way but maybe she got fed up with being ignored by everyone. It can be pretty sould destroying doing a street collection.

feelingratheroverwhelmed Sat 22-Oct-11 21:28:04

I remember being told that it was illegal to rattle tins when I was a RAG member at university, and finding this rather odd! But, I don't think you should be tapped on the shoulder and have a tin shook in your face, that would have annoyed me too.

uselessbillynomates Sat 22-Oct-11 21:32:58

standing with a tin is, apparently, within the law but rattling the tin makes it, legally, begging - I think.

Sirzy Sat 22-Oct-11 21:36:04

It isn't hard to make sure your collectors don't rattle tins, and they certainly shouldn't be being rude like that. Volunteer or not they are still representing the charity and I am sure if they found out they would have words with them about how they conduct themselves in future.

Anyone collecting should have been briefed on what was allowed and what isn't

AgentZigzag Sat 22-Oct-11 21:36:31

The NSPCC/Childline are probably at the point of having to beg for it useless sad

Cheeseandseveredfingersarnie Sat 22-Oct-11 21:38:36

yanbu.id have asked the store manager if they knew this was happening in store.

worraliberty Sat 22-Oct-11 21:40:46

I don't think the store manager would have been happy if he/she knew this...because if one collector acted like that, well others could too.

That would be a perfect reason for me to avoid that shop all together.

Henrythehappyhelicopter Sat 22-Oct-11 21:46:20

I feel the end justifies the means.

troisgarcons Sat 22-Oct-11 21:47:56

You cant email the NSPCC - not without making a donation and requesting a friend does so too. hmm

shockers Sat 22-Oct-11 21:53:44

It is sad, but charity collectors make me want to run in the opposite direction. I give willingly to 4 charities by DD... I shouldn't have to explain that on the street. However, I once tried when a charity collector (who was actually from one of my 4!) asked me to sign up, on the street. The collector came close to accusing me of lying... he actually asked for proof! It's a blimmin good job that I support this charity for reasons of my own, or I would have stopped my DD there and then... cheeky bugger.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now