Talk

Advanced search

To be annoyed DH just said 'you need to give him a bottle'?

(71 Posts)
Ams25 Mon 17-Oct-11 06:35:51

my DS2 is EB, and at the moment is waking every couple of hours for a feed. I think this is manageable, since we co-sleep and I am still managing to get a reasonable amount of sleep (usually!) so I can get up with DS1 at 6 am. This morning my DH said dismissively 'you just need to start giving him a bottle'. This has annoyed me on so many levels I hardly know where to start. Both my children have been EB, I have always been the one to get up with them, my DH goes to the spare room if the baby disturbs him, he knows I don't want to formula feed (or need to come to that!) and this just makes me feel like he doesn't listen to me or understand anything about me as a mother!

TanteRose Mon 17-Oct-11 06:38:58

tell him if he feels so strongly about it, HE can go out and buy bottles/formula/sterilising kit, and then get up every two hours in the night, go to the kitchen, prepare a bottle (while trying to keep a hungry baby calm), feed him, settle him, wash bottles, sterilise bottles....etc. etc.

sorry he is being such a twunt

prioneyes Mon 17-Oct-11 06:45:00

His justification is ...? Surely he can't think that milk from an alternative source will magically prevent night wakings? hmm

BullyBeefBadgers Mon 17-Oct-11 06:47:48

Men always do this don't they. With me it was the other way around. I was desperately trying to BF DD, getting up all hours through the night, and DD still couldn't get enough milk. Her weight was dropping and then she hit a growth spurt and I was told I didn't have enough milk to feed her. DP says dissmissively that I should try harder and he wouldn't allow formula. Took me a whole day to get my hormones in check long enough to not cry at him and tell him to fuck off.

Just tell him that he's not the one feeding her so he doesn't need to worry about it. And that actually formula doesn't help with the nighttimes!!

Andrewofgg Mon 17-Oct-11 06:55:36

Men always do this don't they.

No, Bully, we don't. I'm no angel but I can say I enjoyed feeding (ff of course!) my now adult DS and tht included nights. My BILs had the same experience. There's something wrong where the work is not shared.

scarevola Mon 17-Oct-11 06:59:26

Maybe what you are interpreting as "dismissively" is actually the voice of concern.

We do not see things clearly or objectively when we are long-term sleep deprived.

TheTenantOfWildfellHall Mon 17-Oct-11 07:02:42

Well said Andrew!

I BF and other than ask if there was anything he could do to support it, my DH passed no comment at all.

OP, there were days with my 2 when I was up all night feeding, lying on the sofa all day just feeding. That's pretty much what babies do! Tell him you're happiest BF and there's no reason to change it.

CogitoErgoSometimes Mon 17-Oct-11 07:04:29

I'm with scarevola. Rather than getting defensive, what is the reason for the remark? Lack of sleep is a total killer. He may be struggling or he may be worried that you are struggling and his idea is therefore borne out of concern rather than criticism of your methods per se.

Forrestgump Mon 17-Oct-11 07:13:52

Agree with cogito and scarevola. You might be thoroughly enjoying it, but he probably sees a different side. Co sleeping may work for you, but maybe he is struggling. My dh happily helped in the night with a bottle when that time came, after all baby has 2 parents.

nooka Mon 17-Oct-11 07:14:52

I can't see how the dh would be struggling if he has another room to go to if he is disturbed, and the OP says she is doing fine. So I think it is perfectly reasonable for the OP to be annoyed. How old is your ds2, and sorry to be a bit of an ignoramus, but what does EB stand for? Is it extended breastfeeding and your son is having a bit of a relapse as it were?

flamegirl77 Mon 17-Oct-11 07:15:38

I would be very cross if my husband said this to me.

TanteRose Mon 17-Oct-11 07:19:38

EB is Exclusively Breastfed, nooka smile

Ams25 Mon 17-Oct-11 07:21:34

He always wants the easy answers... Has got it in his head that giving a bottle of formula before bed will make him sleep through. I know this is rubbish, because I tried it in desperation with DS1 when he was 5 months and it made no bloody difference!

Bully what a total swine... Like we all need more guilt in our lives!

mummytotwoboys Mon 17-Oct-11 07:21:55

YAB a bit U Maybe he meant express some so he could help. I know my husband hated me breastfeeding as he saw me knackered and in his "male" brain the solution was that he should help. Maybe he is thinking about you and you shouldnt be so defensive. Also, it is his baby too and maybe he should get a bit of a say in how its fed. You dont want to formula feed, maybe he does. . . just saying grin

pregnantpause Mon 17-Oct-11 07:23:37

Not unreasonable to be annoyed. His comment was ignorant and unhelpful at best, dismussive and condescending at worst. However as others have said sleep deprivation is a killer(although it sounds like he gets plenty) and he could just bit have thought it through. Talk to him, explain that what he said was insensitive and ill informed, well done for feeding your dcs the best way that you can x

callmemrs Mon 17-Oct-11 07:23:57

Erm.... It is entirely possible to exclusively give breast milk but for the baby to sometimes drink from a bottle (or cup). I think the op is being unreasonable for automatically equating bottle with formula! Speaks volumes!
This is not the ops baby- the baby has two parents, and both should have input into how it's raised. Maybe the dh is feeling left out and would prefer the op to express sometimes so he can give some feeds.
To just completely dismiss one parents view is wrong. Talk to him and find out his reasons for thinking this

MamaMaiasaura Mon 17-Oct-11 07:25:16

Ams - yaNbu and I'd being extremely pissed off with dh if he said that to me. While I was ebf ds2 dh took time to read up on all the benefits and he's been my greatest supporter and also with cosleeping.

Dh also didn't get up thro night tho early days he'd help if he could.

QuietNinjaZombie Mon 17-Oct-11 07:27:05

Can't believe bullybeefs dp! Won't allow formula? What a knob. I'm lucky my dh (dp at the time) was supportive of my decision to bf and supportive when I started to mix feed. Would have been extremely pissed off if he hadn't.

MamaMaiasaura Mon 17-Oct-11 07:27:42

Add please let's not turn this into a bf ff debate to prev poster. Neither of my ds's would accept ebm from a bottle or a dummy. And it is most prob that ops dp meant formula in a bottle. Let's not nitpick as make this into another ff/bf debate smile

MamaMaiasaura Mon 17-Oct-11 07:29:34

Last post aimed at callmemrs. And ops dp made a passing remark, how on earth do you know how involved he is? A bit presumptuous of you to assume all his Views are dismissed hmm

Ams25 Mon 17-Oct-11 07:32:01

DS2 is 4 months. I think he is having a bit of a sleep regression, but ( for the most part hmm I am managing okay and I know it won't last forever. I know perfectly well DH wouldn't be up sterilising bottles in the middle of the night if I was formula feeding, I would!
Sometimes I feel like I would just like a bit of recognition for sticking to breastfeeding despite finding it hard at first, and for doing all the night wakings... Instead it feels like he's saying I'm stupid for ignoring the obvious answer of a bottle... angry

HappyCamel Mon 17-Oct-11 07:33:28

I'd be cross too. DH does all DD's baths so we each have an exclusive role in her life. He helps me feed by making sure I've got a drink. In the early days he fetched an settled her at night.

It sound like he's read or been told that ff babies sleep for longer periods (often true because it's harder to digest). From OP icant tell why he thinks the night wakings are a problem.

Whatmeworry Mon 17-Oct-11 07:33:32

But why did he say you need to bottle feed, does he feel you are not coping? This may be the voice of reason and concern speaking.

Chandon Mon 17-Oct-11 07:33:57

EB is not a religion.

FF is not poison.

take it from there

MmeLindor. Mon 17-Oct-11 07:37:14

Will he be getting up at night to give your DS a bottle then?

Ask him that.

If he says no then you can say, "Well, if it is me getting up, I am going to use the most convenient method of feeding our child".

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now