Talk

Advanced search

To hate reading books about child abuse?

(69 Posts)
DarlingDuck Mon 12-Sep-11 20:02:58

I mean the autobiographical books. I imagine it's a good form of therapy for the writer and could be helpful to others who read it and have been through similar situations but I find them gut wrenching and haunting and cannot imagine why someone would want to read a book detailing abuse, is this an unreasonable reaction?

Pagwatch Mon 12-Sep-11 20:06:22

But why do you read them then?

If people didn't read them the 'tragic life stories' shit would stop.

I have no desire to read other peoples experiences. I suspect there maybe a therapeutic prices involved in writing but I think that stops when you print the mawkish shit. The titles are bad enough

<<shudder>>

cornsylk Mon 12-Sep-11 20:06:30

...don't read them then?

Catsmamma Mon 12-Sep-11 20:07:22

it's not obligatory!

I loathe miserylit!

MissPenteuth Mon 12-Sep-11 20:08:17

YANBU. Titles like "Please, Daddy, No". I can't imagine anyone enjoying reading them. The therapy/catharsis explanation makes sense though.

worldgonemad72 Mon 12-Sep-11 20:08:47

I cant bear to read them, so i dont.

DarlingDuck Mon 12-Sep-11 20:09:13

I don't read them, have read a couple in my early twenties but that's it. Just wondered if people thought it was unreasonable to find them so dark.

vickibee Mon 12-Sep-11 20:09:22

i read a child called it and it eas very disturbing but compelling too. There is a sequel which I am not going to read

mousesma Mon 12-Sep-11 20:09:51

So don't read them. I can't stand miserylit either. I know the author has made their own choice to document their experiences but it feels wrong to use it as entertainment.

slavetofilofax Mon 12-Sep-11 20:09:57

It is the titles that are the worst thing about them.

I can't read them either, but I agree they are probably a good form of therapy for the authors.

ImperialBlether Mon 12-Sep-11 20:11:08

Misery porn, it's called in the trade.

MissPenteuth Mon 12-Sep-11 20:11:28

Really? You think you might be unreasonable in thinking that books about child abuse are not fun to read?

I haven't read any, and have no desire to. I'm happy to read about dark subject matter and difficult subjects to a point, but child abuse is beyond my limit.

grumplestilskin Mon 12-Sep-11 20:11:50

YANBU. anyone I've known who's had shelves full of misery porn were emotional NIMBYs and had no tolerance for others in their local community, but thought that "enjoying" shock reading misery porn meant that they were really empathetic people.... whatever!

Sometimes plots have to explore those issues as part of a bigger plot/issue, I'm talking about the "please not again daddy" type titles!

but do understand why they are written.

DarlingDuck Mon 12-Sep-11 20:13:08

MissPenteuth - there seem to be an awful lot of people who read them and presumabley enjoy reading them, some are bestsellers confused

AnyFucker Mon 12-Sep-11 20:14:37

I hate them too

I hate the way WHSmith has a whole bookshelf devoted to them

I find it hard enough to read about the children that are subjected to living in an abusive atmosphere on here sad

MissPenteuth Mon 12-Sep-11 20:15:27

It's odd that they're so popular, who on earth reads them?

Maybe the same people who read The Da Vinci Code? [book snob emoticon]

solidgoldbrass Mon 12-Sep-11 20:16:23

They are a fucking disgrace. Not the authors (at least not all of them) - writing your life story can be very therapeutic though some of these authors have been found to be not just exaggerating but making pretty much the whole thing up. It's both the publishers and the buyers I despise. Because the sort of people who buy this shit are generally the same sort of whangers who are forever clamouring for censorship of sexually-explicit material and horror fiction - as Grumplestiltskin says, while considering themselves wonderful caring people for wallowing in miserylit.
Of course, another market for child-abuse memoirs is likely to be sadistic paedophiles who find them a wonderful source of easily-available and legal wank material.

MissPenteuth Mon 12-Sep-11 20:17:16

Ha AF I remember being shocked that they had an entire section devoted to them. It was a tall unit, at least 5 or 6 shelves. Can't remember the title they gave them, it wasn't "misery lit" but not far off.

AnyFucker Mon 12-Sep-11 20:17:38

< runs screaming from thread >

herecomesthsun Mon 12-Sep-11 20:17:41

I liked Andrea Ashworth's book, Once in a House on fire (I think). Mind you, it was very well written and rather discreet, with an emphasis on the writer's relationship with her mother, who was loving but weak IIRC. I find the covers and titles of the other ones distasteful so left well alone.

AnyFucker Mon 12-Sep-11 20:18:10

I have been trying to remember the section name too, MP

sunshinelifeisgood Mon 12-Sep-11 20:18:16

I personally do not normally read those sort of books but did read A CHILD CALLED IT. It is followed up of how the author came out of the abuse etc and made a life for himself. A very inspiring read

MissPenteuth Mon 12-Sep-11 20:18:20

sgb I hadn't thought of that explanation. How depressing.

RumourOfAHurricane Mon 12-Sep-11 20:19:04

Message withdrawn

AnyFucker Mon 12-Sep-11 20:20:14

ah, remembered it

Tragic Lives

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now