Advanced search

To wonder what the govt has planned to punish those NOT on benefits?

(494 Posts)
Glitterknickaz Fri 09-Sep-11 16:41:12

News link

This is not the first time cutting benefits has been suggested as a punishment. How are the government proposing to punish parents who don't tackle truancy efficiently that aren't on benefits exactly? Just like the assertion that the rioters should lose benefits, yes because they were ALL on benefits weren't they? hmm

Once again the government fuels the totally untrue daily mail esque belief that all of society's ills lie at the feet of benefits claimants. Apparently they are the root of all evil, eh? hmm

Not one of the policies publicised has said what would happen to those who do not claim benefits.

Money designed for basic sustenance should not be removed imo. At the end of the day it is the children that will suffer from these measures.

breadandbutterfly Fri 09-Sep-11 16:46:27

Conversely, I noted wryly that I must have done something really bad as I - along with every family where someone earns over about 40K a year - am having my kids' child benefit removed. Next year.

Am I the only one to find it amusing that a load of totally innocent middle-class people with blameless children are suffering something too dreadful for them to actually dare to inflict on those whose kids do burn down shops etc?


Glitterknickaz Fri 09-Sep-11 16:49:51

Yes but if you did get cross and burn down a shop there's nothing to take away is there? wink

2shoes Fri 09-Sep-11 16:50:17

interesting question,
reminds me of EMA, how students who got EMA would be punished by having it taken away, but a student not on EMA who did same "crime" no punishment.

crazynanna Fri 09-Sep-11 16:51:55

God,he really does hate poor people,doesn't he? Knob hmm

Glitterknickaz Fri 09-Sep-11 16:55:26

none of these would lose benefits would they? (apologies for Daily Hate link)

OpinionatedMum Fri 09-Sep-11 16:55:52

He is just showing his contempt for poor people.

Glitterknickaz Fri 09-Sep-11 16:56:46

and fuelling the assertion made by some of the media that it's all the fault of those on benefits....

crazynanna Fri 09-Sep-11 16:57:58


Tortington Fri 09-Sep-11 16:58:12

well if its the choice between bluebelltinkle's needs and me affording sky plus, i am gonna get sky every time innit - cos what 'as she got to watch when she lets it from playgroup na?

BrawToken Fri 09-Sep-11 16:59:31

Hmmm. Punishing people for committing crimes while pushing them into a life of crime due to high and growing umemployment. Only the tories would do this. Cunts.

OpinionatedMum Fri 09-Sep-11 17:05:06

Children learn best when starving.

Peachy Fri 09-Sep-11 17:06:26

On that assertion breadandbutterfly I am being punished for having an autistic child next eyar becuase the tax credits disability segment is going down by £50 a week for mr dla claimants.

but that's not what OP is saying is it?

One punishment for everyone regardless of which part of society they come from surely?

And yes, what Custy said is exactly what just a few of the famillies I used to work with would have done; not forgetting the ones who were too pissed to make their kids go to school and whose addiction would trump the kids every time.

<<group point and laugh to the first peson who assures me SSD would sort that out- er no tthey don't, they ahve no money either>>

Tortington Fri 09-Sep-11 17:06:27

i really dont unerstnd the problem here, why should be punish those people who tax dodge and don't contribute to society?

Peachy Fri 09-Sep-11 17:07:24

And yes OM

and the costs to teh state of the associated healthcare and homelesness are not real money that would outweigh the financial penalties.

Honest, like.

Glitterknickaz Fri 09-Sep-11 17:08:18

Yep, we're getting that penalty as two of ours qualify for middle rate care rather than high, Peachy.

Not what it's about though. Publicly coming up with new 'punishments' that cannot be evenly applied across society for the same crime is just completely out of order.

2shoes Fri 09-Sep-11 17:16:09

oh well at least we won't be punished for that crime then, as dd gets HR, sure they will think of someway to punish her for being disabled though.

Peachy Fri 09-Sep-11 17:18:51

Exactly Glitter

<<shakes fist cartoon stylee at 2dhoes; why you... wink>>

breadandbutterfly Fri 09-Sep-11 17:23:43

My point was that it didn't make sense as a 'punishment' if it was being applied randomly to people who had committed no crime other than earning over 40K per year. So I'm agreeing with the OP.

Clearly deterrants are needed but this should have been thought through more.

CogitoErgoSometimes Fri 09-Sep-11 17:24:07

YABU People not on benefits can be punished for their children playing truant. Fines and imprisonment have been dished out before. We're all quick to complain about the 'entitlement culture' and I'm not surprised, therefore, if the response is to move it more into a 'responsibility culture'. Benefits are conditional.... always have been... but that's often forgotten.

Glitterknickaz Fri 09-Sep-11 17:24:59

I'm not sure the child benefit/tax credits cuts are a punishment hmm
(not to say I absolutely agree with them)

Glitterknickaz Fri 09-Sep-11 17:26:01

Cogito, so how do you propose people who aren't on benefits get punished for the same thing?
There are plenty of working poor who are just above benefits thresholds, if their child has a strong truancy record how are they going to be punished?

slavetofilofax Fri 09-Sep-11 17:28:10

If they want to hurt the pockets of criminals on benefits, why can't they just fine them so everyone can have the same punishment?

There must be people on benefits already paying fines for stuff, and I thought there was some system like with bankrupcy where you had to give them details of your outgoings to decide how much you have to pay back each week?

Glitterknickaz Fri 09-Sep-11 17:28:49

it's not the criminals on benefits I'm concerned with, it's the ones not on benefits!

BelleDameSansMerci Fri 09-Sep-11 17:30:50

Tories - putting the 'n' in cuts...

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now