Advanced search

To think it might have been suicide

(37 Posts)
Mitmoo Sun 24-Jul-11 09:19:43

I am wondering if it was drugs or suicide that took Amy, she was being booed off stage and her boyfriend had recently finished with her, or should I just keep my thoughts to myself?

AuntieMonica Sun 24-Jul-11 09:21:24

yes you should


schomberg Sun 24-Jul-11 09:21:47

Keep them to yourself. It may well have been but what's the point in speculating on Mumsnet?

birdofthenorth Sun 24-Jul-11 09:23:24

Yes yabu. Mind your own smile

catsareevil Sun 24-Jul-11 09:24:47

I suspect its a bit more complex than 'drugs or suicide'. No doubt there will be an inquest.

2shoes Sun 24-Jul-11 09:25:04

op you are a ghoul

Tee2072 Sun 24-Jul-11 09:25:58

How is se any more a ghoul than the millions of others with the same thoughts?

BornInAfrica Sun 24-Jul-11 09:28:42

I think it's a perfectly reasonable query tbh. Don't believe it was suicide but the OP has as much right to ponder the matter as anyone else has to poo poo it.

fanjoforthemammaries7850 Sun 24-Jul-11 09:30:06

You didnt know her so how on earth can you form such an opinion? From the papers?

Mitmoo Sun 24-Jul-11 09:31:11

The news was reporting that it is Jewish tradition for the funeral to happen today and they are trying to make that happen for her family's sake. The poor father has had to fly home from America knowing his DD has died. I do feel for the family and think it's very sad that she couldn't get her life together despite her talen.

2shoes Sun 24-Jul-11 09:31:15

most people have the common sense to keep stuff like that in their head. but hay lets just start another thread to talk about a woman who died.

AuntieMonica Sun 24-Jul-11 09:31:34

it's a tragic death, i find it ghoullish to want to debate the possible cause

smoggii Sun 24-Jul-11 09:31:38

It's unexplained as yet so you might be right. Even if it is an overdose it still might be deliberate, only she knows and she can't tell us now.

Mitmoo Sun 24-Jul-11 09:32:01

To reach what opinion fanjo?

SquidgyBiscuits Sun 24-Jul-11 09:33:25

Well done on forming an opinion based on tabloid fodder.

But really, how is it any of your business? If it were suicide it would be reported as so.

2shoes Sun 24-Jul-11 09:33:32

we don't need police, we have the mumsnet ghouls, they can reach conclusions and make them fact. brilliant, we can save a fortune on wages

duckdodgers Sun 24-Jul-11 09:35:00

OP has formed an opinion - or in this case surmising - because she is human, and we all do it to various degrees about things. It looks as if some of you here think its wrong - fair enough, but in my opinion its not "right" or "wrong" just human nature. Im sure suicide has crossed lots of peoples minds - why shouldnt it be discussed - this is a discussion board after all.

bellavita Sun 24-Jul-11 09:35:33


Mitmoo Sun 24-Jul-11 09:36:03

To those with claims of me believing the tabloids, jumping to conclusions and forming opinions.

I repeat I was wondering

2shoes Sun 24-Jul-11 09:37:28

it is aibu, so yes I can post that she is a ghoul and that this thread is in bad taste.

sleepindogz Sun 24-Jul-11 09:38:51

of course it was suicide one way or another

she must have been warned thousands of times she wouldnt last long on that lifestyle, but she either thought oh well hey ho, or i will start getting clean tomorrow, or no not me, I am invincible. Whatever, she had the means and opportunity to get help but chose not to.

noddyholder Sun 24-Jul-11 09:39:47

Well stop wondering and go and do something constructive with you day. Agree ith 2shoes unnecessary ghoulish speculation

catsareevil Sun 24-Jul-11 09:40:58


Mitmoo Sun 24-Jul-11 09:42:17

sleep I think it does go to show just how hard it must be to come off drugs. She had everything financially, lived in a £2m+ home but still couldn't get off them. I hope some good comes of this in that youngsters will look at her and think twice before starting on drugs.

Mitmoo Sun 24-Jul-11 09:43:39

noddy we're both doing the same thing, posting on Mums net, I find your "advice" rather amusing.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: