Talk

Advanced search

To give my DD 20 sanctions in 2 hours?

(42 Posts)
Fairenuff Tue 19-Jul-11 18:09:34

14yo DD is normally fairly well behaved but for the past 2 hours has refused point blank to tidy her room (a job which would have taken ten minutes and she is used to doing).

She basically said, she wasn't going to do it and there was nothing I could do about it. I said she would have a sanction (punishment) and she said all she needed was food and a bed to sleep in. Little madam!

So after leaving her a while to think about it, I finally told her that she would have 1 sanction per minute that she delayed. 20 minutes later, she is tidying her room.

AIBU?

Flisspaps Tue 19-Jul-11 18:10:50

YANBU. She's 14, not 4 - and if you've told her she's getting 1 sanction per minute she now needs to see that you'll follow through on your word.

worraliberty Tue 19-Jul-11 18:11:03

Well it worked

But if it hadn't, could you really have thought of 20 meaningful 'sanctions'?

Sirzy Tue 19-Jul-11 18:11:28

You have to follow through with your word now.

Although good luck thinking of 20 sanctions!

DogsBestFriend Tue 19-Jul-11 18:13:00

Nope.

I'd have made it very easy for her - all she'd have been left with would have been a bed to sleep in, anything found on the floor or surfaces would have been binned and she'd have received her dinner when she'd cleared the rest up and apologised to me and not before.

(Can you tell I have a 14 yo daughter too?) grin

Fairenuff Tue 19-Jul-11 18:13:33

I will give her 20 jobs to do around the house. It will keep her busy during the school holidays and help me out at the same time.

valiumredhead Tue 19-Jul-11 18:14:23

IME teen girls respond well to having straightners removed grin

20? Can you list them? <<curious>>

Fairenuff Tue 19-Jul-11 18:19:39

No tv, no computer, sent to bed early, no lift to school, no lift home from school, no sleepovers, no pocket money, no lifts to friends, no friends over, no mobile, no shopping! (no hair straighteners - love it)

Wash the floors, clean the cars, ironing, wash your own clothes, cook your own meals, mow the lawn, weed the garden . . .

ooh I'm just getting into this grin

I feel better now.

UpsyDozy Tue 19-Jul-11 18:21:24

I'm printing this thread out to refer to when my two DDs get older! grin

worraliberty Tue 19-Jul-11 18:21:44

And what are you going to do if she refuses to do all of those things in the summer holidays?

Give her another 20?

LoveBeingAbleToNamechange Tue 19-Jul-11 18:25:05

Get her to come up with her own list.

Fairenuff Tue 19-Jul-11 18:30:49

worra I am hoping she will learn her lesson from this. What else can I do?

MaureenMLove Tue 19-Jul-11 18:31:30

Do you really call them sanctions? Isn't that what they get told at school when they misbehave? Surely, just calling them sanctions is enough to get her back up?

Not disputing that she needs a kick up the arse, I have a 15 yr old girl of my own, but is telling her to tidy her room really an argument you need to have? I can't help thinking this argument ran away with itself.

I've given up with the bedroom. However, I have also given up going in there to collect washing! My theory is, if you want to be treated like an adult, start behaving like one.

Fairenuff Tue 19-Jul-11 18:37:58

Maureen we call them sanctions or consequences. Better, I think, than punishments. Don't really know what to call them that 'won't get her back up'.

The argument was more about her flatly refusing to do what she'd been asked and basically saying 'what are you going to do about it?'

I felt that she was challenging my authority and that it was important to reinforce who was in charge here. Other times I have let it go because I know she needs to 'win' sometimes.

Btw she has now done her room, has freely and generously apologised for her behaviour and is off to make her own dinner. 1 down, 19 to go.

ChunkyMonkeyMother Tue 19-Jul-11 18:40:17

Sounds like you had all of these "Sanctions" ready for your slave daughter - give the girl a break, she's 14!

I'm not saying she shouldn't tidy her own room but a list of 20 things to do? Do you even do these things?

worraliberty Tue 19-Jul-11 18:43:38

I don't know what else you can do but I have to say, 20 sanctions and then possibly more sanctions on top...well that's just going to drag the punishment on and on isn't it?

I mean it'll be a Summer of sheer drudge and misery and she's hardly going to be blaming herself...I'd say she's far more likely to begin strongly resenting you.

I find grounding and all the normal having things taken away until their behaviour improves, works in this house.

BuntyPenfold Tue 19-Jul-11 18:43:46

Effective sanction 21 - no tweezers grin

OldRedEyes Tue 19-Jul-11 18:50:09

i think you need to pick your battles

if her room is a tip, so be it, she has to live in it

i wouldnt allow talking back though

Fairenuff Tue 19-Jul-11 18:50:48

worra if she doesn't blame herself then she hasn't taken responsibility for her actions. I don't want her to grow up blaming everyone else for her own behaviour.

How do you help a young adult learn how to be a responsible grown up if there are no consequences?

She knew it was 1 consequence per minute and she sat there for 20 minutes. How is she not to blame?

Chunky yes I do do all of those things. Don't we all?

MaureenMLove Tue 19-Jul-11 18:50:50

LOL! Good for you.

Maybe it's because I spend all day, giving students sanctions and telling them, 'you know the consequences', that I can't bring myself to say it at home.

Poor thing, does rather get it in the neck sometimes, if I've had a shit day. I find myself saying, 'don't you bloody start, I've had a gut full of Yr10's all day!' blushgrin

Don't get me wrong, she does get told off and I find the straighteners and phone, the quickest way to sort her out. DH favours, taking the fuse out of her TV! grin

MaureenMLove Tue 19-Jul-11 18:53:17

Well, the consequences of a tip of a bedroom is no clean clothes, smelly and no friends because she looks a mess and smells! Works for me! grin

usualsuspect Tue 19-Jul-11 18:55:14

Pick your battles

I would hate to spend my whole day fighting over a messy room

houseofheave Tue 19-Jul-11 18:58:16

I think you handled it brilliantly.

<applauds>

purplepidjincantatem Tue 19-Jul-11 18:59:10

Cook one meal a day and wash it up for 10 days = 20 sanctions - hardly a summer of drudgery! Add in hoover and load washing machine every day and it reduces to 5 days. Definitely NOT onerous, and an excellent way to teach lifeskills wink

LaurieFairyCake Tue 19-Jul-11 19:01:03

You did exactly the right thing once you had decided she had to do her room within a certain time.

Once you've picked the battle you have to follow it through.

Which is why I pick few battles smile

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now