Talk

Advanced search

to think the Mother who's had her baby taken away from her for breastfeeding isn't newsworthy but who Ryan Giggs is shagging is?

(26 Posts)
MrsDimples Sun 12-Jun-11 01:43:32

If you google the story of the woman in Madrid whose 15 months old daughter has been taken away from her for breastfeeding her, you get one news story. This has got to be more newsworthy surely. angry

The Facebook group has been open for several days & has just over three thousand likes, which isn't very much.

http://www.facebook.com/WeAreAllHabiba?sk=wall

I can only find 2 threads relating to it on Mumsnet. shock

Clearly I am posting this to try & drum up more support, which I think is perfectly reasonable. wink

Mummy2LZ Sun 12-Jun-11 04:43:12

Just liked it!
Cant believe this has happened. We are in Brisbane and I never even heard it on the news!
Is there any news on her progress?

LolaRennt Sun 12-Jun-11 05:06:43

They don't explain in the info whayt they mean by weaning. Is the baby still totally milk fed at 15 months? That can't be healthy?

thumbwitch Sun 12-Jun-11 05:11:50

That's so shocking - that poor girl and her baby! Barbaric. Bastards.angry sad

ProjectGainsborough Sun 12-Jun-11 05:40:55

There's a bit more information on the story here

brookeslay Sun 12-Jun-11 06:20:49

That is terrible i`m not sure how to sign the petition. Disgusted at Spain treating this woman like this my heart aches for her child.

brookeslay Sun 12-Jun-11 06:23:32

tu correo- e is that email adress ?

meditrina Sun 12-Jun-11 06:29:01

The linked blog post is the only information about this case that has emerged in about a week now.

The allegations of both violence and non-compliance in a parenting programme are serious ones, and might/might constitute good reason for removing a 1.25 year old from its mother regardless of whether still BF or not.

There have been a couple of earlier threads about thus eg here which also contained a shout-out for Spanish speakers to see if there was any more info in the Spanish press. There isn't.

So the silence may well be because there is clearly far more to this story than the blog post by her supporters.

Greythorne Sun 12-Jun-11 07:07:25

I agree with meditrina. itnseems like there must be more to the story than first appears.

I can imagine many scenarios wherein the authorities would remove a child and be right to do so. Obviously, breastfeeding a toddler is not one of them, and is so outlandish a reason, I feel there must be more to it.

The lack of other news outlets reporting it suggests it is not as clear cut as the blog implies.

But YANBU re Ryan Giggs. I could not care less about him and his affairs.

troisgarcons Sun 12-Jun-11 07:19:09

Is that a 'real' story? At the bottom of the blog it says it might be a hoax.

Many friends who live and worked in Spain; and I've never heard of a cultural issue regarding breast feeding. Doesn't mean it doesnt exist of course.

Back to the Op and which is more newsworthy: Ryan Giggs or Spanish Breastfeeding - can't say either of them interst me but I'd hazzard a guess that Ryan Giggs will flog more papers

ShellyBoobs Sun 12-Jun-11 11:24:33

Back to the Op and which is more newsworthy: Ryan Giggs or Spanish Breastfeeding - can't say either of them interst me but I'd hazzard a guess that Ryan Giggs will flog more papers

Exactly. It's not a case of what's more important, it's what will sell the most papers and people are interested in who Ryan Giggs is shagging than the Spanish mother's plight.

I think there's more to it tbh.

PrinceHumperdink Sun 12-Jun-11 11:47:32

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Rosmarin Sun 12-Jun-11 11:52:25

http://www.amormaternal.com/2011/06/please-help-habiba.html

If you need any more info.

Rosmarin Sun 12-Jun-11 11:54:36

Y para los que quieren y pueden leer en espanol:

http://www.amormaternal.com/2011/06/madre-lactante-separada-bebe-amamantar.html

No se si es un hoax o es la verdad// I'm not sure whether it's a hoax or the truth - apparently quite a few well-known birthing/breastfeeding etc advocates are involved?

JustShootMeAlready Sun 12-Jun-11 12:31:28

If it's not a hoax, I highly doubt that her exclusively breastfeeding was the cause of her child being taken away. There are blatently other factors that have not been reported - diminished mental capacity/ violence/ neglect......god knows what. But I would be certain there is a lot more to this than merely a breastfeeder who was treated terribly.

meditrina Sun 12-Jun-11 13:38:41

Rosmarin: that's the same and the only blog post about this.

Are there any MNetters in Spain who could let us know what sort of coverage this story is receiving in the main stream Spanish press?

(I doubt the British papers would pick up any foreign domestic story unless it was pretty big in its country of origin or had a specific UK angle).

MrsDimples Sat 18-Jun-11 16:56:28

Medical Report

http://www.facebook.com/WeAreAllHabiba?sk=app_103822229704881

fairydoll Sat 18-Jun-11 17:02:13

I don't believe it for a second.It is either a hoax or there is a lot more to the child being removed than this.

Triathlete Sat 18-Jun-11 17:37:18

I speak Spanish and I've lived in Spain. I've done a scan of the Spanish press online - Vanguardia, El Pais, ABC.

The case is genuine, and is as reported. Although I love Spain and the Spanish, there is a Catholic racist patriarchal undercurrent in that society, especially towards powerless young women, and this behaviour is entirely consistent with it (30 years ago the same thing was happening in Ireland, and 40 years ago in Liverpool). However I must say that the majority of Spanish people would be appalled at this case, in my opinion.

A backlash against the IMMF and in support of Habiba is growing and the case has reached the top of the paediatric and public interest community.

I've joined the Facebook group, and will be sending information about it to everyone I know. I'll also be contacting BBC about it. I'd encourage everyone else to do the same.

There's a petition here that can be signed:

http://actuable.es/peticiones/immf-give-back-habiba-s-baby

JudysJudgement Sat 18-Jun-11 17:53:18

none so gullible as a facebooking mumsnetter eh smile

Triathlete Sat 18-Jun-11 21:13:12

http://www.lavanguardia.com/local/madrid/20110617/54173370107/la-defensora-del-pueblo-pide-a-la-comunidad-que-evalue-a-la-hija-de-habiba-en-un-hospital.html

http://www.elperiodico.com/es/noticias/sociedad/separada-del-bebe-por-querer-amamantarlo-1039210

http://noticias.lainformacion.com/interes-humano/sociedad/la-fiscalia-impugnara-la-retirada-de-la-tutela-a-habiba_mFuNymLxD0lgXMfEmufjT4/

http://www.elpais.com/articulo/sociedad/Defensora/Pueblo/pide/Comunidad/evalue/caso/Habiba/elpepusoc/20110617elpepusoc_13/Tes

DorisIsAPinkDragon Sat 18-Jun-11 21:41:44

I've been following this on facebook for a few days now.

The report that was seen by the IMMF did not give any real reason for removing Alma (the 15 month old dd) other than refusal to cooperate with anti breastfeeding and co sleeping policies (these were deemed too chaotic) Alma was not fed by bm alone but some form of blw was in progress, but the ffoods were deemed 'unsuitable'.

The case has been refered to the courts and the prosecutor has accepted that there is a case to investigate.

The IMMF do not have to go before the courst to remove a child.

Habbiba (not her real name) co slept and bf and refused to take lactation suppressing medication. for these reason she was deemed an unfit mother.

There are spainish doctors who have read the reports on Alma and those who have examined Habbiba who all agree that the seperatuion is unjustified and extremely damaging to the child.

Please before you dismiss this as a hoax or unjustified campaign please dig a little deeper.

Like Trialete I have lived in a very a patriarical sociaty and do believe that it is not unheard.

Even the fact that it is policy to end bf with lactation supressing drugs whilst within a mother and child home should raise a few eyebrows.

DorisIsAPinkDragon Sat 18-Jun-11 21:42:34

EL Pais has picked up the story so it should be available there.

MrsDimples Wed 22-Jun-11 20:33:02

www.amormaternal.com/2011/06/habiba-and-alma-together-hugging-and.html

No thanks to the majority of people round here, eh.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now