Advanced search

to let MN decide which house we buy?

(143 Posts)
mistressploppy Thu 26-May-11 19:33:19

To cut a long boring story short, we are now stuck deciding between two houses. DH knows which one he wants; I need more opinions...

House A is on the road we currently live on, the Nicest in the Villaaage, all leafy etc
House B is on the second nicest road, nearer the Main Road

House A is a 4 bed semi
House B is detached, 5 bed

House A has a big back garden and a small drive
House B has a very big front garden (because it's a southfacing plot) and a huge drive

House A is pretty and Victorian
House B is a bit less pretty and Edwardian

House A would mean keeping our lovely neighbours
House B may well have lovely new neighbours

House A costs x
House B costs x plus £25k

Any thoughts?

LaurieFairyCake Thu 26-May-11 19:35:06

How big is the back garden for house B?

I'm massively leaning towards the 5 bed detached with the big drive - you'll never have to move again

thisisyesterday Thu 26-May-11 19:35:14

i'd go for House A

Punkatheart Thu 26-May-11 19:35:54

I like A but then I have always been a sucker for Victorian houses.

TheSecondComing Thu 26-May-11 19:36:07

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

coccyx Thu 26-May-11 19:36:25

any pics

stoppinchingthedummy Thu 26-May-11 19:36:37

House A ...dont mess with "might" have nice neighbours ...i couldnt care less if i lived in a 50 bedroom house ,if i had shit neighbours id sooner swap it for a 1 bedroom flat with nice neighbours .....Can u tell i have had past issues with neighbours ?? grin

House A is cheaper and may be smaller but it sounds lovely smile

SomebodyNew Thu 26-May-11 19:36:56

House A definitely, just sounds much nicer for some reason. Can we see links? Yes I'm nosey!

squeakytoy Thu 26-May-11 19:37:03

House A sounds better to me, but peace and quiet, a huge garden, and good neighbours are important to me.

mistressploppy Thu 26-May-11 19:37:07

Laurie - it's big enough for a shed, rotary line, some shrubs, patch of lawn. It's just north facing so pretty dark. There's also a garage on the west side of the house, and a veg patch there that gets sun from west and south

ohhappyday Thu 26-May-11 19:37:43

house A quality over quantity for me every time. Also by the sounds of things you love it. Best of Luck

Pedallleur Thu 26-May-11 19:38:12

Which can you afford and how many in the family? if you have or are planning a large family then obviously bigger is better but not if you struggle to pay the mortgage/bills

SomebodyNew Thu 26-May-11 19:38:22

Also, reading between the lines you have described house A more positively so maybe you're leaning that way?

mistressploppy Thu 26-May-11 19:38:41

Ok, both houses are on my profile, House A is the first one, and has a floorplan blush, House B is the last pic

cottonreels Thu 26-May-11 19:39:11

If one room would be a spare room in house b, go for house a and have a clear out wink

mistressploppy Thu 26-May-11 19:39:54

I tried to be even handed with how positively I described them! I knew I'd cock that up!

LadyOfTheCuntryManor Thu 26-May-11 19:41:29

House B. It's similar to my house here

That's also for sale. Buy mine so I can move.

House B because you have the privacy of the surroundings, you're off the main road, and Georgian houses provide better interiors.

SoupDragon Thu 26-May-11 19:42:09

house A.

I think having a large front garden would be impractical.

LaurieFairyCake Thu 26-May-11 19:43:57

They are both lovely but that aerial shot of the detached with all the green is fab!

For me it's always detached - doesn't matter so much about the neighbours then wink

Remember, some arse could still move next door to you in the semi.

btw - I've been to Petra too! wish I was there now smile

mistressploppy Thu 26-May-11 19:43:59

Ooh, Lady, I love your house! If you could transplant it to Hampshire I would definitely buy it

montmartre Thu 26-May-11 19:44:12

Pmsl! First pic I see is the treasury at petra... bit older than victorian grin

Off the pic, id choose the first.

SoupDragon Thu 26-May-11 19:44:27

Except, LOTCM, House B is Edwardian and nearer the main road.

thisisyesterday Thu 26-May-11 19:44:33

having seen pics I still say house A!!! it looks lovely.

how big is its garden?

LadyOfTheCuntryManor Thu 26-May-11 19:44:47

That can be arranged. If you buy it, I'll let you know how you can transport it grin

<rubs hands wickedly>

TheSecondComing Thu 26-May-11 19:45:14

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: