Talk

Advanced search

to find TV magic shows utterly pointless (and irritating)?

(22 Posts)
HouseOfBamboo Sat 29-Jan-11 19:42:57

wtf is the point? There is AMPLE scope for hidden effects, props, duplicitous camera angles. That's how TV works ffs.

And we're supposed to sit there like a bunch of idiots and go woooooo aren't they clever shock ?

[grumpy, scratchy, bah humbug]

coastgirl Sat 29-Jan-11 19:44:16

YANBU - most 'magic' is crap. Have seen Penn and Teller live though and they were fantastic! I love it when they show you how things are done - it's really clever stuff.

HouseOfBamboo Sat 29-Jan-11 19:46:57

Penn and Teller are the only magicians who I have ever enjoyed - they are genuinely entertaining.

I can't stand the smug card trick brigade.

Thingumy Sat 29-Jan-11 19:47:50

was just thinking the same.

begonyabampot Sat 29-Jan-11 19:49:56

Can't stand magicians - just boring.

Hardandsleazy Sat 29-Jan-11 19:50:24

It's got Lenny henry on it- can't get past that so if you add in magic it's not something I feel enticed by.

It's a bit of a shame for no social life types - from scd merlin to this- roll on sky Atlantic next week.

brimfull Sat 29-Jan-11 19:51:13

8 yr olds love it
but yes not my cuppa tea

SleepWhenImDead Sat 29-Jan-11 19:53:00

The Magicians is officially crap. I can't stand Lenny Henry and the format is totally lame. Did you see Fool Us a few weeks ago with Penn & Teller? Brilliant TV - I hope they come back with a series. I also saw Penn and Teller at Hammersmith last year and they were phenomenal. I love going to see live magic with DH. Going to see Derren Brown for the third time in April and can't wait.

Santiagosmama Sat 29-Jan-11 19:53:22

YANBU completely agree.

TheCowardlyLion Sat 29-Jan-11 19:54:42

ROFL, ggirl - my 8 yr old DS is watching this absolutely transfixed ! grin

GreenEyesandHam Sat 29-Jan-11 19:57:19

Oh you are so not being unreasonable!

It's all godawful, and I'm including Penn and Teller in that, because they freak me out.

HouseOfBamboo Sat 29-Jan-11 19:58:54

That thing with the bloke whose head dropped down to his chest earlier, you never saw him filmed from behind or below the waist. Yes they cut to a RL audience 'reacting' - but they could have been acting or watching another show entirely. So what's the point. Grr.

Penn and Teller cut through the self-regarding bollocks of 'illusionists' and are therefore great.

maryz Sat 29-Jan-11 20:00:34

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Vallhala Sat 29-Jan-11 20:02:55

The thing on the TV tonight is hugely unimpressive but some magicians are... well, just magic. One of my friends from my teenaged years was the son of the late Pat Page, a hero and mentor of Derren Brown. Mr P was a member of the Inner Magic Circle, was consultant to several TV shows from magic shows to Poirot and also advised many up and coming magicians. He travelled the world performing his art and didn't TV need cameras to cover up what he was doing.

That lovely, modest gentleman wasn't just a great magician, he was a genius.

Thingumy Sat 29-Jan-11 20:03:38

Wouldn't be so bad if they didn't have these fucking awful actors 'presenting' it.

Ego central.pah.

joydivisionovengloves Sat 29-Jan-11 20:28:20

YANBU. I hate magic.

LetThereBeRock Sat 29-Jan-11 21:58:51

I love good magic shows, but this is dreadful,and the two Scottish guys particuarly so. They drone on too much,so by the time they've finished their spiel the audience has lost interest.

Newgolddream Sat 29-Jan-11 22:08:54

TheCowardlyLion - you and me both, my 8 year old DS adores this programme lol. Im on here reading stuff and he was telling me about it every 5 minutes.

mumalot Sat 25-Jun-11 18:33:42

I found that Lenny Henry thing atrocious though DCs seemed to like it. But the Penn and Teller show last Saturday night was great. I'm not big on magic either. I think it's a boy thing TBH. But the show last week was the first thing in ages we've all sat down and watched together without someone on FB or complaint it was boring. It's a series so should be on again tonight. Itv 8 pm.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe Sat 25-Jun-11 18:40:10

I love Penn and Teller but really struggled last week to avoid watching and worse, listening to Jonathan Ross.

Penn and Teller look bored as well they might be... the magic tricks presented by members of the public were by and large rubbish and overdone and that Ross bloke just everywhere. I hate him. angry

I won't be watching tonight, I'm going to indulge in a couple of episodes of Jonathan Creek. Now there was a magician... grin

giraffesCantZumba Sat 25-Jun-11 18:45:45

not seen any magic since brit got talent

giraffesCantZumba Sat 25-Jun-11 18:46:16

oh i loved jonathan creek

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now