Talk

Advanced search

To have 10 children

(234 Posts)
Sapphire2012 Fri 24-Dec-10 14:42:52

Hello waves I'm new around here. I'm Kirsty, mum to 10 lovely children. I'm curious as to what you honestly think of people with lots of children. I am not on any benefits and their child benefit goes into their savings accounts. (I hope this doesnt sound like I am bragging, I just hate when people assume we are scroungers, this is most definately not the case)

Sapphire2012 Fri 24-Dec-10 14:43:09

Oh didnt think waves would be bolded lol!

truffleshuffle Fri 24-Dec-10 14:45:41

YANBU.
I think people should be able to have as many children as they want as long as they can..
a) pay for them and
b) look after them all properly.

I know I can afford any more and would struggle to care for any more which is why I've stopped at 3.

HappyMummyOfOne Fri 24-Dec-10 14:49:07

I think as long as you only get CB (universal at present)and no tax credits, housing help etc then you can have as many as you can afford with the relevant insurances should something ever happen.

Whether or not 10 children get enough one to one time, help with homework, go to their hobbies etc is another matter and something that should be taken into account.

stropiwithbellson Fri 24-Dec-10 14:50:26

Not really aibu though is it? smile

TrillianAstra Fri 24-Dec-10 14:50:34

Well if YABU then it's a but late to do anything about it, you can't exactly put them back grin

TiredofTinsel Fri 24-Dec-10 14:50:50

As long as they are all happy, why not?

violethill Fri 24-Dec-10 14:53:17

If you are comfortable with having 10 children, and are able to support them, then why ask?

Some people will think you are unreasonable, on the grounds of over population and dwindling resources.

Some people will think its not a problem.

Most people will shudder at the thought of it.

PositiveAttitude Fri 24-Dec-10 14:53:28

New and you have posted in AIBU. Oh dear, good luck!! smile

As for the 10 children, lovely, I say, as long as you can care for them yourself, good on you.

hairyfairylights Fri 24-Dec-10 15:03:59

I think it's none of my business, but I do wonder how one set of parents has adequate attention to give to ten.

onlyjuststillme Fri 24-Dec-10 15:04:44

as long as you are looking after the children and giving them the attention and emotional support they need and you are not expecting the older ones to raise the younger ones so you dont have to then its fine.

Get it wrong though and there are are a lot of very damaged pieces to pick up- i am speaking as someone who has picked up some of the pieces here.

catinthehat2 Fri 24-Dec-10 15:10:42

Ah
2012
I love that date.
It's when the world ends
Innit

MickyLee Fri 24-Dec-10 15:12:41

Wow.. What a blessing! You must tell us about your daily life with 10!!! Love to hear it

bunnymother Fri 24-Dec-10 15:13:28

Is that 10 pregnancies that you have endured? I doffs me hat, if so!! Same view as others re if you can afford it and look after them, it's completely up to you. You have far more patience than I, that's for sure.

SerendipitousHarlot Fri 24-Dec-10 15:16:10

And me! Good luck to you. I certainly can't imagine anything worse.... smile

amijee Fri 24-Dec-10 15:22:37

I am one of nine kids. My dad worked all the hours under the sun as did my mum in the home.

I feel we were neglected somewhat as well as money being very very tight.

As adults, there are so many family rifts that I am glad I moved away.

However, if you can avoid all that - hats off to you. a big family can also be a wonderful thing.

happy xmas and good luck with 10 sets of presents under the tree!! smile

CuppaTeaJanice Fri 24-Dec-10 15:23:05

Honestly? I wouldn't judge - it's your choice (or maybe not, if the last batch were septuplets or something!). I don't understand why people would choose so many, in the same way I don't understand people who have 6 dogs or 15 cats. I like my life to be full of lots of different things, and I think it would be hard to find an enjoyable balance if there was such a hefty demand on my time, emotions and finances from my children.

SeaTrek Fri 24-Dec-10 15:29:27

YANBU if you can afford them financially and give them a warm and loving home.

I think the Duggars to a wonderful job but they have many advantages that are fairly unique to America.

Personally I have one DC as that is the number that DH and I feel we can properly care for given our personalities and level of finanical comfort that we seek both for ourselves and our son.

MadamDeathstare Fri 24-Dec-10 15:35:10

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

midori1999 Fri 24-Dec-10 15:36:47

I think it's completely up to you if you can support them yourself. I am only 1 of 4, but would have loved more siblings. (despite not having much contact now with one brother)

I couldn't have had ten, but will soon have four DC and hope to go on to have no. 5. It's wonderful seeing the DC together.

My Gran was one of 13 children and love/loves it, despite the household always being busy when she was a child. She is one of the oldest and although she did help with the younger ones (as did I in a smaller family) she doesn't feel she brought them up and loved helping her Mum.

effymeffy Fri 24-Dec-10 15:36:53

Good for you, keep enjoying them!! Don't envy your grocery bills though grin

HelloOutThere Fri 24-Dec-10 15:37:41

What made you decide to have so many?

Do you plan any more?

I have a large family in most people's mind anyway so am always interested in others reasons

MissAnthrope Fri 24-Dec-10 15:45:47

We're sat watching Cheaper by the Dozen at the moment... have you considered a couple more wink

mummyloveslucy Fri 24-Dec-10 15:47:19

No, not unreasonable at all. maybe slightly mad and very brave.

I only have one, not through choice though. I find that's hard enough. grin

PressureDrop Fri 24-Dec-10 15:50:22

My honest, honest thoughts when I hear about people who have enormous families are usually along the lines of 'they must be bonkers!' (you did ask), but if you are happy, the kids are happy, you can cope with all the demands....well bloody done! I also doff my cap to you!

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: