Talk

Advanced search

scottish student fees

(32 Posts)
egopostulosomnus Thu 16-Dec-10 07:16:46

With scottish students never having had to pay fees, do a higher proportion of 'poor' students apply than in england?

Or does it not really make a massive difference?
Genuine question, I have no idea....and wouldn't know where to look to find comparison data.

LolaBellsAllTheWay Thu 16-Dec-10 07:23:41

I studied in glasgow, started in 1998 (goodness i'm getting old) and i had to pay fees.

Admittedly it was only just over £1k a year but still had to pay.

Niceguy2 Thu 16-Dec-10 08:29:49

I'm interested to see how the Scots will manage.

Will they be able to continue to keep their uni's fee free? Now England are charging up to £9k the pressure will be on them to either follow suit or publicly declare they won't (and how they will pay).

Already the English subsidise the Scots so it would be a bitter pill for English families to swallow when they have to fork out massive fees whilst their Scottish equivalents get a free pass.

nightmarebeforechristma Thu 16-Dec-10 08:31:18

I wish some would explain this to me.
where does Scotland get it's funds from?
does it get money from the English government?
(sorry if that is a hijack)

AgentProvocateur Thu 16-Dec-10 08:36:00

Yes, because we don't pay any taxes at all... hmm. And Westminster is the uk government, not the English government.

narkypuffin Thu 16-Dec-10 08:36:46

Scottish MPs voted in the recent fees increase that applies in England but not Scotland. And now are going to charge £6k/year to english students going north to avoid the higher fees. angry

Niceguy2 Thu 16-Dec-10 08:50:54

AgentProv. I take it then that you are unfamiliar with the Barnett formula? The taxes Scots pay go directly into the UK govt coffers and how much Scotland gets is determined by this rather unfair formula which was only ever intended to be temporary and in fact has no basis in law.

It's fairly complicated as you can imagine but as far as uni education goes, you'll find that for every fee paying student in England, an amount is transferred to Scotland, in effect subsidising their tuition.

In fact per-capita expenditure on services in England is 97% and in Scotland, 117%. In short, the English subsidise the Scots.

nightmarebeforechristma Thu 16-Dec-10 08:54:52

AgentProvocateur that isn't what I meant, but you kind of explain it, so all parts of UK pay taxes to the one goverment.

sarah293 Thu 16-Dec-10 09:00:11

Message withdrawn

bumperella Thu 16-Dec-10 09:05:34

Personally, I do think fee payment differences in England, Wales and Scotland are hugely unfair. I don't see a real justification for it as such: my understanding of the reason behind it being how the Welsh Assembly /Scottish governement chooses to spend it's "pot".

IMO, items are, or should be, definied by need rather than by who-pays-in: e.g. life expectancy in Glasgow appalling, so higher NHS funding there - not becuase of where it is but because of need. If crime is higher in London, then there should be higher spending on policing there, (I think there already is but wouldn't swear to it!).

Having said that, the "who is a net payer of taxes and who is a beneficiary" actually ends up with the very few subsidising the majority - so a few of the very highest income - pay for the rest of us. It is possible to calculate averages but not very illumincating, particularly if you start faffing about with "ooh, who should pay rent for military /energy installations/ what about N Sea oil...etc etc etc" then it does tend to degenerate into meaningless rubbish.

scotsgirl23 Thu 16-Dec-10 09:11:30

I think we have a reciprocal fee agreement with most EU countries - I could be wrong though, but my understanding is that is the case, so we don't pay to study there, and they don't pay to study in Scotland. The same isn't true for England - Scottish students pay fees if they study in England/

In terms of whether no fees makes a difference, I don't know. I think there are a lot of drivers when it comes to poorer pupils going to university, and in the scale of it fees is a pretty minor one..

I just looked at the leavers destination info for a few schools. The school I went to (state school, outwith catchment in a very middle class area) has 46% of leavers going to higher education, and 34% to further education. By contrast, the school in my catchment when i was growing up (very poor area, entire catchment is a council estate) has 8% and 36% respectively.

thefurryone Thu 16-Dec-10 09:13:01

What interests me is what do people in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland miss out on to get things like free prescriptions and tutition fees paid for.

tyler80 Thu 16-Dec-10 09:16:14

It seems grossly unfair that students from any other EU country pay the same rates as Scottish students whilst English students pay much more.

tyler80 Thu 16-Dec-10 09:19:33

Just to clarify, Scottish students in England pay the same rates as English students and every other eu student. English students pay 'English' levels of fees in Scotland whilst all Scottish students and those from elsewhere in the eu pay nothing.

egopostulosomnus Thu 16-Dec-10 09:24:14

scotsgirl they are the type of figures i was thinking of!
as someone mentioned before though about scottish ministers voting on english matters and then seemingly voting differently on the same subject in scotland hmm whats that about?
also i have wondered the same as thefurryone, what do english taxpayers get that the others dont-free prescriptions have to be paid for by someone dont they?
whatever happened to the UNITED kingdom?

scotsgirl23 Thu 16-Dec-10 09:28:57

Yeah, the voting system is a bit mad. Remember it isn't the same ministers though - different ministers in the Scottish parliament to Westminster.

I don't see how we could possibly have free fees in Scotland for English students though, when the same isn't true in the other direction. Scotland has a fraction of the universities that England does and has made a decision to subsidise higher education. If we did this for english students too, we would be utterly swamped and it would be totally unaffordable.

I don't agree with their being such a mismatch but I don't think blaming Scotland is the solution. There is no way we could afford to provide free education for English students.

MollysChambers Thu 16-Dec-10 09:34:27

The Scotland Act 1998 act states that certain things, referred to as reserved matters, will be dealt with by the Westminster Government including Defence, International Relations, Fiscal and Economic Policy, Drugs Law and Broadcasting.
Anything not mentioned as a specific reserved matter is automatically devolved to Scotland, including health, education, local government, Scots law and all other issues.
So the Scottish Government can spend its money however it sees fit in relation to these matters.
It chooses to subsidise university eduacation. That it the right of the Holyrood Parliament.
The differences in government policy we are seeing between Westminster and Holyrood are in essence because Scotland is a socialist country where the SNP and the Labour Party are the main parties and the Conservative party are a joke.
The Scots as a nation did not vote for the Tories. They were, once again, completely and totally annihilated at the ballot box. Yet we are still governed by them at Westminster.

arudolf Thu 16-Dec-10 09:38:50

lolabells - I studied in Glasgow, started in 1999, had to pay £1K for a year or 2 then fees were scrapped. I think 98-99 were the only 2 years who paid actually.

FanjoForTheMincePies Thu 16-Dec-10 09:40:03

Scotland doesn't get free prescriptions!!

SantasMooningArse Thu 16-Dec-10 09:51:35

Riven- apaprenlty there's an EU law that prevents fees being charged to Eu non dom students. I assume that explains a lot of what happened with Welsh students too. £6k is still potentially cheaper than England no? Although I am not saying I agree with the EU thing- I do not.

Free presecritptions are Welsh; however having lived in both England and Wales what you win you lose out elsewhere. For example we have no regs on school meal quality so most mums I know entitled to free school meals choose not to take them as a classic menu seems to consider hot dog and fries, fish grill and fries, burger all OK in any one week.

not just that obviously- as a family with a few sn kids we have no support in palce, the hospital locally was so bad that maternity cases had to be refused due to danger to life of mother around the time my yongest was born 9thank goodness I had a booked HB!), there's no children's centres or anything like it even for the neediest of children- none of this SN Nursery stuff I read about with envy. Swings and roundabout and tbh I;d gladly pay half the prescription price we paid in England in exchange for access to a decent children's centre like the one I used to work in, or for ds2 to be able to access young carers within the next five years. or for ds2's literacy support (dyslexia, dyspraxia, possible ADD) nto to have been pulled in entirety.

Swings and roundabouts every step of the way.

SantasMooningArse Thu 16-Dec-10 09:53:32

Oh and the thing that came about on the Welsh fees thread was a misunderstanding that students wherever were treated as members of where they study: not so, it is the home LEA that funds or does not. I was funded in Wales by England as I applied from Somerset, but as we'e been here 5 years DH is now funded by Wales: that is why it is organised as it is.

Vassia Thu 16-Dec-10 10:00:23

That's what I was thinking Fanjo! We don't get any free prescriptions. I studied in Glasgow also, and anyone graduating in 2005 and 2006 had to pay £2k to be allowed to graduate. Something the Scottish government brought in, when the SNP came to power they scrapped it. So I think there will always be some sort of fee paying scheme coming and going in Scotland at some point. They like to spring these things on students.

tyler80 Thu 16-Dec-10 10:00:29

Scotsgirl - but Scotland subsidises university for all other EU students (they are required to by European law).

tyler80 Thu 16-Dec-10 10:07:35

As much as I think the union is a good thing, I'd prefer to see total independence than the current system.

Interestingly if that happened and Scotland were in the EU then English students would have the same fees as home students .

scotsgirl23 Thu 16-Dec-10 10:09:05

Yes, but other EU universities subsidise scottish students who go there. England doesn't! If you want subsidies to apply they have to go in both directions, surely?

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: