Talk

Advanced search

to think that vegetarians will not be happy until farm animals are extinct

(70 Posts)
mrleebob Mon 06-Dec-10 18:16:20

Let's face it. If farmers can't sell them, they have no purpose to keep them. So they become near extinct.

Tee2072 Mon 06-Dec-10 18:17:06

Well, I am not planning to stop eating them. So how will that work then?

Goblinchild Mon 06-Dec-10 18:18:13

It is possible for an animal to exist without being a food source, we just wouldn't need quite so many of them.

sarah293 Mon 06-Dec-10 18:18:13

Message withdrawn

TragicallyHip Mon 06-Dec-10 18:18:39

I can't imagine vegetarians would like any animals to be extinct
YABU
bear

SuePurblybiltByElves Mon 06-Dec-10 18:19:23

I do hate the phrase "let's face it" more than any other I think.

Callisto Mon 06-Dec-10 18:20:33

If you buy British, chances are the animal has lived a lovely life with no pain or suffering, bar a tiny bit o stress right at the end. If you buy cheap shit from elsewhere then yes, Riven, you're probably right.

ChippingIn Mon 06-Dec-10 18:20:34

Not you again

biscuit

taintedsnow Mon 06-Dec-10 18:20:59

Oh joy, another bashing of the vegetarians thread. Yawn.

YABVU and you know it.

sarah293 Mon 06-Dec-10 18:21:55

Message withdrawn

TandB Mon 06-Dec-10 18:22:13

Isn't this the trolling DH?

mrleebob Mon 06-Dec-10 18:22:26

I don't think I am TragicHip. I think that a lot of veggies try too hard to force their opinions on others. I once knew a woman who gave a dog a non meat diet. THAT is animal cruelty. And farm animals WOULD become extinct. Where would they live?

Unrulysun Mon 06-Dec-10 18:22:33

hasn't the novelty of this worn off yet?

eviscerateyourmemory Mon 06-Dec-10 18:22:41

The difficulty that many species have in existing given the way that humans tend to treat the envionment is an important point, I agree, but I'm not convinced that it is an arguement for eating meat?

theevildead2 Mon 06-Dec-10 18:22:54

Fuck we better start eating kittens then! Oh and panda bears they are on their way out must be because we don't eat them!!

Callisto Mon 06-Dec-10 18:24:47

Yes, I missed out the sad chickens - didn't mean to. I eat free range or organic, but British welfare standards are so superior to anywhere else, even if it is battery.

mrleebob Mon 06-Dec-10 18:24:51

evildead. You have misunderstood. The majority of farm animals are bred for the sole purpose of being food. Where do they fit into the earth if not for food products?

Unrulysun Mon 06-Dec-10 18:25:27

Yes it's the dh - I'm finding this really patronising tbh. Not sure why it's irritating me so much. I think it's because I'd like for dh and I to have this much time on our hands - this is not what we'd be doing if we did.

BaroqinAroundTheChristmasTree Mon 06-Dec-10 18:25:35

" think that a lot of veggies try too hard to force their opinions on others."

Really - I know loads of vegetarians - not one of them has ever tried to force their opinion on me. Live and let live and all that.

Abr1de Mon 06-Dec-10 18:26:23

It's true that there would be no sheep on many parts of Britain if people stopped eating lamb. We have next to know woollen industry.

panettoinydog Mon 06-Dec-10 18:27:10

yeah, those darn vegetarians are always muttering about the extinction of farm animals and plotting the revolution.

It's not going to happen but so what if they did become extinct?

magicmummy1 Mon 06-Dec-10 18:27:47

You're showing your ignorance. My OH comes from a farming community which is entirely vegetarian. They keep plenty of cows, and their neighbours keep goats, chickens etc.

Ever heard of milk, cheese and eggs?

BaroqinAroundTheChristmasTree Mon 06-Dec-10 18:28:25

Abride - perhaps though if we all stopped eating the lamb then the farmers would turn to wool instead grin

TragicallyHip Mon 06-Dec-10 18:28:39

You asked the question, If you don't think yabu then why did you post? hmm

I have never met a vegetarian who has tried to force their opinions on me

SuePurblybiltByElves Mon 06-Dec-10 18:28:57

mrlee, those animals would die out and be the better for it. They are not bred to live, they are bred to produce. Are you fighting to save the turkey whose legs cannot support its weight? Or the pigs that can't mate unaided?

It's a very silly argument. Were you planning on mentioning at any point that Hitler was a vegetarian? Or banging on about canine teeth? Let's take it as read.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now