Talk

Advanced search

To really hate The Beatles?

(184 Posts)
notnowbernard Sat 20-Nov-10 20:34:19

I find them a bit like a secret I've not been let in on

Find the music tres dull

I get the cultural significance etc but fucking hell, it's been 40-odd years...

GypsyMoth Sat 20-Nov-10 20:35:03

oooh me too!!! watching x fACTOR are you??

SlartyBartFast Sat 20-Nov-10 20:35:21

they were brill. harmonies, singer song writers. you name it. ground breaking - more superlatives

SpringHeeledJack Sat 20-Nov-10 20:35:46

I feel the same about the X factor grin

perfumedlife Sat 20-Nov-10 20:36:24

Me three. And I really don't get the big fuss re Imagine. What a dull song.

As for Cher Lloyd biscuit

MrsChemist Sat 20-Nov-10 20:37:27

It's not so much the music they wrote, but the music that stemmed from what they wrote IYKWIM.

I imagine music being produced now would be different if the Beatles had never existed.

juneybean Sat 20-Nov-10 20:38:30

I thought Imagine was just John Lennon.

SlartyBartFast Sat 20-Nov-10 20:38:57

x factor are ruining them though

Vallhala Sat 20-Nov-10 20:39:07

YANBU. I've never seen the appeal, despite having spent my youth with music business crowd and dating a music journalist.

The music of my youth was very Beatles-influenced and I'm one of The Jam's biggest fans to this day but still I can't see what was ever so fab about the Four.

yama Sat 20-Nov-10 20:39:38

YANBU

southeastastra Sat 20-Nov-10 20:39:55

i love the beatles and the stones and all 60s british stuff

do you hate a certain era of their stuff or all of their stuff?

ShadeofViolet Sat 20-Nov-10 20:41:45

YANBU - so dull and annoying.

notnowbernard Sat 20-Nov-10 20:41:57

I dislike nearly all of it

I can handle bits of it (Sgt Pepper eg) but most sends me to sleep

Overrated is the word that springs to mind

I love other 60s stuff though

Rockbird Sat 20-Nov-10 20:42:25

I really hate them as well. Overrated bunch who think they are God. Paul MacCartney is a talentless fool who trades on his past but forgets that a) it was long long ago and b) they were no great shakes to start with.

I'm a Jam fan as well and I'll take them any day.

PassionKiss Sat 20-Nov-10 20:42:54

YABU!!

X-Factor is what's shit not the Fab Four!

How very dare you grin

notnowbernard Sat 20-Nov-10 20:43:44

This isn't about the X-Factor btw... I've hated them forever grin

southeastastra Sat 20-Nov-10 20:43:59

do you like the stones? grin

PassionKiss Sat 20-Nov-10 20:44:32

Rockbird shock and you from very near their home town I believe!

LetThereBeRock Sat 20-Nov-10 20:48:28

YABVU. And I'm pretty sure that it's against the law to hate The Beatles.

Hassled Sat 20-Nov-10 20:51:09

You should wash your mouths out, you disbelievers shock.

I don't understand how anyone can write off so many albums and such a huge range of styles - Love Me Do was a very long way from Because. And it's that range that has made them revered, I think.

Imarriedafrog Sat 20-Nov-10 20:51:11

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

curlymama Sat 20-Nov-10 20:51:29

Agree. The Beatles are well overrated. It's completely ruining my Saturday x factor experience!

I'd take the Beatles over the BeeGees any day though.

southeastastra Sat 20-Nov-10 20:52:47

i think the beatles are a band that one day you just suddenly 'get' which is nice grin

perfumedlife Sat 20-Nov-10 20:54:41

southeastastra do you mean like when one day you just 'get' athritus?

notnowbernard Sat 20-Nov-10 20:55:05

I'll never 'get' them, truly

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now