Talk

Advanced search

or is it okay to ask someone you haven't seen for a while if they

(26 Posts)
Eve4Walle Mon 15-Nov-10 07:35:09

are pregnant?

Happened to me on Saturday. Saw someone I worked with until March this year and she asked me if I was having another baby and when was it due. I am not pregnant.

It really pissed me off TBH - you might think 'Oh, she looks a big pregnant' but unless you are 100% sure you never ask right? It's just downright rude.

Was quite funny watching her try and carry talking to me as normal once I'd told her I wasn't expecting though!

Eve4Walle Mon 15-Nov-10 07:36:10

bit pregnant...

TheGrumpalo Mon 15-Nov-10 07:39:19

This happened to a friend of mine last year, she was mortified! I feel your anger, I'd be raging grin
I personally wouldn't ask anyone if they were pregnant unless there was no doubt it was a baby bump.

GeraldineAubergine Mon 15-Nov-10 07:41:40

I met someone yesterday who I hadn't seen for eleven months and I was eight months pregnant last time I saw them. They asked me if I had had the baby yet. We were both embarrassed.

onceamai Mon 15-Nov-10 07:59:58

YANBU but I doubt she'll ever do it again.

Dracschick Mon 15-Nov-10 08:07:12

I never ask that question, you never know whether they are having problems conceiving or what ....if they're pregnant they tell you.

She was rude and perhaps jealous of you Eve.

echt Mon 15-Nov-10 08:12:59

Why jealous? Why put that idea in the OP's head?

Talk about upping the ante. hmm

Dracschick Mon 15-Nov-10 08:33:32

Perhaps Eve looks v young and the other woman said that purely out of nastiness ...why is that upping the ante??? fgs its monday morning go back to bed and get out the right side smile.

PuppyMonkey Mon 15-Nov-10 08:38:50

If it's any consolation, when I was a lot younger I made the terrible, terrible mistake of asking someone I'd bumped into after not seeing her for ages "when it was due" - I mean she was wearing a definite maternity frock IMHO - and she just looked at me. Didn't say anything. Because she wasn't. And I wanted the ground to swallow me up. Mortified is not the word. blush blush

I was only young, I promise... have learned my lesson now and would never, never ask this question ever again. Not even if the woman i was talking to had an "I'm pregnant and it's due in January" tee shirt on.

twoboots Mon 15-Nov-10 08:39:17

blush
I have personally been guilty of this:
I was trying to be friendly with a very aloof and scarey work colleague. She made me nervous, so I was trying to think of something to lighten the conversation. I mentioned that she had that wonderful pregnancy glow [mortifed emoticon] luckily she laughed it off and explained that yes her cat just had kittens.
I was 20 at the time, if someone said this to me now, I would try to say something funny.

echt Mon 15-Nov-10 08:39:18

It's the "perhaps" E. looks young.
"Perhaps" she said it out of nastiness.

Why not deal with what was actually said; surely it was thoughtless enough without digging further? The Op had plenty to be going on with. You're suggesting ideas the OP had not put in her post.

Eve4Walle Mon 15-Nov-10 08:40:43

The funny thing is that I've actually lost a fair bit of weight since I last saw her and thought I was looking pretty good grin.

She's not exactly built to supermodel proportions herself. hmm

Phew96 Mon 15-Nov-10 08:46:41

I took DD to be weighed when she was 4 months old and a HV that I had never met before asked me if I was expecting again. I'm afraid I may have been fairly short in my reply to her blush

Funnily enough, the next time I saw that same HV I was 8 months pregnant with DS and she never said a word

thehairybabysmum Mon 15-Nov-10 08:56:46

I've been asked this twice blush this year...my stock answer is 'No i'm just fat' with a big smile....then watch them squirm!!

Secondly i then resolve to lose weight!

Dracschick Mon 15-Nov-10 09:03:19

echt .....im really not getting what your diggin' at?

Eve has took no offence at what I suggested indeed she has already told us shes lost weight and feels shes looking good......

Whats biting you??

I used the term perhaps because I havent seen Eve nor had she until that point mentioned how she looks or feel;s she looks.

FGS.

MmeLindt Mon 15-Nov-10 09:05:34

I would never ever ask this, as I have been on the receiving end of this question shortly after having my second miscarriage.

It is hugely upsetting, much more so than being thought of as fat.

You cannot know if someone is having difficulty TTCing.

A friend of mine has recently admitted that they are giving up TTC and it is so painful for her when she is told by well meaning relatives to not leave it too late.

MmeLindt Mon 15-Nov-10 09:06:25

Not that it would not upset me to be seen as fat, btw. Not meaning to say that it is unreasonable to be annoyed at this.

Jux Mon 15-Nov-10 09:09:10

Ah, poor you. It might simply have been that you were positively glowing with health and she couldn't believe that anyone looked that good without being pg!

DH asked the bride of one of our friends if she was pg - on the wedding day, in her beautiful and v expensive white dress. She wasn't blush

A friend of mine - very slim - was walking through our local town, and some bloke wacked her on the tum saying "Nice one!". She assumed she looked pg. It was hilarious tbh and we nearly weed laughing.

bookeater Mon 15-Nov-10 09:09:36

Someone did this to me once. Made sure I didn't slouch with my belly hanging out after that!

I made the reverse mistake with a lady who looked rather large, but I didn't like to assume it was a pregnancy. When she mentioned she was expecting, I stupidly feigned surprise, "Oh, really?", implying I just thought she was fat. blush

emptyshell Mon 15-Nov-10 09:20:11

I'd get upset by being asked it by anyone old enough to know better to be honest. It's none of their business, if they wait 9 months they'll get a definitive answer either way anyway, and it's the fat/pregnant tightrope.

I'm fat, I get asked quite regularly by little kids if there's a baby in my tummy - that's fine, I just reply that no, there's just cake in there - but I'd be fairly sharp with any adult who dared to start quizzing me like that.

saffy85 Mon 15-Nov-10 09:23:25

My mum asked someone this years ago. Knew the lady from doing the school run.

In my mum's defence the lady had been pregnant so when my mum saw her out shopping and commented "not long to go now!" she wasn't being totally thick or nasty. She felt both when the lady in question politely informed her that she had lost the baby to stillbirth at 7 months gestation. sad and went and sat in her car and sobbed for ages. sad

MmeLindt Mon 15-Nov-10 09:28:39

Oh, Saffy. How sad.

A colleague of mine lost her baby just weeks before her due date. It was horrible for her starting work and people expressing surprise that she was back already.

ConstanceFelicity Mon 15-Nov-10 09:30:56

This happened to me a few times when I lost lost of weight after birth of 1st DS- I think the weight came off everywhere except my tummy. I braved it out then went home and sobbed- weirdly, it never happens when I'm at my biggest...

Flyonthewindscreen Mon 15-Nov-10 09:59:23

I did this once, caught the end of a conversation with someone I didn't know well. I thought she was talking about a 20wk scan she had just had and asked her when it was due. Her baby was 6 months old blush

BeatrixRotter Mon 15-Nov-10 10:05:54

I very nearly did this once. It was the first time I met a family friend and she had 2 children already so I just thought she had number 3 on the way. Anyway I am so glad I didn't say anything!

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: