Advanced search

What is the best bought Christmas pudding?

(31 Posts)
BelligerentGhoul Sun 14-Nov-10 19:48:44

We usually have a Duchy Originals one and they are bloomin' lovely but the price of them does make me feel a bit ill tbh, so last year we had a Waitrose one, which I wasn't fond of.

Are there any others that are really nice but perhaps not as expensive as Duchy?

Hulababy Sun 14-Nov-10 19:52:29

I am considering trying the Heston one in Waitrose.

Rockbird Sun 14-Nov-10 19:54:15

My mum was talking about that one. I haven't looked at it properly, I avoid lots of cherries and nuts as they're foul

BelligerentGhoul Sun 14-Nov-10 19:59:18

Ooh - how much is it Hulababy? The Duchy one was around 13 pounds, I think - because dp insists on buying a humongous one, even though there are only four of us!

Tillyscoutsmum Sun 14-Nov-10 20:00:15

Oooh - have just seen an advert for Heston's orange one in Waitrose. Looks yummy

waterlooroadisadocumentary Sun 14-Nov-10 20:02:38

I am also thinking about buying the Heston one.

BelligerentGhoul Sun 14-Nov-10 20:07:45

Just googled it. It looks gorgeous here

Any more tried and tested favourites? I may buy two!

blametheparents Sun 14-Nov-10 20:10:58

I am very tempted by the Heston one, but what if it is horrible?
Therefore may have to buy two so that I can have one in reserve!

waterlooroadisadocumentary Sun 14-Nov-10 20:11:21

I always make the Delia light pudding with boozy sauce to go with a real one.

alfabetty Sun 14-Nov-10 20:13:22

We are considering the Heston one.

Given the level of interest I would feel justified in purchasing and tasting one now (well, when the shops open tomorrow), and reporting back.

Shall I?

waterlooroadisadocumentary Sun 14-Nov-10 20:14:49

I may buy mine this week as well!

Are people buying the Delia Christmas cake pack. I always make a Delia cake so am considering it but it feels like cheating.

BelligerentGhoul Sun 14-Nov-10 20:15:00

Alfabetty - the whole of Mn would await your verdict tomorrow evening, with baited breath, I'm sure.

BikeRunSki Sun 14-Nov-10 20:24:10

I have had some fab ones from Aldi and Lidl at v low cost.

We always stock up after Christmas as DH loves Christmas pud and insists on one on his birthday in July!

blametheparents Sun 14-Nov-10 20:35:54

I've just made my Xmas cake with the Delia cake pack.
It's a fab idea, got everything you need in the right amounts so no waste.
Cake is cooling now.
Made mine in a 23cm tin though, and cooked ot for 3 hours.
Would prefer a bigger, slightly flatter cake as it is easier to cut into portions.

notabadperson Sun 14-Nov-10 20:36:46

lidl and aldi puddings have more fruit and nut that M&S and Tesco Finest..... (or at least did a few years ago when I compared them - take a look, honestly they are fab)

nameymcnamechange Sun 14-Nov-10 20:38:14

I like the M&S extra luxurious one with brandy and nuts.

I really really really can't be arsed with making the blardy things. There's always so much else to do. And the children don't like it anyway!

CherryMonster Sun 14-Nov-10 20:41:05

i like the sainsburys TTD one. its yummy

alfabetty Sun 14-Nov-10 21:10:28

OK. I shall swing by Waitrose tomorrow and, in the interests of research, purchase a Heston pud.

We have previously had Duchy original (v good), M&S (OK), Aldi (agree, v fruity) and as a child we always had Mrs Peak's which I recall being very fine indeed.

But other puds are being mentioned. Should I sample them all in the interests of a full & comprehensive survey? [sicknesss face]

BelligerentGhoul Sun 14-Nov-10 21:15:41

the Duchy ones really are v good. As the price is so similar, I think I'd go for a Duchy rather than risking an untried Heston, since the reason to not have Duchy was cost. But would be v interested in the results of your research!

alfabetty Sun 14-Nov-10 21:20:15

Just looked it up. £14 and 1.2kg for Heston's. Bit much for a night in on my own wink No sign of a smaller one, but I suppose if you have a cram a whole orange in...

Going to try it before Xmas, but when I've got guests. Will report back but not tomorrow!

There's a small Duchy originals (500g or so) for 7.49 which is a cheaper way of having a delicious pud. On offer with G&B icecream on Ocado.....

blametheparents Sun 14-Nov-10 21:56:08

alfabetty Don't mind coming round to sample it with you smile

notabadperson Sun 14-Nov-10 22:05:09

given price of aldi/lidl puds, worth trying before Christmas just to see what you think. The only bought pudding I've ever had that was better was from Fortnum & Mason..........

MortaIWombat Mon 15-Nov-10 00:27:13

Shhhh! Don't tell them about the Lidl puddings, notabadperson!

<whole almonds, mmmmmmm> grin

DandyDan Mon 15-Nov-10 11:28:00

Lewis & Cooper - ?cid=2000086#2000086

kateecass Mon 15-Nov-10 21:51:49

Good Housekeeping mag have Xmas pud review.

Tesco Matured with cognac 1st (£10)

2nd M&S Luxury (£8)

3rd Waitrose richly fruited (£11)

But Heston's sounds interesting. DH likes the look of it

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, watch threads, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now »

Already registered? Log in with: