This page is no longer current

Survey updated: November 2005

Below we list the three wheelers that scored highest amongst mumsnet members when they were rated on ten different criteria. Of course, the final score isn't everything. There are plenty of excellent models that didn't quite make it into the best of the best because they scored particularly badly on one or two categories (e.g. shopping basket). Those particular categories may not be important to you, so it's worth having a good look at the ratings to find the three-wheeler that suits you.

And remember: if you don't agree with our verdict or can't find your model rated, you can help to make this guide more thorough and accurate by sending a review. Many thanks.

The beginner's guide to buying a three-wheeler / all terrain pushchair
So you're considering a three-wheeler then? A few years ago when these first appeared we'll be honest and say we thought they just might be a fad - I mean how many new mothers are together enough to be able even to locate their trainers, let alone manage running in them? But of course it transpired that these agricultural looking vehicles made light of uneven pavements, muddy fields and sandy beaches alike and what's more their pneumatic tyres and state of the art suspension ensured a ride fit for, well, fit for a baby. And they look really cool too (if that matters).

But before you plump for a three-wheeler, examine your lifestyle. They're not for everyone. If you regularly use public transport or live up or down stairs, weight and portability will probably be key for you - and although some three-wheelers are a lot lighter than others, (the Instep Nipper or Jane Powertrack for example) they can't really compete with an umbrella-style pushchair for portability.

On the other hand if you never use public transport and have few or no steps your baby will be in the height of comfort in a three wheeler and you'll love pushing one around - you really can do it one-handed. Or if you're an outdoor type, forever visiting countryside and beach, with a large car boot and lots of storage space, then one it is probably right up your street.

If you're a keen shopper and are planning on cruising the high street with baby in tow, super-suspension and swivel wheels actually make some models a very good bet. The Mountain Buggy Urban is compact and also highly manoeuvrable, as is the Quinny Freestyle 3 XL and the Mothercare Urban Detour Glacier, which was described as "so easy to push it practically goes by itself." Look out though for stingy shopping baskets and warnings about width - some three wheelers will struggle on narrow pavements and doorways. If you need a pushchair that fits in the boot of your car, the Mountain Buggy Urban and the Jane Powertrack are more compact than most.

Most of the models that made it into the mumsnet selection are suitable from birth. Those that aren't, aswell as some that are, have optional carrycots and many too can take a car seat. So for a bit of extra outlay you can have a full-blown travel system. If you think you'd like that flexibility then look at models like the XTS Twister which have lots of accessories available. And do bear in mind that some models throw in many more extras than others - e.g. with Mothercare's Urban Detour Pinnacle you get a cosytoes, changing bag and raincover all in the price.

And lastly, if you're the type who looks ahead, then Phil & Teds E3 Explorer with it's innovative second child seat is, "a great choice if you are planning on having two kids within two years." And just think how smug you'll be when number two appears!