ZOMBIE THREAD ALERT: This thread hasn't been posted on for a while.
Challenging sexist statements and attitudes from people one can't avoid(30 Posts)
Someone I must see regularly has the infuriating habit of spitting 'You girl' as a negative pisstake comment.
Mainly at our respective DSs.
I need to challenge this, but I'm not sure merely pointing out this sexism will have any impact, and I can't cause a big rift.
Lots of good ideas here.
My personal favourite is to call them on it and compare it to racism. Eg, would you say throw like an Asian? In my experience the direct comparison gets people thinking.
Message deleted by Mumsnet for breaking our Talk Guidelines. Replies may also be deleted.
this "I do challenge other things she says, but I've struggled to address the 'jokey' insult for some reason." really resonates with me. You lose so much face in our culture if you 'can't take a joke' - (I've noticed this now I live elsewhere, where people are less interested in sense of humour as a prestige thing) - and that's why the 'it's only a joke/gawd you humourless feminists can't take a joke!' is such an infuriating response.
I can see why you'd not want to engage, frankly. But that's where disingenuous/overt and obvious reactions can be fun. like, you can either go "I don't get it? (wide eyed) Don't you think girls are good at throwing?" if you're in the mood for being infuriatingly disingenuous, or you can use "HARR HARRDY HARRR! It's so funny because GIRLS ARE RUBBISH! I used to be a girl and I KNOW HOW RUBBISH THEY ARE! THAT'S SO FUNNY! HAAARR HARR!" because often calling out the implied assumptions make people embarrassed at what they're actually saying.
E&M - yes, indeed. Girls like me who once played netball and basketball throw far better than the average bloke.
Have you never heard "he throws like a girl" etc Speedy? Good.
Good grief this thread is so depressing. If it were racial stereotyping it would be quite a different story. Who are these morons? Can we have them shipped off to a volcanic island somewhere?
Aand0 shh, don't tell, but I did think of some of those later. Alas, I've had plenty of chances to have a quip ready, that's all! And it's taken me years... but now my inner Samuel L Jackson is at the ready
Great thread. Really interesting, I have 3 yr old ds and dread the day when he hears anti girl comments. Good idea to stock up on responses and ways of discussing it with him.
Blackcurrants - You are my hero, I only ever think of things to say later!
Plus if this is your main contact with her, you're only really trying to limit the impact of what she says on your DS, by making a joke out of it.
How old is DS? Maybe you should chat to him about what she says sometime? E.g. "Do you remember when Mrs X called you a girl, as if it was a bad thing? Do you know why some people do that?" and then it might be a good jumping off point for a kid-friendly history of sexism talk. He's going to hear it from other people than her and needs to have his own retorts, both mental and verbal.
I do challenge other things she says, but I've struggled to address the 'jokey' insult for some reason.
I think the difficulty is that 'you girl' is just the tip of an iceberg - you are not going to be able to affect that person's attitudes by simply calling them on that, however well-scripted you are. Because, of course, there is a whole mean bitter complex backstory about spitting insults at your child in the first place - and you'll probably get that underlying bitterness directed at you instead.
This is, like tabouleh's saying, where you can see language as a symptom - and although you can have a go at the symptoms it won't deal with the problem unless you get at the cause.
So, what is her cause?
DS (2) does this cute thing sometimes when he's leaning on something, he cocks one leg back and it looks like he's doing an arabesque at the ballet barre. Always play it up.
I'm absolutely signing him up for dance lessons in the future if he wants to go.
And he's getting a doll's buggy for his birthday. Probably the cheapo pink from Argos.
Mind you when I was an under tens football coach I always had to tell them that 'girl' is not a derogratory term.
Yep I've come accross this with dcs friends and totally stumped some of the boys with lines like,
Your mother's a girl and
Aw thanks that's brill that you big girls up so much, your mother did a great job with you didn't she.
Couldn't respond without dissing their own mother HA!
At the moment though my 13yr old ds is baiting me with sexist remarks and have now realised not to go for the jugular straightaway but to 'explore' why he says that, and point out examples he personaaly has had experience of sexism himself.
Therefore having great disscussions despite himself.
wastingaway, I feel your pain. With people like this, IME they generally tend to be such tossers that the only suitable response, I feel, is a hearty slap. All the more necessary since it's a woman saying it. Bloody idiot.
Not a mature response, I know, but bloody satisfying .
I've been thinking... "There's nothing wrong with being a girl, so that's not much of an insult."
Ooh Elephants, how I wish I'd said that
When I get my time machine, that'll be on the list!
One of me female friends at old job used to shout "votes for women!"and make banner-waving gestures when I started challenging sexism, I think because Mrs Banks in Mary Poppins was her only exposure to feminism before me (not joking). She did mean it in a nice way though. and it was an honour to be compared to suffragettes/ists in however ridiculous a way!
Wubbly, did you say "Well you just tuck this baby into your abdomen a sec and I'll get on with shifting the carpet."
I see, wastingaway. Then how about "you're a woman, why would you think being a girl is a bad thing?" or just plain "don't you like girls?".
I'm so glad this new topic has been added. I'm only just beginning to realise how isolated I've become from the world since becoming a SAHM.
I used to work in a largely female workplace, although men held almost all the positions of power. I'd actually forgotton the daily tirade of sexism that was commonplace there. I'd really forgotten how exhausting it was to challenge that almost every minute of the day. Every sucessful woman was belittled on how she looked, no matter how brilliant. It was part of the culture. I was often called Milly Tant as I was the only one prepared to challenge it.
The last time I recall being totally stumped by a ludicrous sexist remark, I was 6 months pregnant and trying to get an old carpet collected by the council. The man who came to collect it said 'I dunno, I thought you women wanted equality' WTF?
wastingaway that's so frustrating! Gah, I admire your calm!
In the which case, I'd go with one of Madwoman's suggestions, laugh uproariously and say "yes, kids, once it was considered to be bad to be like girls - wow, do you remember that? It was years ago! HAH!" or just use Elephant's tactic of "You mean really well?" (Big grin) until she STFU.
If all else fails, I think tabouleh's guidlines for effective interventions look spot-on. And if you want to boost your inner Samuel L Jackson, that post is wonderful
Lots of good stuff here.
I forgot to mention, this is actually a woman who says this all the time.
God blackcurrants I want to stop bigging you up, but that is a brilliant example of the kind of chat I love to have with misogynists: "I like talking about lots of things and I don't want to shag all of them." PMSL.
Have said on another thread, but THE most effective response I've used has been when s/o talks about "throwing like a girl" or "thinking like a girl" etc.
"You mean, really well?" [Eye contact, inquisitive smile.]
They just cannot bring themselves to explain outright that they are being a sexist backsplash.
(I should add, this has worked wonders for me in the past in that it's provided me with a laugh and stopped the perpetrator, who was suggesting I was a dyke because I was outspoken, but I'm not sure it actually EDUCATED him as such. I (and the others there) got a laugh out of "But why should wanting to talk about sexism mean I want to have sex with women? I mean, I like talking about lots of things and I don't want to shag all of them. Can you tell me about how my concern for ending sexual violence is really an elaborate ploy to get women to sleep with me? Would my concern be less effective if I did want to have sex with women? Do you like women? You do? And yet you can do that without caring about rape conviction rates? So maybe I can care about rape conviction rates without fancying women? I mean, the two aren't linked in your case, are they?" - but I doubt he learned much about his own idiotic bigotry ... other than not to voice it near me.
That was enough for me, though.
Actually I have to confess that of course it works both ways.
Since "discovering" Feminism a couple of weeks ago and "introducing" it to DH I then proceded to say to him:
"Oh why don't you be a man about it" about some thing (can't remember what).
Of course I was very very promptly (and correctly) called on this by DH!
I am now firmly of the belief that the use of language shapes opinions and that we should all work on erradicating our own and others sexist remarks/ideas etc.
Join the discussion
Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.Register now
Already registered with Mumsnet? Log in to leave your comment or alternatively, sign in with Facebook or Google.
Please login first.