My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Feminism: Sex & gender discussions

"Teaching men not to rape"

194 replies

Opshinz · 26/03/2014 12:15

I been noticing more and more people spitting rhetoric like this. I love freedom of speech and surely they should be allowed to say this, but.. rather then describe my feelings perhaps I can give an example.

Imagine I was giving a lecture and said "We really need to teach women to stop killing children", or "We really need to teach black people not to eat so much fried chicken".

Anyone have any thoughts?

OP posts:
Report
Cluffyflump · 26/03/2014 12:19

Do lots of women kill children?
Eating fried chicken is not akin to rape or murder Confused

Report
scallopsrgreat · 26/03/2014 12:20

Imagine I was giving a lecture and said "We really need to teach women to stop killing children" Wouldn't have a problem with that. Although I would suggest that it would explore more the reasons around why women kill their children, in the same way that I would expect teaching men not to rape would explore the reasons they do.

"We really need to teach black people not to eat so much fried chicken" As far as I am aware eating fried chicken isn't illegal and any harm caused is to the person themselves. Oh and it is racist.

Report
scallopsrgreat · 26/03/2014 12:21

"Do lots of women kill children?" Well 85,000 children a year in the UK are not murdered by women, no.

Report
NeoFaust · 26/03/2014 12:24

It's the assumption that being a rapist is the natural state of men, but then, through the application of more evolved feminine programming, we can somehow not be.

I'm not a rapist, never have been, never will be, which is why I feel that promoting the idea that all men naturally are is evil. No more, no less.

Report
Cluffyflump · 26/03/2014 12:27

Good.
I've never felt the urge myself. Just checking that I'm not the only one.

Male attitudes to rape/consent do need addressing.
I can't see how working towards that can be a negative.

Report
scallopsrgreat · 26/03/2014 12:32

No it is not assumed that the natural state of men is as a rapist. Men who rape do so because they feel entitled too. It is that sense of entitlement that needs tackling. And that sense of entitlement is brought about by the culture in which they live.

Report
NeoFaust · 26/03/2014 12:39

Male attitudes to rape and consent certainly need clarifying, not least because the discourse on the subject has been exclusively from a feminist (and, lets face it, grossly misandric) viewpoint.

Whether or not there are issues to address will need to wait until data is available from non-biased sources.

For the moment, the promotion of a 'rape-culture' by certain feminist strands leads to a society where all consent is suspect; As a result, even if you have had consensual sex with a woman you are a rapist.

With this sort of attitude prevalent, it's impossible to resolve the issue.


Rape is the worst of crimes, not least for the divide it drives between men and women.

Report
NeoFaust · 26/03/2014 12:42

Men who rape do so because they feel entitled too.

I dispute this. Men who rape do so because they have the opportunity to take something they feel they are not otherwise entitled to. This opportunity could be offered by social expectation or a dark alley - the rapist knows they are a transgressor against the social laws of both men and women, so requires an environment that offers privacy for their crime.

The attempt to conflate the attitudes of rapists with the attitudes of normal men is misandric bigotry, nothing more.

Report
BuffytheReasonableFeminist · 26/03/2014 13:01

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

scallopsrgreat · 26/03/2014 13:01

"The attempt to conflate the attitudes of rapists with the attitudes of normal men is misandric bigotry, nothing more." And who is doing that? Unless of course you think that all men feel entitled to have sex with women?

Most rapes happen in the woman's home by someone they know. Most rapes are planned in advance. Opportunity isn't normally a problem. Rapists will create the opportunities.

And feminists aren't promoting a rape culture. Society, rapists, abusers and their attitudes are doing that quite nicely.

Report
BuffytheReasonableFeminist · 26/03/2014 13:02

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

scallopsrgreat · 26/03/2014 13:03

It is funny how naming a problem is so threatening isn't it Buffy?

Report
RowanMumsnet · 26/03/2014 13:04

This is another re-regging troll, folks. Ban-hammer's been busy this morning...

Do you want to keep the thread?

Report
BuffytheReasonableFeminist · 26/03/2014 13:10

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Sillylass79 · 26/03/2014 13:11

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Sillylass79 · 26/03/2014 13:12

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BuffytheReasonableFeminist · 26/03/2014 13:17

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

TheBookofRuth · 26/03/2014 13:22

But no one says this because they believe all men are rapists. It's pithy rhetoric which evolved in response to a number of police campaigns which centred on educating women on how not to get raped - don't drink too much, don't walk home alone, don't dress provocatively, etc. The phrase is simply intended to put the responsibility for the act back where it belongs - on the perpetrator, not the victim.

Report
NeoFaust · 26/03/2014 13:26

Buffy

I agree that the lessons that teach women 'how not to be raped' are putting the onus in the wrong place. However, it is my solid belief (derived from extensive conversation on the subject and being male) that the attempt to disassociate men from rape isn't some sort of shirking of responsibility for collective guilt - it's attempt to make clear to the world (and above all rapists) that they are NOT US.

Scallops believes that men and society create an acceptance of rapists - that rapists believe that they are tacitly supported by a silent majority of men. In truth (traditionally socialised)men have a violent, virulent hatred towards rapists - they get short shrift in jail, for example - because they have transgressed both the old, patriarchal rules for the acquisition of a mate and the modern values of equality.

So essentially, men are urgently striving, as a class, to ensure that being a rapist is seen as anathema to any acceptable concept of male-ness. They are trying to establish that rape is the responsibility of the rapist, not the victim and not anyone who happens to share the rapists gender. In this the well-meaning rape prevention education is a horrible error, but the feminist pressure to reintegrate 'rapist' into the collective 'male' is still a horrible evil.

Report
TheFabulousIdiot · 26/03/2014 13:29

'teaching men not to rape' usually is something that is said as a direct opposition to 'teaching women not to get raped'.

Report
BuffytheReasonableFeminist · 26/03/2014 13:34

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

scallopsrgreat · 26/03/2014 13:54

Teaching men not to rape is not about saying 'men don't rape'. It is about identifying rape, why men rape, how that is supported by society, looking at the influences on men, the impact on victims etc etc

Rape culture exists NeoFaust. It isn't a matter of whether I believe it or not. Rapists aren't just supported by other men. They are supported by society in general. Men hate rapists when it suits them. Stranger rape, for example. However, they don't seem to want to do much about it do they?

The old patriarchal values for getting a mate included rape. Why do you think marriage was brought into existence? Why do you think it was only 1991 when rape was illegal in marriage?

Here are just a few examples of rape culture:

rantagainsttherandom.wordpress.com/2013/03/19/so-youre-tired-of-hearing-about-rape-culture/

www.opendemocracy.net/5050/sian-norris/sexual-harassment-in-uk-schools

www.theguardian.com/books/2013/jan/26/mary-beard-question-time-internet-trolls

thenewinquiry.com/blogs/zunguzungu/woody-allens-good-name/

Report
NeoFaust · 26/03/2014 14:07

Buffy
They do it where you will be very unlikely to see - amongst themselves. The male-class is a very weird thing to feminist eyes because it is very, very individualistic and private. There isn't a class conscious, nor a political voice. There aren't any movements, or slut-walks or waves - there's just the whispers, the quiet words and the turning of backs.

For every transgressive joke you've heard laughed at, there's the quiet moment where one guy round the pub table mutters 'rapists should get their throats cut' and you can hear the low animal growl of assent and feel the animalistic surge of rage. The reason for newspapers bemoaning the damage to a young mans life from an erroneous/false accusation is that he is now an object of intense hatred and distrust from all of society, but in particular other men - whose hands twitch when they see him pass, who will speak but never communicate. Nobody has sympathy for one they honestly consider a rapist.

As for comments on websites, anonymity breeds cruelty. Some of the things I see said about men on this website (which I'd never characterise as sexist) make my heart pound and my soul ache.


The change is slow - glacially slow - but that's the inevitable nature of social change. It's silent and private, secretive and subtle - as society has trained men to be about their inner world. It's a change in climate, not a revolution, but it is happening inexorably.

I don't think you'll actually believe me, but it's true.

Report
scallopsrgreat · 26/03/2014 14:12

"reason for newspapers bemoaning the damage to a young mans life from an erroneous/false accusation" I don't think that was what Buffy was referring to, false accusations (25 posts before that gets mentioned must be a record), but actual convictions. Steubenville & Ched Evans spring to mind but there are many others.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.