Tiny issue in comparison to most, but skin care...

(30 Posts)
Kamchatka Sun 22-Sep-13 18:08:56

I was given some free face cream samples at work yesterday, so this morning I tried some serum or other. First time, so I had to read the instructions.

After wading through some crap about Walchivia extract or hermodiastic skin unification (see I can make up words too!) I found that you smear it on, the smear on your usual face cream.

I thought: if this is actually any use then bunging moisturiser on top of it immediately is going to upset the formula, ruining the carefully 'explained' effects of the serum. So...it can't, surely, be worth anything, from a scientific point of view. Never mind the made up words and long-winded phraseology.

I've felt this for a long while, but it bothers me that women are marketed random 'smeary stuff' so easily and widely, and it bothers me that they buy and/or covet the high end stuff when plainly they are being duped. Is there any sort of publicity or campaigning about this that anyone's aware of?

wol1968 Tue 24-Sep-13 00:44:10

Sometimes I amuse myself by going through the ingredients list on the box and try and identify which chemical corresponds to the magical wonder ingredient with the fancy name in the advert. 'Boswelox' (remember that?) turned out to be a very small amount of frankincense oil, more a fragrance than anything else.

Other trumpeted ingredients are essential oils (potentially irritating to skin as well as temper), various forms of synthetic/plant-derived grease, emulsifiers, sunscreens and preservatives. There's a well known night serum marketed as an anti-ageing product that contains sunscreen (methoxycinnamate). Sunscreen at night? Why? confused

WhentheRed Mon 23-Sep-13 23:15:31

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

BasilBabyEater Mon 23-Sep-13 21:07:03

I googled Randall Wicket but a whole load of stuff comes up about a cricketer. confused

grin

*in her 50s

I can't quite get my head around how vegetable or herbal extracts are going to work. we aren't made up of vegetable protein are we? A friend of mine in the 50s with beautiful skin swore by some French stuff with fish oil in it? Bonsoir might know what it is?

Its one of those what if situations for me, what if I don't use it, what if I stop using it, what if I had never started using it. I can't make a comparison or know with any certainty whether my face cream does anything but I'd probably panic if one of you ran off with it!

Kamchatka Mon 23-Sep-13 20:19:44

Oh I absolutely agree that something on the skin is far better than nothing, and the best product will be different for everyone's individual skin "chemistry" - but all the anti-aging, serum/BB/Ojon Oil=coconut oil/rare plant extracts "have been found to improve X normal skin feature" GUFF that litters our lives: it's the brazen guffness of it that offends. And then you layer on top of that the false advertising and the horrible overperfected, emaciated, massive-haired images of womanhood.
It's hateful.

Bonsoir Mon 23-Sep-13 20:07:05

FloraFox - my DP does sell vitamins and food supplements. That's why I feel qualified to talk about them.

wordfactory Mon 23-Sep-13 20:06:39

I think much of the beauty industry is built on making women worry and playing on existing anxieties.

The idea that aging is wrong and must be fought is extremely corrosive. That a cream can be armour in this battle is pretty cynical.

That said, some face creams do help some skin conditions. And some creams do help and protect...

Pachacuti Mon 23-Sep-13 19:48:36

^Walchivia extract
hermodiastic skin unification
Snorgellopsia extract^

Have you considered doing this professionally, OP? <<wilfully misses point of thread>>

NotDead Mon 23-Sep-13 19:48:24

its interesting how easily journalists who coukd criticise the claims are very easy to buy off witg free samples of the serum they would ordinarily be dissing (financial times especially!!)

ButterMyArse Mon 23-Sep-13 19:42:14

I'm always boggled at how otherwise intelligent friends of mine are completely sucked in by the pseudo-science of the marketing surrounding these products.

My eyes were opened a few years ago when reading (it might've been Bill Bryson's Made in America?) how an advertising company invented the concept of 'micro moisturising beads' or whatever and then a skincare company worked to actually make the product. It's a total farce.

MrsSlocombe Mon 23-Sep-13 19:40:58

rather a pricey boots own brand serum as I recall though meditrina. Agree that there is probably surprisingly little difference between the vast majority of moisturiser in terms of effect.

meditrina Mon 23-Sep-13 19:35:44

I thought that Which? Magazine had done some testing on this.

Using some form of moisturiser is better than using none (so Bonsoir's family finances are safe). But as long as you use something regularly, it doesn't really matter which one. The differences are tiny, and the only one that stood up to scrutiny was a Boots own brand serum.

WhentheRed Mon 23-Sep-13 19:34:58

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

specialsubject Mon 23-Sep-13 19:34:31

a combination of the perception that knowing basic science makes you a 'geek' (rather than well-informed) and succumbing to the belief that anyone can really look like the anorexic, photoshopped freaks that appear in the magazines.

campaigns to deal with both of these would be great. Starting in schools.

Kamchatka Mon 23-Sep-13 19:28:34

I googled Paula Begoun, but came up with this as first hit: she sells her own line of face creams here.

Kamchatka Mon 23-Sep-13 19:26:56

It's an error, Bonsoir, to suppose that because the supplement industry is riddled with dishonesty, the face-cream industry is therefore all right. Both can be pretty bloody awful, but if it keeps you well then I can see why you would employ wilful blindness.

WhentheRed Mon 23-Sep-13 19:21:34

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

FloraFox Mon 23-Sep-13 19:10:45

unless someone comes along and tells us their DP sells food supplements/vitamins and it feeds their family? hmm Then they can tell us to get our knickers in a twist about some other random thing?

Bonsoir Mon 23-Sep-13 18:29:25

If you want to get your knickers in a twist about being duped, try food supplements/vitamins... a whole other duplicitous story...

Bonsoir Mon 23-Sep-13 18:28:19

My DP sells face creams - masses of them. That's what feeds our family. Women aren't systematically being duped. And actually, men are big buyers of face cream too. Creams make a big difference to the quality of your skin (as do other treatments).

BasilBabyEater Mon 23-Sep-13 18:26:05

This is actually a really interesting issue isn't it?

I'd love a scientist to go through all the ingredients and analyse the shit the cosmetics company talk about them.

I thought that Channel 4 programme was going to do some of that - you know the one that was on recently, a series where they test out various claims, but when I watched an episode of it, it just looked like they were selling it all.

WhentheRed Mon 23-Sep-13 18:05:26

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

FloraFox Mon 23-Sep-13 17:19:30

When I say I'm not sure if they have done this, I mean I'm not sure if they have ever carried out a review on this industry sector. It would be interesting if they did because I think lots of people are taken for a ride on these products and the way they are sold.

FloraFox Mon 23-Sep-13 17:17:42

I think a lot has to do with advertising spend. Cosmetics companies are huge spenders on print media, especially with publications targetted at women. I can't imagine any publication putting their heads above the parapet on this issue, even though I'm sure lots of journos must know it's mostly snake oil. More serious journos probably don't care about this issue.

The place this generally gets dealt with is by the Advertising Standards Authority but only really in the context of individual complaints about claims for products. I don't know who makes these complaints (possibly competitors). The Office for Fair Trading could potentially deal with it on an industry level, I'm not sure if they have done this.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now