Renault Clio ad banned for exploiting women - after only one complaint

(37 Posts)
BIWI Wed 17-Jul-13 12:53:35

Story here

Whilst I'm appalled that anyone at the agency could consider this an acceptable piece of advertising, it's gratifying to see that it's been banned after only one complaint!

(I realise that by providing the link I'm actually giving the ad more air time, but I think you need to see it to realise just how jaw-dropping it becomes)

meddie Thu 18-Jul-13 12:41:37

The first part of the ad was fun. If they had just had a line of can can dancers going left to right then off screen, that could have worked. But half the ad of women lap dancing a car.....yuk.

BIWI Thu 18-Jul-13 11:14:48

Well, sad that I am blush I actually e-mailed the ASA to ask about this yesterday. Their website says that they respond to queries within 24 hours, so it will be interesting to see what they say/if they respond!

And my response is still not up on the Perry's website. Funnily enough, there are still 0 comments in reply to the article

teetering13 Wed 17-Jul-13 23:07:32

Agree with captchaos .. and yes, I guess I'm the cynical type too confused

wem Wed 17-Jul-13 17:49:58

Could be a marketing ploy still, in that they went so far so that ASA would have no choice but to ban it, giving them publicity. Because it is just unbelievably crass.

I have to say at the beginning of the ad I was surprised to see it showing two blokes going for test drives. I know nothing about cars and even I know Clio is a 'woman's car'. It's possible it could simply be an incredibly idiotic attempt to appeal to men. How insulting, to everyone!

BIWI Wed 17-Jul-13 17:49:35

.... although, presumably, making something just to be shown in the internet is a way around being banned. I presume that the ASA can ban ads from being shown on television but not sure what their powers are for internet-based advertising

BIWI Wed 17-Jul-13 17:43:31

Nope - can't be a marketing ploy - ASA wouldn't get involved in anything like that.

MmeLindor Wed 17-Jul-13 17:21:38

Shame, cause if they had stuck with the romantic Paris (and the witty bit with Papa?! referencing the old ads) then it would have appealed to women, who are probably more their target market for the Clio.

Having half-naked women just made it cheap and tacky.

And yes, I am cynical enough to wonder if it was a marketing ploy

weirdthing Wed 17-Jul-13 17:20:47

That is horrible!

BIWI Wed 17-Jul-13 17:19:54

And funnily enough, my comments have yet to appear on Perry's site ... hmm

K8Middleton Wed 17-Jul-13 17:16:30

From the piece linked it seems Resault tried everything to justify the ad!

Honestly it was like a teenage boy's wet dream. It just went on for so long and you couldn't even see the car.

Funny way to advertise a women's car hmm

Owllady Wed 17-Jul-13 17:14:13

It is actually pretty degrading to men as well to depict them as simple creatures who like fawning with their tongues handing out over ladies in underwear hmm

BIWI Wed 17-Jul-13 17:08:15

Except it was the Advertising Standards Authority who actually banned it. Although quite what they have banned it from, I have no idea - as it is freely available, as far as I can see.

CaptChaos Wed 17-Jul-13 14:58:53

A cynical little voice is telling me that maybe Renault didn't need a real live complaint before they pulled the ad. It's suggesting that pulling it, but having it on YouTube and TELLING people that there had been complaints about it from wimmenz was all part of the campaign.

You know, in a kind of, 'we want to sell this car to men, only men would appreciate such a fab car, all women do is complain about how sexy this car is, look, beautiful women who get their bras out love this car, and they will love you if you drive it' style of things.

MN is making me question everything. I am becoming very cynical about pretty much everything now.

ImNotBloody14 Wed 17-Jul-13 14:52:41

wonder why they had no female test drivers? oh yeah.... hmm

Owllady Wed 17-Jul-13 14:40:54

urgh! and the bloke is acting like he has never seen a woman ina bra before ffs
what is he 12? hmm

BIWI Wed 17-Jul-13 14:40:22

I have commented on that piece. Let's see if my comments pass their moderation team!

BIWI Wed 17-Jul-13 14:39:15
Twirlyhot Wed 17-Jul-13 14:35:18

I wonder if it's the advertising agency that made the 'complaint' and the reason it was pulled so fast is that Renault chose not to defend it. It's getting them more publicity this way.

A more honest ad for Renault would have had bits of the dancers flying off mid can-can.

TondelayoSchwarzkopf Wed 17-Jul-13 14:34:44

It's got nothing to do with free speech; advertising is not free speech - that's why it costs so much. It is regulated and objectification of women is not permitted in any medium.

ImNotBloody14 Wed 17-Jul-13 14:33:33

so basically their cars are so shit the need to give a man an erection before he'll even consider buying one? not saying much for Renault is it?

PoppyAmex Wed 17-Jul-13 14:29:12

Good!

Didn't Audi self-censored themselves after bad feedback for their weird "quality" ad? I think they swiftly changed the whole campaign.

BIWI Wed 17-Jul-13 14:26:50

It's interesting, isn't it, that it's been banned. Yet it's still freely available on the internet. (And I know I've contributed to that too)

DoesBuggerAll Wed 17-Jul-13 14:23:00

It's a rubbish ad. As others said, it could have been ok but they ruined it by being about 2 mins too long.

CaptChaos Wed 17-Jul-13 14:20:51

Who the actual fuck thought that that would be ok as an ad for anything, let alone a crap car? They could have made it a lot shorter (but equally vile) by having a short film of the anorak wearing creeps jacking off to porn, with a small toy car in the picture.

NoComet Wed 17-Jul-13 14:08:13

Fuck, as others have said it would have worked perfectly a minute shorter with relatively decently dressed can can dancers going across the screen and the back drop changing.

As it is it just says "Clio, driven by small dicked, ugly man, who can't afford a decent car. Probably spends all his money on sex sites."

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now