My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Join the chat on our Weight Loss forum.

Weight loss chat

atkins

10 replies

franyfroo · 22/02/2007 21:46

anyone done it, how much could one loose in a month. are there any online copies of the diet. anyone want to join me

OP posts:
Report
franyfroo · 22/02/2007 22:11

anyone.

OP posts:
Report
franyfroo · 23/02/2007 09:01

ok, so can i eat burgers, costing me a fortune in meat.

OP posts:
Report
wannaBeWhateverIWannaBe · 23/02/2007 09:22

don't do it. it's unhealthy and will make you feel awful. In the beginning you will get headaches, tiredness, and once you go into ketosis you will have bad breath.

And there are several documented cases of people who have suffered heart failure following doing the atkins diet. In fact the atkins co is no more as they filed for bankrupcy last year due to the increasing unpopularity of the diet.

There is no evidence that shows that you are any more likely to keep weight off doing the atkins diet than any other diet.

your best bet would be to calory count or do one of the points diets that allows everything in moderation, coupled with regular exercise.

Report
Furball · 23/02/2007 09:34

Lovely greasy breakfast sounds great when you think of dieting but after day 3 - yuck. No bread, no potatoes, no pasta. Having your spag bol with cauliflower instead of pasta. The reality is on paper you think 'great' after a few days, you think. I just want a bowl of cornflakes for breakfast! oh and also no or little fruit. No healthy at all.

Try something like GI diet (google for more info) - easy to slip into everyday life, easy to understand and easy to stick to (which is the main thing!) oh and very very healthy.

Report
Nip · 23/02/2007 09:35

Franyfroo - I did it a few years ago - and when i need to lose a little i do it (but not fully)

I dont think its great for your body and you certainly cant keep it up - but its a good way to lose weight fast!

Report
Nip · 23/02/2007 09:37

I forgot to add if you like meat like me - its not that hard - but after i did it the first time and lost 3 stone in 4 months (You can see how drastic it is!!!) i decided i wouldnt do it fully again.

Now i just kerb the amount of carbs i have when i want to lose weight - i dont cut them out totally. In the summer its a lot easier because you can have a nice steak with salad for example.

Report
franyfroo · 23/02/2007 17:23

ok, thanks. what is the best g i diet book, anyone know.

OP posts:
Report
lupo · 25/02/2007 08:15

Yes, did this but not followed it exacetly, still had cereal for breakfast and fruit, just didnt eat carbs in evening..helps lose about a stone but you have to do it for life, though, soon as you start eating lots of carbs in the evening weight goes back on

Report
Lovecat · 07/03/2007 14:42

I did it for 3 years before I got pregnant with DD and I don't think I'd have got pg without losing all that weight - in total I lost 4 stone and went from a lumpy size 16 to a very shapely size 10. I was full of energy, my skin was fantastic and I didn't have that horrible drawn look that peeps who lose a lot of weight tend to get on low-fat diets spits.

People who say it's unhealthy either haven't read the book properly (it's amazing how many peeps don't bother to read the research and the reasoning behind something and just dive straight into the diet, then complain when it doesn't work properly or they feel ill) or just haven't read it at all and have believed the scare stories in the media.

It's not just eating meat, I ate more green veg on that diet than any other time in my life! I had to have an emergency c-section and the doctors and midwives were very impressed with my blood counts and blood pressure - not something that would have happened had I been living on baked potatoes and beans on toast like I used to!

There is a support website which is really, really helpful and informative, here and I found it a lifeline while I was doing it.

Unfortunately I stopped doing it while I was pg as I didn't want to take any risks (we'd been trying 10 years to conceive), consequently the weight piled on and 2 years later I'm still trying to get motivated enough to get back on it - it's a lot of hard work preparing all your food from scratch!

And that's probably the biggest downside - the intensive cookery - the whole point of Atkins (which sadly his company ignored) is that you eat 'proper' food without the processing, the artificial additives, transfats etc that give you health problems. And doing that with a 2 year old is almost impossible! I'm waiting for her to get a bit less demanding before I go back to it....

Report
OrmIrian · 08/03/2007 13:02

hear hear lovecat! I'm giving low-carb a break atm and trying to eat moderately and do loads of exercise, but not because I think lc is unhealthy simply because I want to know I can eat normally without the safety net of the diet ifswim. Atkins made me realise that I have a real problem with sugar and made me much more aware of what I eat. Pre-Atkins I was bingeing and steadily putting one more and more weight.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.