Manufactured Baby Food - not a surprise

(55 Posts)
FrauMoose Tue 10-Sep-13 07:15:51
mrsmartin1984 Tue 10-Sep-13 09:52:39

I felt so smug for not using them when I read this. Totally validates why I do BLWing

LittleBearPad Tue 10-Sep-13 09:57:11

Good for you mrsmartin. Always good to be able to feel smug so early in the morning

And I did BLW too

FrauMoose Tue 10-Sep-13 10:07:08

I was skint when my daughter was a baby. And I remembered how high a proportion of the jar got wasted from when my little brother was fed the jars. So making baby food ourselves seemed the obvious thing to do.

Mashing up bananas, carrots etc etc really didn't seem that hard.

Maybe if you don't cook for the adults/older children but just heat up processed stuff doing food for a baby seems difficult?

Sleepybunny Tue 10-Sep-13 10:17:51

Good god, I think if I read another article or comment on the benefits of BLW, milk the main source of nutrition until 1yr, breast is best, I think my head will actually explode. grin

I breast feed, do BLW but as I have given a couple of formula bottles, spoon fed a few times and used a Ella's pouches I feel so incredibly guilty! Think I have to get of mn for a while confused

FrauMoose Tue 10-Sep-13 10:31:00

I'm assuming BLW is breast-led weaning. When my daughter was a baby the six month thing wasn't the big deal it is now - four months seemed the standard, and as my daughter was permanently voraciously hungry the health visitor said it was no big deal if I offered her a bit of baby rice when she was about 15 weeks.

So I'm not a breast-feeding only evangelist. More of a foodie who dislikes the way we're pressured into buying overpriced junk under the pretence that it's good for us.

FrauMoose Tue 10-Sep-13 10:41:09

No it must be 'baby led weaning'...

OneLittleToddleTerror Tue 10-Sep-13 12:24:42

I don't think the article is saying BLW is best. It's saying that manufactured food is a lot less nutrient dense than homemade food. And that they have less calories per weight then formula. It is a useful thing to know, especially for those parents who are contemplating using solids from jars/pouch to fill up their LO in the hope of making them to sleep through.

Homemade food is very clearly purees in the study.

And that they also use infant formula for comparison.

OneLittleToddleTerror Tue 10-Sep-13 12:25:05

It's on the BBC too btw, www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-24013437

bigkidsdidit Tue 10-Sep-13 12:28:10

It's talking about Home made food not blw.

mrsmartin1984 Tue 10-Sep-13 12:43:51

I know it's not talking about BLWing. But BLWed babies wouldn't use that stuff.

LeBFG Tue 10-Sep-13 12:51:51

BLW babies can eat junk too - rusks, biscuits, cakes, crisps...

Manchesterhistorygirl Tue 10-Sep-13 12:56:39

I did blw (with ds1 it was called letting him help himself) with both of mine, but I also used the pouches when out and about and not able to stop and give a proper meal. This article is a bit "and in other news pope is catholic". It tells us nothing we didn't already know and quite frankly it must be a slow news day. Why can't we also just raise our children in our way? Why does everything have to have a bloody label?

TheContrastofWhiteonWhite Tue 10-Sep-13 13:03:39

It's not really a shock is it? I mean, it isn't a good idea for pre-prepared and processed food to form your whole diet as an adult or child. A baby isn't likely to be much different.

What I take from this is the fairly obvious 'handy for out and about and when you are in a big hurry but best not to always feed your child from pouches/jars'. TBH, I'd have thought that was true solely from a cost perspective anyway.

bigkidsdidit Tue 10-Sep-13 13:04:49

I saw a blw thread once where someone said Ella's kitchen pouches were ok of the baby held and sucked them -grin

Anyway. I did spoon feedig and finger foods and used maybe three pouches a month when out. Very useful to have one in the change bag. That they're worse js no surprise is it, but you can't cart freshly prepared food out with you all the time.

I don't understand why people don't know this already. Commonsense I'd have thought.

OneLittleToddleTerror Tue 10-Sep-13 13:13:15

I don't know if it's common sense actually. I've seen people on here defending that Ella pouches are just as good as homemade. They have some very clever marketing.

A friend of mine also gave me advice when I was weaning DD to use tinned fruit. Apparently they are in fruit juices so as good as the real thing. I didn't contradict her but just smile and nod.

OneLittleToddleTerror Tue 10-Sep-13 13:13:15

I don't know if it's common sense actually. I've seen people on here defending that Ella pouches are just as good as homemade. They have some very clever marketing.

A friend of mine also gave me advice when I was weaning DD to use tinned fruit. Apparently they are in fruit juices so as good as the real thing. I didn't contradict her but just smile and nod.

flatmum Tue 10-Sep-13 13:20:58

personally I am grateful to Ella's kitchen, my children wouldn't have survived without those pouches! think it would have done them more harm being stuck indoors with me all day cooking than getting out and about in the fresh air (I get very stressed when cooped up in the house with a small baby).

as long as their breakfast and dinner are good quality homemade meals I am afraid I can't get worked up about a few fruit pouches a week.

Everything in moderation and all that

GingerBeerAndTinnedPeaches Tue 10-Sep-13 13:21:17

It's only true if the person preparing the food knows how to cook and create a balanced diet. Manufactured baby food is better than a crap diet of homecooked rubbish.

I did everything homecooked for DD1, and DD2 gets some manufactured stuff as well as the homecooked stuff, due to lack of time and energy. I trust myself to do what is best, and these articles aren't actually helpful.

I weaned traditionally for both (purees and finger foods).

OneLittleToddleTerror Tue 10-Sep-13 13:28:19

No one is saying a bit of pouch is bad. No one says you can't exist on a diet of pouches Even. it is simply about being informed. Just like adults have takeaways, microwave dinners and eating out. Why does everyone have to go so defensive about this? I know chips are bad and DD had chips from she started solids. But I won't fool myself think fruit shoot is just as good as an orange. Or that that chicke stew in a pouch really is as good as a pot of real chicke stew.

schmee Tue 10-Sep-13 13:36:01

onelittletoddlerterror Tinned fruit can actually be more nutritious than fresh fruit as it is canned nearer the source and loses less of the nutrients (unlike vegetables btw which tend to lose nutrients when tinned). So less good than an apple picked straight from your tree, but better than strawberries from New Zealand that have sat in your fridge for a week.

schmee Tue 10-Sep-13 13:38:51

And actually I think the BLW thing is a complete red herring. My BLW DD had a far inferior diet to my partially spoonfed DSs. Not for want of trying, but she just spat out or ignored the good stuff.

OneLittleToddleTerror Tue 10-Sep-13 13:53:54

schmee if you are referring to that study from
well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/05/27/really-the-claim-fresh-produce-has-more-nutrients-than-canned/

Then the caveat being "Nutrient density measures were based on 6 nutrients. Based on Dietary Guidelines to Americans, vegetables are important sources of fiber, potassium, magnesium, and vitamins A, C, and K in the American diet" and also "the nutrient density score used here focuses solely on nutrients to encourage, and does not account for fat, sugar or sodium."

They are all very interesting scientific study for sure.

Andcake Tue 10-Sep-13 14:55:31

Ella's are really sweet - and it is common sense that packaged food is not as nutritious as homemade its the same for adults.

I think its all about just making sure you give your baby a balanced diet and the occasional pouch won't do any harm but check the ingredients and nutritional value on the pack. Some of ella's savory ones are mostly fruit (thats why babies love them so much) but its not great for them. other brands seem to be more balanced although the study compared some of those too i think.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now