Shetland-bbc1 Sunday @ 9.

(50 Posts)
Sugarice Fri 08-Mar-13 09:17:59

Another crime murder whodunnit set in....................Shetland!

Douglas Henshall is the copper and the scenery looks stunning, really looking forward to this.

Please be good.

diddl Fri 08-Mar-13 10:47:48

Looking forward to this also.

Although after the tripe that was Mayday...

Still, at least there will be Douglas Henshall the scenery to make it worthwhile.

I will be watching! Scenery looks stunning doesn't it.

Sugarice Fri 08-Mar-13 11:51:17

Although after the tripe that was Mayday...

I know, there can't be another duffer of a series as bad as that , can there? hmm.

It could be bad, but they like to get our hopes up with these ads. smile

scampadoodle Fri 08-Mar-13 17:09:28

The books it's based on are really good, and it's Douglas Henshall not David Tennant as was once mooted - yay!

legohamster Sat 09-Mar-13 09:38:47

It will clash with Broadchurch on Monday night, will be interesting to see which one comes out on top.

Very much looking forward to it, can't wait!!

Sugarice Sun 10-Mar-13 21:15:11

Love it, just like wallander!

PirateHat Sun 10-Mar-13 21:20:46

Looks nice doesn't it? Accents are wrong though.

Highlander Sun 10-Mar-13 21:36:35

Sandy has a western isles accent.

PirateHat Sun 10-Mar-13 21:42:14

Yeah they seem to be doing "Scottish" of varying types, which is nothing like how Shetland people speak.

I am also loving the Shetland facts they are crowbarring into the script. Can't wait to see Up Helly Aa!

Highlander Sun 10-Mar-13 21:56:29

It's all a bit posh. I'm a bit rough, but I always found Orcadians and Shetlanders utterly unintelligable grin

YouMakeMeWannaLaLa Sun 10-Mar-13 21:57:57

Awful, turned over.

Slow and confusing; quite an achievement.

The characters had no character (a murder in a remote community and everyone just carries on as normal) and the accents were all wrong.

What a waste, could have been great.

Horsemad Sun 10-Mar-13 22:00:14

I loved the scenery but think the story is a bit slow.

cocolepew Sun 10-Mar-13 22:00:18

It's a bit boring...

Roisin Sun 10-Mar-13 22:00:33

I didn't particularly enjoy it: normally love Douglas Henshall.
Still, solves the clash with David Tennant tomorrow!

MousyMouse Sun 10-Mar-13 22:01:28

I quite like it so far --but wouldn't be able to distinguish scottish accents.
stunning landscapes.

WitchOfEndor Sun 10-Mar-13 22:02:47

Bloody hell, just realised I've missed the first one and there's no repeats!

Horsemad Sun 10-Mar-13 22:03:47

Will it be on iPlayer?

tigerdriverII Sun 10-Mar-13 22:11:15

I love the books. This wasn't like the books and Douglas h just isn't jimmy Perez. He just isn't!!

They did all seem to have random Scottish accents, I've never been to Shetland or Orkney but I can't imagine they have west Scotland/Glasgow/ western isles accents....

Scenery was good though. I lost the plot early n, or it lost megrin

JaquelineHyde Sun 10-Mar-13 22:14:19

I've got it on sky+

Having lived there I can't wait to watch it.

The only thing that has looked authentic so far from the clips is the scenery but I suspect if they had real Shetland accents no one would understand a bloody word that was being said grin

GeorginaWorsley Sun 10-Mar-13 22:16:32

Have read the books ,not watched yet but recoeded.
Books great,storylines tweaked a bit though,

Clawdy Sun 10-Mar-13 22:19:43

Nothing like the books which are really good. Jimmy Perez should be dark and Mediterranean-looking,and he does not have a female sidekick and a teenage (step)daughter.They are trying to make it into a Scottish Wallender and it hasn't worked.

Clawdy Sun 10-Mar-13 22:20:46

Nothing like the books which are really good. Jimmy Perez should be dark and Mediterranean-looking,and he does not have a female sidekick and a teenage (step)daughter.They are trying to make it into a Scottish Wallender and it hasn't worked.

Clawdy Sun 10-Mar-13 22:21:51

Nothing like the books which are really good. Jimmy Perez should be dark and Mediterranean-looking,and he does not have a female sidekick and a teenage (step)daughter.They are trying to make it into a Scottish Wallander and it hasn't worked.

Squirrelface Sun 10-Mar-13 22:21:51

Was it just me then, who struggled to understand half the dialogue?
Lovely scenery though!

Clawdy Sun 10-Mar-13 22:23:29

Oops sorry didn't mean to post three times !!

highlandcoo Sun 10-Mar-13 23:44:20

I like Dougie Henshall - he was great in South Riding I thought - and haven't read the books yet so had no preconceptions about his appearance etc.

I wanted to really like it - and it was okayish I thought, but nothing to set the heather on fire grin

The accents were bowfing though

Sugarice Mon 11-Mar-13 07:26:17

Well I loved it so much I fell asleep grin and woke up during the news , not sure I'll tune in tonight.

I was disappointed. Won't watch tonight.

valiumredhead Mon 11-Mar-13 16:00:59

It was soooooo dull!

guineapiglet Mon 11-Mar-13 16:51:39

Out of all the dramas which graced our screens last week ( Lightfields/May Day and Broadchurch) it was the one we all enjoyed the most really - it was a bit more Scandi drama than the others - I thought it was very atmospheric and absolutely loved the scenery and the settlements and the amazing seas around the islands, I just wish someone could come up with a crime drama WITHOUT a murder if that makes sense, I fear we are getting immune to all these horrors, whereas I could get absorbed in something like a mild conspiracy, blackmail, etc etc, - will watch again tonight, and tape Broadchurch in the hope that gets better as well. smile

louisianablue2000 Mon 11-Mar-13 18:19:18

Steven Robertson, who plays Sandy (and Mr Rook in Being Human), is from Shetland so his accent was right but yes, some of the others waxed and wained (I'm from Orkney so can spot a Shetland accent a mile off). I did have a giggle at the washing flapping like crazy on the washing line and the joke about the man wearing goretex, and I liked that the local touches like the Shetland Boat and archaeology storylines. It looked gorgeous (I never thought January in the northern islands could look so good) but the storyline was a bit standard issue Sunday night drama.

IrnBruTheNoo Mon 11-Mar-13 18:55:41

"Steven Robertson, who plays Sandy (and Mr Rook in Being Human), is from Shetland so his accent was right"

I suspected as much, louisiana although DH was a bit baffled with the array of Scottish accents all the cast seemed to have!

Will be tuning in tonight again, quite enjoyed the drama. Agree with another poster though, it is slightly slow paced. Still, I want to know what happens in the end! grin

IrnBruTheNoo Mon 11-Mar-13 18:56:02

Am also wondering if non-Scottish folk felt they need subtitles on?

IrnBruTheNoo Mon 11-Mar-13 18:57:48

"if they had real Shetland accents no one would understand a bloody word that was being said"

Probably true JaquelineHyde.

idiot55 Mon 11-Mar-13 21:10:20

how many weegies live in Shetland?

NigellasGuest Mon 11-Mar-13 21:13:28

ooh he's a dirty dog isnt he

NewAtThisMalarky Tue 12-Mar-13 06:41:05

Both the actor that played Sandy and the actress that played Mimie are Shetlanders. Sandy's accent was a very tempered Shetland accent, not broad and he was obviously speaking the script rather than speaking 'properly' Shetland.

There are a lot of weegies in Shetland. But maybe not quite THAT high a percentage!

But it was good fun spotting 'ex's' in the crowd scenes. Two ex-school mates, an ex-colleague, my ex-hairdresser, an ex-neighbour...

diddl Tue 12-Mar-13 08:17:32

Well I enjoyed it overall.

The actress playing Mima-think she was in Local Hero-haven't checked yet.

And Mima's son was in Monarch of the Glen.

TwoIfBySea Tue 12-Mar-13 08:51:22

There's another thread about this which is so ott snobby about "needing subtitles" over the fact it dared to have Scots accents in a Scots drama. Like we haven't had to deal with Eastenders and all the English regional accents all these years? Hmmn. hmm They should've set it in Aberdeen and had the whole thing in Doric - ha! That would have had them going.

Anyway I quite liked it blush , quite liked Mayday too though and am waiting to have all Broadchurch episodes before watching. Perfect fodder for the evening I'd have thought. Shetland looked beautiful!

IrnBruTheNoo Tue 12-Mar-13 09:12:48

Some of the cast had that River City look about one else think that? Or just me?

Yes, overall, it was a brilliant two parter. Enjoyed it more than I thought I would, so that's a bonus!

IrnBruTheNoo Tue 12-Mar-13 09:14:31

I personally didn't need subtitles as I'm Scottish, but was wondering how the rest of the UK felt about watching this drama as it's fairly broad the language.

valiumredhead Tue 12-Mar-13 09:29:23

I didn't like it but anyone needing subtitles shouldn't be allowed out to the shops on their own. Honestly, how ridiculous!

ShatnersBassoon Tue 12-Mar-13 09:33:32

I was fine understanding the accents, and I'm one of those that had to have the subtitles on for the first couple of episodes of The Wire until my ears had tuned in. I thought they all had lovely clear speaking voices, it was just a pity that the plot was a bit dull and plodding.

Horsemad Tue 12-Mar-13 13:13:52

I loved the accents and had no problem understanding them!
Been busy Googling Shetland - want to visit smile

DonkeysDontRideBicycles Tue 12-Mar-13 13:20:50

There was another thread somewhere on MN about this, I know it got off to a slow start but I liked it. Sounds as if not having read the books beforehand was an advantage since people seem disappointed by plot twists and the choice of actor to play the lead. (If Jimmy's ancestor came onshore from the Armada that was centuries' ago, why would he necessarily be dark and Spanish looking?).

Anyway! hope they make some more, made a lovely change to see that part of the world, live in Scotland so didn't find the accents a problem, (thank goodness no broad Aberdonian accents I'd have used subtitles).

guineapiglet Tue 12-Mar-13 13:41:39

Hi - we all watched it and thought it was really atmospheric, and like others on here, are quite tempted to book a visit, even though we are literally at the other end of the British Isles - it all looked rugged, peaceful and remote, and really beautiful. The story was watchable, loved the community they lived in for its closeness and sense of identity,, certainly better drama than others on recently - we have all got used to NCIS and CSI, so it is good to watch things at a slower, more human pace, lets hope it has given the Tourist Board there a boost!

Im totally obsessed with Shetland and LOVE the books. But sadly I didnt enjoy the drama at all. The scenery was good, but otherwise it was slow, unengaging and barely resembled the book at all. sad

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now