Book Adaptations with completely different endings??!!

(15 Posts)
HappinessLivesHere Wed 15-Jun-16 18:34:45

Just watched an 'Adaptation' of Dorothy Koomson's The Ice Cream Girls and they changed the killer!! Wtaf?!

jay55 Thu 16-Jun-16 12:12:22

What?? Wasn't that the whole payoff of the book?

Adventuregame Thu 16-Jun-16 12:49:45

My Sister's Keeper was the worst change I've seen !!

Clawdy Thu 16-Jun-16 20:41:20

Hated the end of A Room With A View, the tv adaptation, where they decided that instead of the more upbeat ending in the book, they would kill off one of the characters.

EverySongbirdSays Fri 17-Jun-16 01:37:24

I hate this too - though I can only think of films

They did mess about with Case Histories a fair bit when that was on.

Gone Girl
Captain Corelli

houseeveryweekend Fri 17-Jun-16 01:43:06

The Painted Veil.
The Beach.
STOP ADDING A LOVE STORY JUST FOR THE SAKE OF IT!
Crash.
High Fidelity.
STOP SETTING BRITISH THINGS IN AMERICA!

houseeveryweekend Fri 17-Jun-16 01:45:56

We Need To Talk About Kevin. The murders at the end were so vividly described in the book including the position of the bodies and it was really distressing... but in the film they arent in those positions!! That annoyed me because i found it one of the most effecting bits of the book.

HappinessLivesHere Fri 17-Jun-16 15:48:56

I don't get! It just ruins everything. The ending of The Ice cream Girls came within minutes of proving the correct killer then out of the blue revealed it to be Serena's mother not Marlene!! Same with My Sisters Keeper when they changed which sister died. So infuriating!

Mivery Fri 17-Jun-16 18:43:21

It defeats the purpose of even adapting a book at all. Why not just tell a new story?

Angelto5 Fri 17-Jun-16 18:51:15

Jaw is one I remember but it wasn't the ending.
In the book Hooper (Richard Dreyfus) has an affair with chief Brody's wife.

MadameMayberry Tue 21-Jun-16 06:21:08

I preferred the film ending of Charlotte Grey to the book. Though I was going out with a French man st the time which might have made me a bit bias...

JudyCoolibar Tue 21-Jun-16 07:55:40

No, the film Charlotte Gray ending is just wrong wrong wrong.

Werksallhourz Tue 21-Jun-16 07:58:17

Worse one is the I am Legend film with Will Smith. They completely changed the ending, when the original ending creates the whole meaning of the book.

Clawdy Tue 21-Jun-16 09:42:27

The tv version of Life and Loves of a She Devil was very close to the book. The film version was a complete travesty, turning a dark and thought-provoking story into a slapstick comedy starring Roseanne Barr.

MistyMeena Tue 21-Jun-16 09:45:43

I hate this with a passion. So many films ruined by changing the ending from the book. Don't even get me started on Charlie & the Chocolate Factory grin

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now