ON BENEFITS AND PROUD - 9PM CH5

(19 Posts)
Blondeshavemorefun Mon 14-Oct-13 16:28:16

Documentary examining the lifestyles of some of those living on benefits who are not currently seeking employment, including a Gloucestershire mother-of-11 who receives benefits equivalent to three times the typical UK family income. Also featured are a Liverpool couple who have not worked for six years, and two single mums in Camden whose rents are more than £1,200 a month each and are paid by the state

I HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH PEOPLE CLAIMING BENIFITS, BUT I DO FEEL THAT THEY SHOULD SEEK WORK IF THEY CAN

to me 11 children and not working is taking the piss, and over a £1k a month in rent is silly - move them to a cheaper (tho nice) area

sits back and waits for fireworks

GobbySadcase Mon 14-Oct-13 16:31:15

More propaganda.

Over 11,000 people found 'fit for work' have died in the past two years whilst some masturbate over 'getting rid of scroungers'.

Makes me sick. Programmes like this increase the hatred towards my family and actively makes my life harder as a carer.

So enjoy, won't you? Knowing that your 'entertainment' is making life miserable for thousands of carers like me who save the taxpayer billions of pounds a year?

that won't be the case any longer with the caps. re the rent.

and I'm pretty sure they have picked the ruffest of the bunch so will just end up being another dig at people that are on benefits. majority of people I know who claim benefits are ashamed to do so because of this stigma that anyone who does is shit. which isn't the case people fall on hard times. could happen to any of us.

I'm v

gamerchick Mon 14-Oct-13 16:33:41

I actually feel fear when any of these programs are aired. I wonder what horrible thing the government have lined up next for people.

posted to soon.

I'm actually very glad we have a benefits system to help those in need.

aturtlenamedmack Mon 14-Oct-13 16:35:15

Will not be watching - this is a beyond vile concept.
The production company should be ashamed of themselves for profiteering from other peoples misery in such an appalling way.

Blondeshavemorefun Mon 14-Oct-13 16:40:36

if you note, I said I have no problem in people claiming benefits but if they can to seek work

those who have /need/are carers/have children or those with sn should be exempt

obv every case if different and should be judged on their circumstances

im talking about those on benefits who don't want to find a job, and in some cases I understand why as they would be worse off working - and fair enough earning nmw of think £6.20ish ph hour for work is awful and without help they cant afford to pay their rent/bills/eat etc if they come off benefits

have always said government needs to up nmw to least £8gross and up wtc to help those who do work - if they are capable

gamerchick Mon 14-Oct-13 16:45:43

shakes head* what's the fucking point?!

aturtlenamedmack Mon 14-Oct-13 16:54:14

This tv program is going to show incredibly atypical examples of people on benefits.
It is not going to give you any true or real representation of the benefits systems, the people who claim benefits or what life is like for those who are reliant upon the state.
It is not designed to be informative, it is designed to be shocking and entertaining.
If welfare is a subject that interests you, I really don't think that this is the right place to get your information from.
There are a million programs, books, articles, blogs and websites that would give you a better idea of the reality of the situation.

MurderOfBanshees Mon 14-Oct-13 16:56:24

Well this is going to be a balanced and fair representation of the lives of hundreds of people on benefits isn't it? I'm sure it's not at all going to be shock TV designed specifically to cast people on benefits in a bad light. Totally impartial and factual I bet.

Hah

Hah

Hah

Ha

Blondeshavemorefun Mon 14-Oct-13 17:04:49

this is true murder

blondes shuffles off with head in disgrace

tbh when I posted the thread I should have known wouldn't be those who need benefits

but as you said tv entertainment sad

tv never shows anyone in a good light whether those on benefits or those on a hen weekend (was on that thread earlier) and I even said obv wont be shown in good light

but im not a person who bashes people on benefits, those who need them iyswim

GobbySadcase Mon 14-Oct-13 17:21:05

But OP don't you see it doesn't matter what YOU think is 'Deserving', the government blithely say their benefit cuts don't affect disabled families so get voter approval. It's lies, of course.

1. Cut in disabled child premium of tax credits
2. 1% increases on income support (carers don't get enough to live on so have to claim)
3. Bedroom tax
4. Council tax benefit

scarlettsmummy2 Mon 14-Oct-13 18:03:32

They probably aren't looking for work as they are I would guess virtually unemployable. That is the reality. There are a certain percentage of the long term unemployed who will NEVER work as they simply have to many barriers to employment.

BurlyShassey Mon 14-Oct-13 18:34:47

I understand what ops saying.

Im on benefits. Im disabled and im also a fulltime carer for a disabled child. i cant go out and earn a wage.

between carers/income support/housing ben/dla i have shit left over after food and bills etc.

These programmes and these people just give an even worse reputation to those of us that NEED it.

BurlyShassey Mon 14-Oct-13 18:36:02

What gobbys saying yy

SugarMouse1 Tue 15-Oct-13 20:46:19

I havé mixed views

Sophie and Emma seem quite typical

Obviously Heather frost is just one extreme example

Unsure about family in Liverpool, they made out they had hardly any money, but spent âgés choosing à sky package. Hmmmm....

TinaThistle Wed 16-Oct-13 00:19:35

What is the point of this program if not to stir resentment and sneer at the poor? If anyone give the slightest toss about actual facts anymore:

UK welfare bill: 42.3% elderly, 20.8% low income, 18.4% families, 15.5% sick/disabled, 2.6% unemployed.

That's right, 2.6% of the welfare budget goes on the unemployed and only a fraction of a percent is "wasted" on illegal claims

Benefit fraud costs around £1.2 bn a year. Tax avoidance cost £25bn.

Where are all the TV shows and relentless headlines vilifying the tax avoiders?

This is just nasty TV influenced by the worse kind of knee-jerk politics.

kateyjayne1987 Thu 17-Oct-13 01:24:14

Omg can't believe that I watched that. I am on income support myself and it made me feel sick.

People like that do give people on benefits a bad name, a very bad name. It disgusted me.

I have 3 kids, im on income support as a single parent, everypenny I get goes on supporting my children and making sure there well looked after. After paying all my household bills (gas, electric etc) I hardly have any money left over never mind getting sky put on in my house. And was it me or has that woman been on Jeremy Kyle quite a few times. is she just desperate for any chance she can get to get on Tele.

I have been looking for work near enough everyday and trying to find the right one to support my kids is difficult, but for her to say she wants £500 left over a week is just taking the mick is she in a dream world.

What tv producer a should be doing is a show for people who are on benefits and physicaly looking for work whilst still trying to do there best to support their families. Just to show the UK that we are all not drunks or scroungers but actually want to better ourselves.

DO NOT LABEL US ALL LIKE THAT SOME OF US ARE GOOD

aturtlenamedmack Thu 17-Oct-13 08:40:42

katy the reason that they don't do that is because they aren't interested in the reality of the situation - it doesn't make good tv.
They are interested in finding the most atypical cases that they can an exploiting them. That's what makes shocking tv and that's what makes them the moat money.
They don't care who they tar with the same brush.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now