which one? Silent witness or above suspciion?

(33 Posts)
amylou Mon 03-Jan-11 20:31:57

Which do you think will be the best to watch? there's no point in recording anything as I never get time to watch it and both carry on tomorrow night..
which one will you watch?

Flossie69 Mon 03-Jan-11 21:14:59

I am watching Silent Witness, but it is very upsetting about the little girl.

The other thread is a bit obvious - the consultant did it?

TreacleOfComfortAndJoy Mon 03-Jan-11 21:15:46

Silent Witness! Always!

Flossie69 Mon 03-Jan-11 22:12:03

OK, so now I think its the daughter........

kylesmybaby Tue 04-Jan-11 14:31:07

i couldn't decide so wanted to tape one and watch the other. however, earlier in the day i plugged the sky/tv out. stayed at funfair later than we should and so i missed the beginning of both of them. was soo gutted when i returned home at 9.30pm... i really need to get out more !! lol

diddl Tue 04-Jan-11 16:35:03

I went for SW.

I think AS will be on ITV3 soon.

Also thought it might be daughter-because she saw her father being upset with them?

The nurse-did she hang herself?

Has this one been on before-or something similar?

Monadami Tue 04-Jan-11 17:29:59

I always find Above Suspicion riveting and seemilgly realistic. I use to like Silent Witness when it first started.

TreacleOfComfortAndJoy Tue 04-Jan-11 18:28:09

No, it's a new series. Don't think we know if the nurse hanged herself or not yet... but not long to go til we find out!

Kyles, SW will be on iPlayer if you've got a computer to watch it on.

Flisspaps Tue 04-Jan-11 18:35:58

I recorded both but prefer Silent Witness. The last Above Suspicion I saw got on my tits a bit, too much pouting and looking 'little girl lost', but it's better than the drivel that's on in the day.

diddl Tue 04-Jan-11 19:03:43

"No, it's a new series."

I thought it was, but it seems familiar.

I think I watch so much of this type of thing I´m almost bound to have seen a similar storyline on somethingblush

TreacleOfComfortAndJoy Tue 04-Jan-11 19:11:12

Well, it is something ridiculous like the 14th series of SW...

diddl Tue 04-Jan-11 19:28:01

"I always find Above Suspicion riveting and seemilgly realistic."

I saw the 1st(?) one, with Jason Durr & thought it was ridiculous & predictable, so haven´t bothered with others.

Shame as I was looking forward to it.

Numberfour Tue 04-Jan-11 19:32:40

SW definitely

I agree about the pouty pouty thing in AS. Drives me mental.

Oh no no no no
SW has lost all credibility
And Emilia Fox character going cracker jack
Much prefer that gorgeous red-head on ITV, DI TRavers envy

agedknees Tue 04-Jan-11 20:38:40

The room the nurse was found hanging was locked from the inside, so nurse must have hung herself?

Nurse said Dr. Silverman came to see the patients, but the consultant was Prof Silverman. Very conscious of titles in the medical world, so maybe it was the daughter? Is she a doctor too?

Ah, its a great life in St. Mary Mead. So much going on.

CDMforever Tue 04-Jan-11 20:47:44

LOVE silent witness!!
Especially emilia fox's clothes, all those floaty blouses and ridiculously high heeled red shoes - perfect for her job methinks....
Have nikki and tom ever been an item in a previous series? If not why not?
Going to put kettle on for part 2!

Will concede, Emilia Fox's wardrobe is highly covetable.

CDMforever Tue 04-Jan-11 20:52:51

Wonder where she gets the aforementioned blouses. I would look like a ship in full sail in one tho, tee hee!

unfortuantely i chose above suspicion
and it is so crap

is it always this crappy?

i'm on AS
Quite like LLP

whos llp?

the red headed woman is so stroppy

I like her
She has inchooition

llp=lynda la plante

She knows how to write a police drama-but usually fairly formulaic

Flossie69 Tue 04-Jan-11 22:01:01

Never mind Nikki's clothes, her flat is gorgeous!

diddl Tue 04-Jan-11 22:01:40

Forgot to say yesterday about the prescription & father & daughter having the same initial.

CDMforever Wed 05-Jan-11 18:10:31

Loved SW's finale. Knew the daughter was involved but couldn't figure out how. Fab ending, thought they might allow Nikki a little smile at cutting open the Child Murderer...but they didn't!
Yes I also love her flat. Wish I had taste like that.

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now