Bobbi Brown gel eyeliner or Badgal liner?

[laughterlines]

I have both which were given as presents although both are unopened and unused. I was thinking about ebaying one of them as could do with some spare cash at the moment but not sure which one.

I have read about Bobbi Brown gel liners drying up quickly. I have a duo pack of brown and black.

I don't mind a gel or a kohl liner, just after some opinions.

[Bobbiewickham]

I've got both of these.

Bobbi Brown gel is good for more precise lines. Stays put all day, really nice, but a faff with the little brush etc.

Bad gal liner better for smoky eyes, goes on really well. It's the one I use most, tbh.

[RocheMoutonee]

ah that is interesting BW
i like the gel one but its not aneveryday one for me as its quite defined.

my fave is eliz arden doublewear

[Bobbiewickham]

Bad Gal eyeliner much better than Bad Gal mascara, which flakes off something wicked.

[laughterlines]

Thanks for your replies although it's really not helping as now I think I will have to keep both

Do you find the gel dries out quickly?

[Bobbiewickham]

Not so far.

[RocheMoutonee]

no