Beauty guru's - in need of a decent navy liquid eyeliner - any suggestions?

(6 Posts)
SpeakerOfTheHouse Fri 16-Sep-16 15:04:16

Used No 7 for years and they've just changed the formula & its now crap. Bought a Lancome one this week and that comes off within a few hours. need a navy waterproof one which stays on all day - any suggestions oh wonderful beauty gurus of MN?

SharonBottsPoundOfGrapes Fri 16-Sep-16 15:52:43

If £17 isn't too dear then Two faced sketch is brilliant. I have oily eyelids and this doesn't shift. (Unless you cleanse). I have the navy one and it is lovely. I had vouchers but even then I winced. However it really is good. I also recommend better than sex mascara. I got one free in my beauty box. They compliment each other very nicely.

jasmine1979 Fri 16-Sep-16 15:55:21

I love navy eyeliner. smile
My fave liquid ones are
Stila stay all day - they do one called "navy" but also a few other dark blue shades that are lovely. It really does stay all day.
Kat von d - www.debenhams.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/prod_10701_10001_123016002499?CMP=SSH&tmcampid=28&tmad=c&sku=8337670&placmp=SSH__659023410_41828745988&mkwid=sjtIG344u%7cpcrid%7c137990882812%7cpkw%7c%7cpmt%7c%7cpdv%7cc%7cprd%7c8337670&gclid=Cj0KEQjwsO6-BRDRy8bsxfiV2bkBEiQAF8EzKCI26AlRUyHveqRJJW4H7TPLSfZpMWJ1-x0yW3Usuz8aAu9-8P8HAQ
Eyeko skinny eyeliner (although I think they may have changed the forumla of this one recently and it's staying power isn't as good?)

Allibear Fri 16-Sep-16 15:57:59

If it's crap take the Lancôme one back op! They have really good customer service, when I worked for them we were encouraged to give refunds for products that don't work. I second the Stila stay all day, it's great but if you're looking for something cheaper the collection 24hr liner is great too smile

Germgirl Fri 16-Sep-16 16:02:51

I know Nyx (in a lot of Boots shops now) do lots of different coloured liquid eyeliners. I have a lovely purple one. I don't know if they have a navy one but its worth a look. You can order on the Boots website for pickup tomorrow.
I love Nyx makeup. It's cheap and great quality.

SpeakerOfTheHouse Fri 16-Sep-16 17:20:33

Ooh thanks everyone, I knew you wouldn't let me down! Will try them all till I find my holy grail again ;)

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now