P20 or alternatives

(33 Posts)
CutYourHairAndGetAJob Sun 10-Apr-16 10:47:35

Hi, it's April so time for me and my ginger family to start covering ourselves head to toe in factor 50 wink

Last year we discovered p20 which is brilliant - easy to apply to a wriggly toddler, lasts all day etc. However it is quite £££. Has anyone seen it on offer or know of any cheaper alternatives?

Thanks

MrsHerculePoirot Sun 10-Apr-16 10:53:59

We use the piz buin all day (8 hour) one - no idea if cheaper but usually I stock up when they have buy one get one free around now sometime for the summer.

MrsT2007 Sun 10-Apr-16 12:21:00

P20 is evil stuff please don't use it.

My dermatologist reckons it should be banned.

It put me in hospital and as a result I'm now allergic to 99% of sunscreens, so in sensitive skins it's just a no no.

chipsandpeas Sun 10-Apr-16 12:24:10

i like calypso once a day sun cream, i use this on holidays can get it in home bargains

have used ultrasun as well but its pricey as wel

Ktay Sun 10-Apr-16 12:26:30

Are you near a waitrose? They are doing 3 for 2 on beauty products, which I think includes sunscreens.

Ktay Sun 10-Apr-16 12:27:01

They have ultrasun and I think P20 (notwithstanding comment above)

Madbengalmum Sun 10-Apr-16 12:28:35

P20 is full of pretty nasty stuff isn' t it?
Was told that the reason they didnt sell it in Boots for years was due to the harmful ingredients.
Ladvial is a viable alternative.

Ifonlyiweretaller Sun 10-Apr-16 12:30:29

I'm interested to know why P20 is evil.I have used it for years to prevent sunburn, as have my (now grown up) children.
What is so bad about it please Mrs T?

Madbengalmum Sun 10-Apr-16 12:32:59

I believe it is some sort of binding ingredient, but i stand corrected.

MarvellousCake Sun 10-Apr-16 14:49:29

Ultrasun is the best. Wouldn't use anything else now. Pricey, mind. Last bottle I got was from M&S with a 20% off code.

member Sun 10-Apr-16 14:54:01

We had no issues with P20 re skin/protection but it did create a very yellowy oil slick in the pool blush

Madbengalmum Sun 10-Apr-16 15:00:25

It is not about whether p20 gives any issues,more about the nasty things it contains that you are adding to your skin.
It stains clothes yellow also.

SingToMeInFrench Sun 10-Apr-16 15:11:07

Ultrasun! It's great. Pricey but you can get good deals on QVC or online

scrappydappydoo Sun 10-Apr-16 15:14:43

We use ultrasun. We did use the boots all day one but it was horrid really thick and wouldn't rub in. We then switched to piz buin which was OK but stained clothes we then discovered ultrasun and haven't brought anything else since. Me and dc use the lotion and dh uses the sport version as he's v hairy and it doesn't get all in a mess like the lotion (sorry for that image). It's on offer with ocado at the moment.

Kirriemuir Sun 10-Apr-16 15:57:17

Ultrasun.

MrsT2007 Sun 10-Apr-16 17:03:36

I used p20 for a week no issues. So before a school field trip I bought more for exactly those 'won't need to reapply' reasons.

I used it & I had a HUGE reaction where it's been applied and sun exposed. The treatment involved A&E in the end, taking steroid tablets and massive antihistamine doses. Five days in, steroid dose reduced, & it flared up massively again.

This continues for a month as p20 chemically binds to your skin. So your skin cannot get rid of what it's trying to react to and your body keeps on reacting more and more.

I basically had chemical burns as the reaction is photosensitive and any daylight made it worse and worse.

Dermatologist tests revealed I am now spectacularly allergic to all chemical sunscreens. This is mainly because my body produced more and more reaction to a chemical it couldn't get rid of.

My arms are permanently marked where I had the reaction, as is my neck. In the summer it comes up redder than other areas.

So yes, I reckon it's pretty vile stuff.

Ultra sun I can't use but it is good. I use SunSense sensitive. Great on reactive skins and kids, and no chemical sunscreens. Also like the green people organic kids one.

notapizzaeater Sun 10-Apr-16 17:07:07

We use ultrasun or p20 - whichever is on offer when I buy it. A bottle last DS a year.

Your reaction sounds horrid MrsT :-(

hollinhurst84 Sun 10-Apr-16 17:12:39

It's not a one a day but I like the banana boat spray. Comes in different variations of waterproof, sensitive and different factors
It's an aerosol spray so no rubbing in and I've never burnt with it (redhead, faint shade of blue)
I don't have DC but recommended it to a friend who likes the fact you can spray it on a toddler that's legging it from you

hollinhurst84 Sun 10-Apr-16 17:14:01

Link to their website
http://www.bananaboat.co.uk/ultramisttheanywhichway_spray.html

CutYourHairAndGetAJob Sun 10-Apr-16 19:11:35

Thanks all

That sounds awful MrsT

I don't have a Waitrose nearby but I could do an ocado online shop and get some ultrasun. I really need the once a day stuff because I always forget to reapply blush

Hulababy Sun 10-Apr-16 19:23:10

Me and DH use P20 with no problems at all. Never reacted to it in the slightest and never burned with it either.

DD uses UltraSun as she doesn't like the oil formula of P20.

She doesn't use many other forms as she reacts to many other brands, including other brand once a days.

So yes, they are expensive - but for us it is worth it as they have worked for us.

Hulababy Sun 10-Apr-16 19:25:19

The newer formula of P20 doesn't stain in the same way - they changed the formula. I wore a new white dress a couple of times on my recent holiday, after using P20 - no staining on it at all.

Hulababy Sun 10-Apr-16 19:27:32

Your reaction to the suncream sounds really horrid MrsT.

DD reacts to a lot of suncreams but luckily never as bad as that. We have now eliminated any that she reacts too as I read that reactions can become worse with time.

Ultra sun, and many once a days, bind to the skin I believe. Must be the way some of them work I guess. DD much prefers UltraSun though.

CutYourHairAndGetAJob Sun 10-Apr-16 19:35:32

Wow the ultrasun is pricey, even on offer. I don't think I can afford that on maternity leave. I will try the Calypso instead as it is cheaper, they have some on Amazon for £6 if anyone else is looking

SuckingEggs Sun 10-Apr-16 19:41:23

Does Ultrasun go on clear or leave a white tinge?

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now